Of all of the delis for which I got recommendations, Taliercio’s was arguably the most popular. And as soon as I walked in, it all made sense.
It took me a good 5-10 minutes to soak in everything on the menu on top of the deli counter. A guy, who introduced himself as Mike, asked if I needed help (I said yes) and then asked if I saw the menus behind me as well, which I hadn’t. There are probably 100 sandwiches to choose from.
With Mikes help, I landed on the Mikey A and the Nonna Murphy. Both sandwiches were delicious. And absolutely massive. The quality was legit, so the size of the sandwich is justified and not just big for the sake of being big.
They are however huge and somewhat difficult to eat. I’d love to come back again for more sandwiches and fried raviolis, which I hear are insane!
Overall, I like Taliercios quite a bit and fully understand why everyone loves this spot.
You honestly can’t go wrong. You get a massive delicious sub for a great price and a dozen fried raviolis, you have an all natural anti depressant that brings you back to life! Great staff too, a true staple to Middletown. Plus, they are huge hockey fans that makes the experience all the better, and this is coming from a Devil fan lol! Thank you!
Gotta say. This spot is top notch. We drove an hour and a half in the pouring rain just for their sandwiches. The fried ravioli and mac salad were ok. You honestly don’t even need them with the sizes of their sandwich. I was also surprised and excited to learn that my 2-3lb sandwich only cost $11. It was our first time so they gave us the raviolis on the house. Can’t wait to go back and try more sandwiches. Pictured: Italian sandwich and Schneider’s cut
Best food I've ever had in my life. Just ate it and still craving it.
Only got takeout and only their sandwiches.
Once on a Sunday and the next on a Tuesday, both before noon. Both times they were crazy busy. Luckily I used the slice app and beat the lines.
If you buy online, you can just walk straight to the register and let someone know you're there to pickup. (Highly recommend)
Huge parking lot, and right off 35, so nice and easy drive.
Below are photos of:
Chicken Parm hero
Taliercios Hero
Sicilian Hero
Italian Hero
Petey C roll
Fried ravioli
This place is the best! The food is incredible, the service is top notch and the prices are absurd. If you don’t get their fried ravioli you’re missing out! Possibly the best sauce i have ever tried!
Finally went here for lunch after wanting to go here for months. I ordered the fried ravioli, trust me get this, and the “Acquitted” sandwich. The fried ravioli was 🔥 filled with ricotta.
The sandwich was phenomenal, something I never tasted before, crunchy, cheesy, spicy, sweet, explosion of flavor.
The sandwich is made of:
Ricotta
Hot stuffed pepper shooters
Chicken cutlets
Prosciutto di Parma
Hot Honey
Locatelli cheese
Black pepper.
The staff is very friendly and makes you feel like family. If you are there for the first time, let them know and they ll give u a warm welcome.
A great spot that I ll def return to.
Heard of lot of good things about this place. They use semolina bread with sesame seeds so I knew I had to try. They have a lot of different options for sandwich’s but I opted to make my own. I got chicken cutlet fresh mozz sundried tomatoes Arugula long hots and onions. Oh my god it was perfect and better then I thought it would come out. The best long hots I have ever had. Very spicy not for the faint of heart. I also tried the fried ravioli. Which I was skeptical at first because it sounds gimmicky but wow was I surprised it was a perfectly fried umami pillow pocket. The outside salty and crispy the inside creamy and rich. Staff very friendly and no wait. Also the prices are very reasonable and the portions are huge. I will go again for lunch later this week.
I came here for the first time and it did NOT disappoint! Staff was amazing keeping us entertained while waiting in line. The place was packed! Everyone very nice. FOOD AMAZING! You could tell as they worked they were having a good time. It was nice to see. Will definitely be returning!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes