Best Pepperoni Pizza in Monroeville

2 restaurant menus in Monroeville, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza
87/100 (1677 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Pepperoni Pizza
Carnivori Pizza
Chocolate cake
Eggplant Marino Pizza
Cheese Cake
Broccoli Rabe & Sausage
Meat Pizza
Meatball & Ricotta Pizza
Salad
Peppers
Paulie's Pie
Wings
White Pizza
Create Your Own Traditional Pizza
Anthony's Coal Fired Wings
Beer Selection
Meatballs
Philly Cheese Steak Pizza
Prosciutto
Thin Crust Pizza
Focaccia
Maria's Meatballs with Ricotta
Cakes
Long Hot Meatball Sandwich
Margarita pizza
Anthony's Classic Italian Salad
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Television
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Happen to be in the area today and found this place and decided to give a try. We are so glad we did the pizza is incredible we went with the classic..."
Joe Peters
"Service was great. The manager, waitress and even the pizza guy were all very friendly and interacted with us. We had wings, pizza and salad. ..."
Bernadette Capets
"Exceptional service, amazing food, full of flavor. Prices are very reasonable, especially for the high quality of the food. First visit was Saturday..."
Stefanie Weese
"The best. I brought my family to Anthony's for pizza and they said they'd drive the 40 miles to get it again. The wings were amazing and so was the..."
Dawn Smidga-Smith
"Great pizza. Great atmosphere. Great service. A special thank you to Craig our server and Jenny our bartender. (I hope I remembered the names..."
Corinne Cecil
"We tried this place for the first time and everything about it was excellent including the service, food, cleanliness and atmosphere! We will..."
Brenda Sue
"We had a large group (9) two were small children. Our server was excellent in taking care of us all, and taking care of the kids. A previous..."
Jeffrey Whalen
"My nephew, boyfriend and myself went there to watch the football game (Go Steelers) and we ordered the wings and 2 pizza special. Let me just..."
Chanel Williams
"Great atmosphere, service, wings, pizza and selection of adult beverages is top notch! We enjoyed our time on the..."
Paige Fulmer
"First time eating here. I definitely give it 5 stars for the service and the food. . Their manager Steve came over at the end and asked how our meal..."
Matt Aaron
"First time here. Staff was great. Wings and pizza to die..."
Loria Welce-Starkey
"Great pizza. Cooked in a coal oven. A unique and great taste. All toppings were so fresh. Then there was the wings marinated in there special..."
Terry Belzer
"Kiddos love the meatballs... I love the pizza and wings! Wish that prices were a bit cheaper, but great food nonetheless. At these prices, I enjoy..."
Matthew Hirtz
"Great service and the best pizza I’ve had in..."
Mark Linden
"Bit of a wait despite lots of empty tables. They appear to be short staffed. That said, the staff were efficient and friendly. There was no delay in..."
Angel Alvarado
"Date night is always a success with this cutie🥺❤️🥺a large 12 slice at Anthony’s was only 30 and it fed us both plus leftovers Our first..."
Greyson Lee
"Amazing pizza! The Caesar salad should be named “To Die For Caesar”! Haha. That’s hands down the best Caesar I’ve ever had and the pizza..."
Rebecca Ogdee
"First time there. Salads are huge and pizza was fabulous. Never had a coal fired pizza before and this place did not disappoint. The staff was over..."
Tammy Mauk
"Great food, meatballs were incredible, pizza was really good especially for gluten free! Service was a bit slow given we were early for dinner and..."
Brian Phillips
"Recently Anthony's catered a small business lunch for 15, and everyone loved the food!! The salad, wings, focaccia bread, meatballs and pizza were a..."
Tod & Laura Pa_5er
"Food was good - pizza is definitely well done (not over cooked, just crispy on the edges), but that’s their thing. Went during the end of happy..."
Cassondra Wood
Caliente
Caliente
71/100 (1256 ratings)
Restaurants
Brew Pub
Pub
Italian
Brew Pub
Pub
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Classic White Tomato Pie
Chefs Rub Wing Dust
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Craft Beer
Chicken Wings
Pepperoni Pizza
Tater Tots
Chicken Salad
The Brooklyn Pizza
Cheese Fries
Pepperoni Palooza Pizza
Godfather Hoagie
New Luca Brasi Pie
CYO Grandma Pizza
Late Night Yinzer Pizza
Godzilla Pizza
Cluckin Hot Rolls
Road House Pizza
Rocky Balboa Pizza
Breaded Zucchini
Pub
Pizza
Italian
Brew Pub
Dinner
Lunch
"Pizzas are absolutely killer!! I've had their fries, and burgers too, both are definitely above your average! Love buying their food for a quick..."
Oak Ridge Review
"Outstanding award winning pizza! What an awesome draft house. Great selection of local micro brews, fantastic selection of unique pizza pies, with..."
Ruffner Lowman
"Nice place to have a drink. They have a beautiful lounge. Sorry, I didn't order any food here. I was at a get-together over the..."
Tracy Corbett Trunzo
"Had the pick two for lunch. Pizza was delicious. For me it had the right amount of sauce to cheese ratio. Crust was crispy and not to chewy. Also got..."
James DiBattista
"First visit in person. Our server, Valerie, and the pizza were both amazing! 🙂 My first experience was a delivered Italian sub. That was also..."
Susan Carney