Best Steak Sandwich in Milwaukee

4 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Balistreri's Bluemound Inn
Balistreri's Bluemound Inn
86/100 (2350 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Lasagne
Pesto
Caprese Salad
Fish
Mediterranean Pizza
Onion rings
The Works Pizza
Lasagna
Tiramisú
Garlic bread
Bread Pudding
Lamb Shank
Steak Sandwich
Baked potato
Chicken Parmesan
Beef Tips
Shrimp
Walleye
Eggplant Fries
Pasta Balistreri
Eggplant
Veal Scallopini Parmesan
Pasta
Fried Eggplant Strips
Salad
Alla Parmesan
Linz Heritage Reserve Prime Rib
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Takeout
Television
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"This Bluemound Road staple is great, from the bar where the bartenders can make good Martinis to the kitchen where they make great food. I recommend..."
Kevin Culver
"We were at the 68th street location. The best thin crust pizza. We ordered a large for the 3 of us so we could take some home. Fried eggplant and..."
Sue Kraus
"Went last night with family and had prompt service, great wine, and amazing lasagna. Whenever we stop through the food has always been excellent. Try..."
Danielle Romain Dagenhardt
"This is one of our favorite places to eat! Service is excellent! We love Natalie, Rhonda, GiGi and Antonio and great bartenders Dave, Phil and of..."
Kathleen Dagenhardt
"What a great place, atmosphere, service and excellent food. 6 of us shared the house salad, eggplant and a large pizza. Thoroughly enjoyed it all. ..."
Liz Gaengel
"Our meal was beyond spectacular and our waiter Antonio was excellent. Thank you for a great meal and experience. Can't wait to come..."
June Prestin
"Becca served Mom and I. She was absolutely the CSO-Chief Service Officer! Mom needed a pick-me-up so we decided to pop in for sweets. Mom ordred the..."
Mary Perry
"I think I found my new place to have a relaxing dinner with great service and incredible food !!! 5 stars..."
Brad Jancarik
"What a top notch restaurant. Excellent staff, atmosphere, and an extensive menu. Everything our group tried was..."
Debbie Jacobs
"Found the place late evening (10:00pm) via reviews after a long day of exploring Milwaukee and we couldn't have been happier with the place, old..."
Kevin LaBarr
"Went late night and had pizza and Martinis... Awesome server Anthony as well as the best Pizza and Martinis I’ve had in a long time... very clean..."
Carmen Wanzo
"Food was terrific and great service. Will definately be back. Highly recommend making a reservation as they are very..."
Mindi Wamser Zenisek
"I had the tenderloin steak sandwich it was so tender and delicious! My husband had the seafood pasta, also loved it. Great service in every way!..."
Cheri Graffenius
"Absolutely delicious! I went for a date night on a Sunday night. Highly recommend reservations or you likely won’t get in. We had lasagna and..."
Faith
"Celebrated my birthday here. Food was amazing. Got the baked tomato bisque soup (made like baked French onion soup) and lasagna. Couldn’t even eat..."
Renee
"We tried the garlic cheese bread and a pizza. Ordered the pizza a little well done and it came out perfect. Nice thin crispy crust and great flavor...."
Erich
"Great service we were seated so fast and barely waited at all for our appetizer, the home made garlic bread! So delicious! And the atmosphere itself..."
Wings-N-Whisky Meat and potatoes
"Stopped here looking for a new pizza experience..I was not disappointed!!! We had half order of eggplant for an appetizer and it more than enough..."
Joe-Ann Landry
"My boyfriend took me out for a nice birthday lunch here and it was amazing! I couldn't believe how great my food was. Prices are really not that bad..."
Marta Julia
"We just love this place. A goof old fashioned supper club. I had the Delmonico steak and it was amazing. Wonderful wait staff, awesome bartenders...."
Mike McLane
"Friendly Service with a Smile. Didn't get the"Not my Job", when we asked the busser for Parm cheese Shaker!😎..."
