Reviews Transfer Pizzeria Cafe

This place is the real deal. Not only do they offer a lot of variety, but they do it very well. The crust on their pizza is exceptional. It has a good structure that holds the weight of the toppings well. It is crisp on the outside and soft and tender on the inside. The flavors are great here and very well balanced. We tried their dill pizza and it had great flavor all around. The pickles added some crunch and acidity, the bacon added some salt, and the fresh dill helped brighten up the pizza and introduce some freshness to it. Our table agreed it was a great pizza, but we definitely couldn’t eat one in its entirety just because how rich and strong it is. I don’t mean this in a bad way at all. It’s just a warning to those who love pickles like we do that it might be best to split this pizza with some others! The star of the show was their special “The Radical” which had goat cheese, beets, parsnips, carrots and fresh sage. The veggies were cut to the perfect thickness that it didn’t weigh down the pizza or make it soggy. They were cooked just enough to have a bite to them but not mushy and the presentation itself was very nice. We had really great service too. The lady who greeted us was very nice and our server Mike was friendly and was great at anticipating our needs. We went during a slow time but I can imagine the atmosphere here is really awesome when it’s busy. There’s lots of seating inside and a bar with some diner stools if you prefer to do that instead. The decor was cool. It’s a very inviting place and the people that work here add to that. It’s hard to fault anything here and I very much look forward to trying it again.

Hands down one of my favorite comfort pizza places in Milwaukee. Having been coming here for years and have had consistently great food and great service. Food if always fresh and flavorful and staff is always very friendly and attentive. I've dined here for birthdays, for date nights, ate at the bar, done take out and I don't think ever once had a bad experience here. My favorite thing is the chicken potato pizza (add bacon), it does not disappoint!

Make reservations, it's not a large establishment, the service was great as well as the pizza. Theirs small, which is a personal size and a large, not sure how big that is, no medium size for pizza.

We ordered takeout, and it was a complex order placed on a Thanksgiving weekend a little over half an hour before we'd be there and yet it was ready in a reasonable amount of time. We didn't have to wait long and they brought the pizzas out to the car in the snow. No mistakes, perfectly executed order, and great quality pies, as always. Transfer is a level above the rest. Always a pleasure visiting Transfer.

We had Grant as our server and he made a gloomy December day in Milwaukee a little brighter for us. Food was great, bloody mary nice and horseradish forward. I love the original architectural details like the headers and original stained glass.

Customer service is always friendly and professional. The pizza is the best New York style in Milwaukee. I recommend the Garlic Lovers, the ingredients are fresh and they add more than enough toppings on your personal pizza (add spicy sausage and green olives). The historic features are amazing from the stained glass to the wood work with the exposed wood beams overhead. My only recommendations are to serve your sangria and wine in wine glasses instead of pints. Also, change the interior green paint on the west wall to match the stained glass and change the dark grey on the south wall to a light grey that matches the tiles instead of the grout. Leave the dark grey in the bathroom hall and paint the bathroom doors to make them concealed. Highly recommend Transfer for date night, families, or take out. Best pizza in town.

I first rated this 5 years ago (its now 2023), and the rating still stands. The 9" personal pizza is perfect for a lunch or dinner. I always get a "make your own", chicken, bacon, jalapeno, with a side of their garlic sauce. You actually float to heaven for about 30 min while you enjoy the food.

Definitely one of my favorite places for pizza. Enjoy their lunch special with coworkers. It’s always easy to talk to them into taking a lunch at Transfer. I always want to take pictures of the food but there’s just no time. You’re there to eat and enjoy. Also the employees are the best. Helpful fast and courteous.