Best Steak Sandwich in Menasha

2 restaurant menus in Menasha, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
The Old Grog
The Old Grog
93/100 (736 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
Pub
Bar
Pub
American
American
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Steak Sandwich
Sit down
Bar
Pub
American
Wine and Beer
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Television
Street Parking
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Mid-range
"Had a great meal for supper! I had the hot beef sandwich/w pickles and horseradish on the side. My hubby had the chicken tenders, tossed in hot..."
Amy Rappert
"Stopped to meet with a friend. Great atmosphere, great bartender. I ordered a prime rib sandwich. It was delicious, but lost a star on how incredibly..."
Melanie Reinl
"Love this place!! The prices are amazing. The check was so low, I thought they made a mistake. The specials are great. The beef tips were done..."
Tony Mostek
"We have lunch or dinner at The Grog at LEAST one time a week ... cheeseburger and fries on Monday, boneless wings on Tuesday, steak sandwich on..."
Zack Wheeler
"WOW! Is what I have to say about Mondays burger special...Super good deal. If you haven't tried this yet you're missing out. Good folks, food,..."
CZSQ QSZC
"A quaint hidden gem located in a Menasha neighborhood. GREAT FOOD, cold beer, great prices and very friendly staff. Daily specials that are..."
Sarah P
"We had the baked haddock and it was very..."
janice immekus
"4-10-2022 went there today and got their Sunday chicken dinner..4 Pieces of chicken, mashed potatoes and gravy, stuffing, cranberry and a dinner..."
Deb Scovronske
Mihm's Charcoal Grill
Mihm's Charcoal Grill
90/100 (2480 ratings)
Restaurants
Diner
American
Dinner
Lunch
Melted Butter
Hamburgers
Cheeseburger with Butter
Top Ground Sirloin Smothered in Butter
Chili
Reuben Fries
Ground Steak Sandwich with Cheese
Steak Sandwich
Sirloin Burger with Cheese and All the Things
Burger Ever
Quart of Chicken Dumpling Soup
Double Cheeseburger and Fries
Steak Burger with Fried Cheese Curds
Vanilla Malt
Fresh Fries and Cheese Curds
Cheese Curds and Onion Rings
Cheeseburger & Onion Rings
Hamburger
Pepsi Products
Double Steak Burger with Cheese
Deep Fried Green Beans
Pie Shake
Butter Burger with Cheese
Burger
"Best little hidden diner!. Absolutely love going here! This place puts the butter in butter burger. 100% suggest as a must try. Be expecting a dinky..."
Facebook User
"Best burger you will ever have in your entire life! The search is..."
Brooke
"Excellent burgers and the waitstaff is always friendly!!! You won't be..."
Ryan Miller
"Menasha's Best Burger. I live in Florida and have been eating Mihm's burgers for 40 years. I always make a stop every time I'm visiting family. Great..."
Ted Ciske
"Great small town atmosphere. One of the few places that I have ever gone that grills there burgers on a charcoal grill. Great food at a cheap..."
Mike
"Best burger for the price so far. Wasn't the best burger ever but very good for the money. I was pretty impressed over fast food options. I would..."
Disraili Gammons
"Chopped sirloin burgers that melt in your mouth. Get extra butter on that burger!Homey kind of diner with old school vibe. Unfortunately they are..."
Bob Minter
"Very good burgers. I love the food, and the people are great. Friendly staff and very clean place. Not very big but still very nice and comfortable..."
JohnCurrent4
"A staple of the Fox Cities, if you haven't been here you need to stop. Everything on the menu is great. Fair warning: they use lots of butter when..."
Dan Braun
"Delicious steak Sandwich with a sampling of deep fried additions. I had a chocolate shake and my friend chose pie. It's a hidden gem in the city and..."
Deb Leonard
"It will be so sad to see this place go but after 65 years of being absolute legends what more could you hope for? It will be hard to express..."
Ryan Vaughan
"Food is priced well but it adds up after a couple of soft drinks. The burgers are delicious and cooked over an open charcoal flame. I'd give a 5 star..."
Travis Antone
"As soon as I walked in it felt like a back yard BBQ we ordered are food and the service was fast and great food was amazing. If you are looking for..."
Talia Krause