Joseph Gagliano
"Balisteris is a very good Italian Restaurant! The building itself is very nice and homely, very well kept and clean from the inside out though it CAN..."
MistahZ
"The most beautiful atmosphere with incredible food and exceptional service! Our server Jason recommended the vodka sauce on the mushroom ravioli and..."
Thomas Vaughan
"Top notch Italian food. Fine dinning without being all stuffy. You can go casual. I don't wear jeans or shorts here. Service and food is outstanding...."
Paul Jeffers
"The food and service were exceptional. A little too hoity toity for me as far as atmosphere since we were taking a shuttle to the Brewers game. I..."
David Ernst
"We are staying in town from Minneapolis for my daughter's gymnastics competition at the State FIr Grounds and decided to try Balisteri's out. Walked..."
Joe Dancho
"Wonderful food, great service. Balistreri's special pizza and ribeye steak sandwich were a perfect..."
SFaye Kachikis
"It's like a home away from home. Jim's people are always top notch, foods great and the drinks refreshing. I've been going here for more than 30..."
rob m
"Stopped in late after everyone else's kitchens were closed and ordered an incredible Cavatappi Bolognese! Extensive menu, the bar was lively, but..."
Jordan Walls
Nite Owl Ice Cream Parlour & Sandwich Shoppe
Nite Owl Ice Cream Parlour & Sandwich Shoppe
85/100 (1222 ratings)
Restaurants
American
American
Dinner
Lunch
Chocolate Malts Hamburger with the Works
Double Cheeseburger
Cheeseburger with Fries
Chocolate Shake
French Fries
Steak Sandwich
Burger
Cheeseburger with Fried Onions
Mushroom and Swiss Burger
Pickles & Onions
Ice Cream
Chicken Sandwich with Onion Rings
Jumbo Cheeseburger
Chicken Bacon and Ranch Sandwich
Shakes Malts Ice Cream Floats
Burger Fries and a Banana Shake
Fresh Beef
Bacon Cheeseburger with Rings
Hamburger Fries Chocolate Malt
Café
American
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"A Milwaukee legend across from the airport on Layton. Only open in summer. They close for the day when they run out of food so go earlier than later...."
Ian McCain
"We can finally cross off Nite Owl Drive In from our must-try food list! We grabbed a double cheeseburger and a double bacon cheeseburger with fries..."
Josh O
"THE best mushroom and swiss on the planet, and I've tried them all. I've been coming here almost 10 years, and I look forward to every single visit...."
Devin Reed
"The mushroom and Swiss burger is mouth watering, could use a touch of salt and pepper. People complain about the hours. 🙄 They are closed for the..."
VI Hearts
"Nite Owl is a burger everyone needs to experience once. It's a Milwaukee legendary burger. Cash only and get there early. Customer's actually tail..."
Tim Zak
"Cute, old school drive-in. Double cheeseburger was thick and juicy. Very good!!! The fried onions I asked for were extremely minimal though. Fries..."
William Alexander
"Love this place. Burgers are delicious, malts were good too. Great nostalgia on the walls. Update July 27, 2021 - Dining room is closed, but burgers..."
Scott Cherek
"Solid burger. I have criss crossed the country eating burgers out of Hamburger America. This one was solid and would get again. I got the bacon..."
Andrew
"The burgers are delicious. Definitely go on an empty stomach because the burger is huge. I got a single mushroom and swiss. Yum..."
R V
"Classic burger and shake joint. The guy at the window was super nice, and both the food and service will have me coming back. Make sure to bring..."
Will P
"Night Owl Drive In: This local gem has been family owned and operated since 1948. Early in its existence it was indeed a drive in and it was open..."
Travis AKA Doughboy Food Reviews
"I was excited to try this place as I've read great reviews. It was tasty but the fries were soggy and limp and the cost for 2 cheeseburgers, 2 orders..."
Lisa Perry
"Excellent greasy burger! Classic place for fries burgers milkshake combo - the butterscotch is especially good. I would ask for light condiments..."
Keigan Vannoy
"Thr burgers are huge. The fries is for 2 people as it is very filling. The food is so good. Remember to bring..."
Jaime Gilbert
"Juicy cheeseburger. Huge burgers for price. Order at window. No inside dining as of this date. Had cheese, fried onions and ketchup on burger. Good..."
Debbie Mccomb
"They are finally open! Nite Owl NEVER disappoints!! The food is always great and very nostalgic. No frills, no thrills, just great burgers, ice..."
The NONCHALANT1
The Rumpus Room - A Bartolotta Gastropub
The Rumpus Room - A Bartolotta Gastropub
83/100 (1281 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
American
Gastropub
Bar
Pub
Bar
Pub
Gastropub
American
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Drinks
Pork Shoulder
Salmon
Appetizer Plate
Steak Sandwich
Petite Filet
Pretzel
Fried Brussels Sprouts
Schnitzel
Burger
Chicken Fried Oysters
Build a Beer Flight
popcorn
Craft Beer and Cocktail
Picada
Wisconsin Old Fashioned
Juice
Scotch Egg and Cheese
Bacon and eggs
BBQ burger
Whistle Pig Whiskey Flight
Salad
Cheese Curds and Candied Bacon
Wings
Bacon Wrapped Chestnuts
Scallops
Pork Schnitzel
Duck
Pan Seared Scallops
Mussels
Sit down
American
Bar
Pub
Gastropub
Reservations
Accepts Credit Cards
Seating
Table Service
Takeout
Wheelchair Accessible
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Serves Alcohol
Accepts American Express
Street Parking
Gift Cards Available
Accepts Discover
Parking Available
Full Bar
Dinner
Lunch
Drinks
Mid-range
"We got tickets to go to the Phantom of the Opera in Milwaukee. We wanted to go check out a new place to grab some food. After looking online we found..."
Andy Fallon (LT Fallon)
"The Rumpus Room has a limited menu with delicious food. I sat at the bar and decided to sample the beer cheese soup, bleu cheese wedge salad and..."
Julie B
"Super food and drinks. Servers were spectacular. Will go back and enjoy the experience of a life..."
Jesse Pauly
"The service was very nice. The bartenders, hosts, and servers were splendid. The food was very good. I would recommend their cheesesteak. The service..."
One Hand Only (The One Hand Only Andy)
"My first visit to The Rumpus Room was wonderful! My complements to the chef for a delicious dinner and dessert. A great big thank you to our..."
patsy gill
"Totally awesome selection of drinks and food - can't beat whiskey flights and amazing meat and cheese plates. They do close at 10pm on Saturday..."
Alison Yuhas
"I've eaten here a couple times, and each time I've been thoroughly impressed. There's a great selection of beers, brandies, whiskies and wines to..."
Janice Lynch
"Great service and drink selection. Food was underwhelming for the price. Really cool space with eclectic wall..."
Tyler Devan
"Had an event here and they were very helpful organizing. The food was good. No parking..."
Beautiful Orchid
"Great stop. Good food, awesome selection of craft beers and whiskey flights, nice..."
Fred G
"So we had to get a reservation for 12 people on the spot, and not only were they accommodating, they answered fast and helped us out. The scene made..."
Jt Cash
"All the food was amazing. Best deviled eggs I've ever had in my life. It's a casual restaurant with very upscale food. Our waiter was knowledgeable..."
turner hombsch
"Went there last night for our anniversary. It was amazing! Best steak I've ever had (New York Strip) and the scallops were delicious! Really cool..."
Dayna Hanson
"Came here randomly and didn't regret it. Our party had everything from Cuban sandwiches to the surf n turf, everyone enjoyed their food. The whiskey..."
Jon Martin
"We were a bit skeptical at first but this place delivered. The spider Scotch egg was phenomenal, just out right delicious. Great selection for an..."
Ric Rini
"Lovely, perfect place to go to before a show. Friendly. Fabulous..."
Swens Photos
"We just enjoyed a great dinner with excellent service!! Everything from the charcuterie to the steaks to the desserts was..."
Rachel Maron
"This bar is low-key and cozy. Had the local Milwaukee flight, which was a great deal at $15 for four samplers considering they were all seasonal..."
Olivia Arnold
"Great food and Great craft beer. I'm from out of town and this place was recommended to me. I had the cheese curds because it's a must if you're in..."
Paul Ellison
Ma Fischer’s Restaurant
Ma Fischer’s Restaurant
81/100 (2611 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Diner
Diner
American
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Breakfast
Orange Juice
Monte Cristo
Patty Melt
Steak Sandwich
Oatmeal
Chicken and Waffles
Fried Cheese Curds
French Dip
Potato Pancakes
Hash Scramble
Breakfast Skillet
Chicken Dumpling Soup
Burger
Reuben
Spaghetti with Garlic Bread
Liver & Onions
Homemade Crepes
Pancakes
Omlete
Chicken Wings
Toasts
Omelette
Corned Beef
Bloody Mary
Chocolate milkshake
Café
American
Diner
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Cheap Eats
"I have heard about Ma Fischers for years but just never had a chance to go there. Well this morning was my chance. Went there with several veterans..."
Scott W
"I had an excellent waiter and the place well clean. Parking maybe an issue but other than that the food and service is worth giving this place a try...."
CODA CAIN JR
"Really cute traditional USA diner. Staff were super friendly and the service in general was great. Ordered cheese curds which were delicious, nice..."
Alwaysanovice
"Highly recommend Ma Fisher’s!! This restaurant offers such a small town home feel in the middle of the east side of MKE. The prices are really..."
Lysha_Marie
"Great food and service. The southern benedict was my favorite. A little older looking but clean. Will go..."
Angela Hobbs
"Fantastic experience. Water and coffee on the table in record time. Nice menu options. Food came out quickly and modifications were as requested. ..."
jselken1978
"Great food, generous portions, strong & tasty coffee, minimal waiting time, classic rock on the radio: as Europeans, this was everything we were..."
D. Zhols
"An all-time favorite Greek diner for me! Reliable, quick service! Quality food. How can you talk badly about Ma's?! Highly recommend. Tables flip..."
Leah Burg
"We received excellent customer service, the food was very good and you really got generous portions along with complimentary soup which was also..."
Julia Boigenzahn
"Love a place with some history to it. The food is delicious and the staff are kind - hard workers. Also - they play REALLY good music here. 👍 From..."
Katie C
"So everybody that knows me, knows I love good food. So on a recent trip to Milwaukee I had the opportunity to seek out something different from the..."
Warren Graham
"This place is such a treasure!! My omelette was cooked to my specification and the Belgian waffles were heavenly! Good portions are commensurate..."
Matilda Ansah
"Very good! Visiting Milwaukee from Houston for the week. Ma's came up as a good breakfast spot. Was not disappointed! Had the 2nd breakfast special..."
Gabriel V
"I've been coming here for years. In my younger days this would be the place to go after the bars close & you really really needed something good to..."
Ahmay
"Been here twice now. Extensive menu. Plenty of options. The staff seem educated and knowledgeable. Big bonus, the glass entry doors are always..."
FLOYD
"I came here 4 years ago. It is still affordable and the portion are generous. Service is..."
Lingehswari Eisvran
"It has a nice homey diner feel to the restaurant. Staff is friendly and helpful. Food has always been good and..."
Chris Jasniewski
"Heard about this place through the grapvine. I tried it a few times in a row to see how their different dishes were and while they were all fine,..."
Benjamin Polony