Greek cuisine: the best places to taste it in Middletown
7 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"this is my third (3rd) order from this eatery. The food is very consistent. the portions are very generous and I have never felt that it was short..."
TZ Trix
"By far my favorite place to eat in Middletown. I have tried almost the whole menu and have not been disappointed yet. From wraps to soups to salads..."
Chandler Fitzgerald
"the restaurant was very welcoming as soon as i walked in, it smelled amazing in there and the staff were incredibly kind. the food was just amazing...."
riley boyd
"Went to Malena’s for the first time this evening. Our first time having Mediterranean food and definitely not our last. We had the falafel wrap..."
rwkde
"This place is so heartwarming. It feels like your in a family restaurant in the Mediterranean. The customer service is friendly, welcoming ,..."
Kayla Mendez
"Outstanding. I love Middle Eastern food and they did not disappoint. Great food…well..."
Tim C
"Excellent food! Very pleasant service too. Lamb gyro was fantastic...hummus and tzatziki were lovely! Will go back again very..."
Scott Boyd
"Marlena's quite frankly rocks. I have never had anything here that wasnt top shelf to me. Personally I would reccomend the Sujuk wrap or the shwarma..."
"Just moved to this area. Very good food, good sized portions! Very consistent & friendly atmosphere. Food is served quickly. Love the light, crispy..."
Alicja Guziewicz
"Family owned since the early 1970’s. We have been dining here for about 1.5 years because of the Wednesday pasta for two special. I have enough..."
Walter van Dusen
"I drive by this place all the time. I ordered a small pizza with pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, meatball and olives. It was banging! Will definitely..."
Matthew Read
"I just got the most beautiful pizza I have ever laid eyes on. The peppers and onions still had a little bit of crunch, not overcooked to mush like..."
Les P
"A great place to stop for a pizza or a very nice dinner. My wife and I stop in for a Sunday dinner. She had a ravioli dinner and I had stuff..."
Ron Allen
"My first time coming here. The food was absolutely awesome. Nice portions and the pizza was delicious. Will definitely return..."
Sensuous Radiance
"First time here. Ordered pizza to take home - with sausage and sliced meatballs. Very good. Liked the crust - good..."
Linda Young
"Amazing service! Waitress was very friendly and attentive! The food was delicious! A great family experience! The owner even takes the time to greet..."
"When we first walked in one of the guys behind the counter welcomed us and asked if we have ever had a falafel. I have not so he proceeded to give..."
Ashley LeBlanc
"I did the Gyro Plate dish and it was a great choice. The rice was moist and packed with flavor. The sauces were definitely homemade. The gyro meat..."
Joe Meringolo
"Amazing food varieties with lots of goodies inside. We got full on the tasty goodness here. There is usually a line with quite a few military people..."
Rock Jocelyn
"We stopped by International Pocket Cafe on our way back to CT from Newport. It's been a while since I've had some gyros, and both my wife and I..."
Ro Jairam
"The owner of this place makes sure the food is fresh, the servings are reasonable, and the prices are right. I call for a taboule salad, and he even..."
K B
"Great food, great staff, great prices. Definitely check this one out. You won't be..."
Geoff Reynolds
"Great food, huge proportions, good prices, Mexican Cokes. Big..."
"Had the most enjoyable dinner out in quite awhile. Maria is an amazing lady and the food was perfect. Absolutely loved the made from scratch tzatziki..."
Phillip Maddox
"The Best Greek food I had the baked (cod) fish and macaroni Greek style chopped Greek salsa on top and salad. Maria home cooking and fast. Great..."
Theo Sotiroglou
"Patti & I have enjoyed Mary's cooking for many years.Great food good price. We are very fortunate to have such a wonderful establishment in..."
Justin Holweger
"I love anything I get there. My favorite is the Greek burger , but you can’t beat Maria’s chicken noodle soup or rice pudding. And Maria always..."
Cynda Mason Kash
"I've been coming here for the past ten years. Awesome..."
Kenneth Wilburn
"Always excellent food here ! Love this place. One of my favorite local..."
Amie Solem Daudt
"Nice hidden jem!! Always have lunch there when I am working in the area. Always polite..."
Chip Gettle
"Love the chicken salad & rice pudding 👍❤️😊They have a variety of options..."
Marlayne Skeens
"Excellent food that is reasonably priced. Family run business that is very customer..."
Joseph Carl Wellinghoff
"Always delicious! We always get the gyros, waffle fries, and..."
Kara Spicer
"Always had great food from here. Love the gyros! Tzeke is my favorite..."
Courtney A. Redding
"Thank you very much!!!! Greattttt food!!!!
Will definitely comeback next time I’m in the..."
Yianni Zee
"The BEST gyro 🥙 around!!! I love the place and the people are really nice. Nothing like REAL Greek food!..."
Nathan Doller
"Me and three coworkers went and we all loved the food and..."
Tony Wallace
"Great Greek food,clean and nice people and I know being..."
Chris Miltiades
"Best gyros around..."
Donnie Johnson
"I just had them make me a grilled cheese with qyro meat on it and I dipped it in the gyro sauce and it was absolutely incredible! They should put it..."
Jeffrey R Patrick
"Great restaurant off the beaten path. I love the food..."
Jim Mossman
"must stop if you're in Middletown... But know what you're stopping for. The food is very tasty and the people are super friendly and the restaurants..."
James Staubach
"Maria, the owner, just catered a party for me. Pastitsio, Athenian Salad and the wonderful green beans. Empty plates and many compliments! The..."
Christine Cowden
"Found this place by accident driving by and so incredibly happy!!! I'm a transplant here in Ohio from North Jersey and miss good Greek food. The..."
Brad Thumudo
"This was very good. Although I don't recommend the cheese pie but it was also my time having it so maybe I just don't like it. My gyro was very good..."
Jen
"This seemed like a very family oriented place. I called them today, Dec. 24th, to see if they were open. They told me they were, that they had..."
Timothy Goeft
"Locally owned great selection of classic Greek treats. We can always depend on quality and such an inviting family..."
Richard Inman
"The food was fresh and delicious. Best lentil soup I have ever had. And Dimitri made the visit even more..."
Amy Rickel
"We love this place! The food is incredible and very authentic! The staff, especially the owner, are so friendly and hospitable! Thank you for making..."
Robert Wolf
"Authentic & full of flavor. Great value; portions are generous. Friendly atmosphere. Great find! Will..."
Michelle Chavez
"Of course, they know what they are doing. My review is meaningless. Great food..."
smooch guntle
"Simply amazing!! One of my new favorite places to..."
Sadie Perse
"Everything was amazing! Food, staff and even the other customers were friendly as if everyone knew this place was for friends and family..."
Chad Walls
"This is my favorite food in the entire world. It makes my heart sing. The Greek fries are incredible and the Baklava… if I could get the Baklava..."
Travis Rigas
"Always fantastic food with friendly service! A+++
Friday special chicken kabob with pilaf rice &..."
Rebecca C
"Ordered the gyro combination for togo. The Greek lady was super nice enough to make me fresh fries :)
Thank you and your gyro is..."
Woong Ji Kim
"This is some of the most delicious food I've ever eaten. It tastes like your little Greek grandma made you dinner. I ordered the special (grilled..."
"Their gyro platters and salads are superb! And the baklava... YUM! Who would think you could get such Amazing food at a gas station?!?..."
vanessa smith
"Nice place, answered all of our questions with a pleasant smile & demeanor. Food is fantastic. They even have a lovely outdoor seating area. Highly..."
Luis Leon
"All the staff here are so genuinely kind. They answer all my questions with annoyance. Food is killer and very flavorful. Never thought a Greek place..."
Killian Peach
"We had a very enjoyable meal here after a hike to Annapolis Rock. The BoardWalk fries were great. My wife and I had the Gyros - excellent. If you..."
Karl Van Neste
"The food was AMAZING!! I ordered the chicken Souvlaki gyro Athenian style. Only reason why I didn't give 5 stars is because my husband's order was..."
Kaitlyn Masotta
"nice shady table outside, good food friendly..."
Rob Meagley
"Greek food and the setting here is better than most. Good place to catch up with friends. Certainly worth a return..."
Wendy Gonzalez
"Love there food! We have carryout for dinner alot..."
"The food was delicious! Everything tasted fresh and the staff was very friendly. 5 star for..."
Banjo Ex
"This little hidden Gem💎💎💎 on route 211 in Middletown!!! Something for everyone Great choices for Vegan or Non Vegan!!! Definitely wont be..."
matthew ropiecki
"Just found this place because I had a craving for a gyro! The second you walk in the smell is amazing. The menu had so many things I wanted to gyro..."
nina reagan
"Wonderful and exceptional food a unique place in this area. The falafels rank in my top 3, with my other favorites being in Boston and California. ..."
Ed Czeck
"Excellent food! We stopped here on a whim for lunch and it did not disappoint. Gyros were delicious and food came out quickly. Highly recommend for..."
Emma Hartke
"Just found this little gem today! Wish we would've known about it sooner! Food was fresh, delicious and staff friendly. If you're in the mood for..."
Amanda M
"Falafel Mediterranean style joint on 211 is tasty and quick.
Quality fast food healthier than traditional fast food places.
Gyros were really good..."
"In keeping with a long standing tradition, I had the opportunity to join the happiest group of people I have ever known, who all share a meal..."
Colby
"Classic looking and feeling diner. Huge menu and everything we had was delicious. Nice serving sizes as well. Service was a little slow and the..."
Dan Fields
"Great variety of food! The omelet and sweet potato fries were excellent, and the chocolate chip pancakes were good too. The service is always great..."
Shirah Mark
"Coming from Florida here and was amazed by there tasty home fries and the wonderfully done challah French toast. Would come here again for..."
jose rodriguez
"We were in Middletown, CT., a few days ago and thought we’d catch a bite at the Athenian II Diner Restaurant. Even though they offer a great..."
Marie Leighton
"A few friends and I came by after searching around for a bit. We were greeted by a polite lady at the front and sent to dine immediately after. Our..."
Angel Rodriguez
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes