Best Ice Cream in Montauk

5 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Buddha Berry
Buddha Berry
82/100 (137 ratings)
Quick Bites
Dessert
Healthy
Healthy
Lunch
Breakfast
Waffles & Crepes
Waffles
Waffles & Crepes
Ice Cream
Frozen Yogurt
Sit down
Healthy
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Cheap Eats
"Froyo and Gelato is my family's favorite place! We go here everyday, every summer! The kids love it and I love it because there are so many options..."
Ghazala Choudhary
"This is a fun place for a frozen treat. There are always several frozen yogurts to choose from and a wide variety of toppings. Kids love the place. ..."
Barney Simon
"Tons of toppings. If you don't want the yogart you can just buy the toppings. Swedish fish, malted balls, reese's peanut butter cups, you name it...."
mary jo pojawis
"Elegant and chic, this joint has a lot of variety in a small space! Belgian waffles, crepes, candy, doggie treats, quinoa bowls, t-shirts and more -..."
Jeffrey Baez
"Buddaberry is a GREAT place to eat frozen yogurt and had a great and nice design. And is healthy too. But the people are sometimes not..."
Braeden Krzenski
"Best dessert in town. My family comes here every night when we’re in Montauk! Ask them for the Fro-Yo..."
Andy Bolton
"Delicious, delicious froyo and well worth the visit even in the summer crowds. Open fairly late,..."
Matt Ballard (450nm)
"So good! The amount of toppings they have is ridiculous. Will be returning for..."
Michelle Tate
"Favorite place in Montauk! Love going and getting some some froyo..."
Diana Arias
"Really good gelato and prices weren't..."
John
"Love it ,wish they more flavors and..."
NASA1
"Tasty but pricey. understandable for a seasonal..."
Michael Austin
South Edison
South Edison
81/100 (1114 ratings)
Restaurants
Fusion
Seafood
Asian
Seafood
American
Contemporary
Italian
Fusion
American
Gluten Free Options
Gluten Free Options
Drinks
Dinner
Fish & Chips
Lobster
Tapas
Tacos
Fish & chips
Pasta
Filet Mignon
Salad
Ribs
Bass
Crab
Octopus
Scallops
Ice Cream
Clams
Oyster
Kale Salad
Calamari
Panzanella
Profiteroles
Cakes
Tuna
Calamares
Pesto
Fish
Sashimi
Chowder
Sit down
Fusion
Asian
American
Contemporary
Italian
Seafood
Accepts Discover
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Reservations
Accepts Credit Cards
Seating
Outdoor Seating
Table Service
Takeout
Television
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Private Dining
Serves Alcohol
Accepts American Express
Wine and Beer
Street Parking
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Dinner
Drinks
Mid-range
Fine Dining
"Out of all the restaurants in Montauk, South Edison is truly the best culinary gem. The Chef is an absolute genius, each dish is more complex and..."
Lauren Jahoda
"The yellowfin tuna main course was delicious and highly recommended. We also tried the sashimi fluke, which was good and had a little bit of spice to..."
Jaclyn O'Day
"Best food I had in Montauk. Atmosphere could use some improvement. It's loud. But the waiter was super nice and the food was just fantastic. The duck..."
Wim Bonjean
"We had dinner here during our stay in Montauk. The restaurant is bigger than it looks, the staff are all friendly and attentive. Parking lot and..."
S Gries
"Our server Olivia was friendly, authentic, and extremely attentive. The Buffalo chicken bites and fried olive appetizers exceeded expectations...."
Austin Feinberg
"Insane food!!! First time in Montauk and we’ve been to five of the best restaurants here……hands down the best food around. Super friendly,..."
Adam Pattisall
"South Edison is a great casual bar/restaurant. The ambiance is very good and the service is perfect. Food is so good and the Oysters were so fresh..."
Sepehr Asadizadeh
"Beyond one of my favorite restaurants in Montauk. From the drinks to the food everything is on point. My favorite main dish is their Tuna and my..."
Gina Vega
"A solid four stars plus. Nothing exceptional, but an overall good experience. The staff is wonderful. Food and drink better than..."
Mack Vismusic
"Awesome! The drinks were great. Especially the espresso martini. Definitely get the duck fat fries. I wanted to eat all of them in one sitting but..."
Michael Peterson
John's Drive-in
John's Drive-in
79/100 (1682 ratings)
Quick Bites
Dessert
Fast food
American
Fast Food
American
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Cheeseburger
Burger
Hamburgers
Fish & Chips
Ice Cream
Gyros
Fish
Fish & chips
Café
American
Fast food
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Takeout
Television
Street Parking
Cash Only
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Late Night
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Great spot. We got the Big John’s burger, cheeseburger, bacon chicken ranch, large soda and a pineapple dole whip. Photos might look small but it..."
Jason C
"Really great food and ice cream. They have a lot of homemade flavors that are all very delicious. The service was great and atmosphere was very..."
Hannah Bennett
"My John’s burger was delicious and so were my onion rings. Burger came with special..."
Connie Sarvanandan Toronto Realtor
"CASH ONLY. Atm on site. Nice to have an informal old school diner in Montauk. Come here for the homemade ice cream, it's yummy. Burgers are good, a..."
Connie Kwok
"Came here for a late night bite didn’t think much of it until I got inside. The service was so friendly. Then came the shake. I drink milkshakes a..."
Fritz Bacon
"Old fashioned fast food place with a welcoming vibe. The ice cream is extremely delicious and it is rather inexpensive! I definitely recommend you..."
Adrie Quinn
"I walked by this establishment many times and the lines were always out the door way out to the sidewalk and now I see why the food here is..."
William L Jones Jr
"This was a little diner we stopped at heading back from a drive by the "Hamptons" The milkshakes were out of this world and the fries were great too!..."
Sue DeAngelo
"Classic old school burger joint ! Vintage decor is super cute. They have one vegetarian/vegan option: the house black bean burger. It’s VERY tasty..."
C. Tapia
"The food and service was great. Very important that it is CASH only. The owner, John, was there and was very helpful with everything and gave us a..."
Jack Schultz
Rick's Crabby Cowboy Cafe
Rick's Crabby Cowboy Cafe
78/100 (444 ratings)
Restaurants
Pub
Seafood
American
Bar
Dinner
Lunch
Juice
moscow mule
Shrimp
Martini
Lobster
Ceaser Salad
Salad
Oyster
Hot Dog
Crab
blt
Clams
Lobster Roll
Oyster
Calamari
Clam Bake Bowl
Mussels
Calamares
Lobster Roll
Steamers
Burger
Ribs
Ice Cream
Bbq ribs
"Just left here. We got there as soon as they opened for lunch. I love their tap beer selection and all local Montauk cans. Husband got a frozen drink..."
Ashley Smith
"First time there. Will definitely be back. Had the lobster bake and my wife had the crab leg bake. At first thought it was a tad pricey even though..."
Ac Resnick
"We had a great time, will be back soon. Fun place, good food, great..."
Fran Cerchia Pensa
"Great spot, people were so friendly, delicious oysters. Hidden gem In..."
Linda Knauer Tambini
"A great flyin place to eat! A lot of fun and yummy food. We had a..."
Ronald Hawkins
"Beautiful seaside restaurant, great food and courteous, friendly..."
Carolyn Gesselli Mulholland
"The food, company & service was great. It was my first time, but my brother who has been there several times recommended. Definately will go..."
Diane Eifler
"Awesome food, amazing atmosphere, perfect for kids!! will def go back every mtk..."
Cara Drewes Pessel
"This place is the best on Montauk!! My wife and I go there every time we head out, sometimes 2 or 3..."
Johnnie Walker
"Awesome atmosphere, friendly staff and delicious food!!! A hidden..."
Mer Bear
"Good mix of seafood and barbecue. They have both indoor and outdoor seating. Live music on weekends. Outdoor bar and firepits. The BBQ ribs are..."
Michelle Kane
"Greate BBR Ribs and pulled pork. Great local fish bites. Maurice the bartender was..."
Gleb Beleavski
"The food was spectacular, fresh , kids really enjoyed , definitely we looking to go back..."
El Piojo Chuecopiojoso98
"Lunch was a wonderful experience, especially during the week as it wasn't to crowded, had nice music in the background and beautiful views. The clam..."
Leigh Overland Architect
"Great casual vibe and stunning sunset. We loved our evening at..."
Teach Mayer
"They did a fantastic job for Maggies mission on Friday May 31. Great food and excellent service. Thank you to all the..."
Frank DeSousa
"Ok food. Nice view. A little expensive but a good summer..."
Gerard
"Very fresh food. Had a great tuna sandwich The tuna was cooked perfectly, asked for medium rare and got it, and portion was surprisingly big. We..."
Ron Bogatch
"We were looking for a relaxed and cozy place by the marina and found just that. We were lucky to sit at a table by the window overlooking the marina..."
Desislava Simeonova
"What an unsung spot. Great fresh seafood and delightful waitstaff. I'm not sure why some people have had mixed experiences, but we will totally be..."
Kristen Slevin
Ben & Jerry's
Ben & Jerry's
77/100 (192 ratings)
Dessert
Ice Cream
"The Montauk Ben and Jerry's is fantastic! Super friendly owner and staff, gorgeous location, and terrific ice cream! Can't wait to get..."
Kathy Corcoran Noonan
"The best ice cream in the world, clean, friendly staffs and tons of ice cream..."
Jessica Punted
"Good ice cream. They offer non-dairy options! And they have an espresso shop on the other side. Decently priced for being in..."
apocalypicjedi
"I love Ice Cream. However this B&J fell short. Cute place but something was just off on my cream and cookies..."
Robyn Stuart
"Lots of wonderful flavours. The perfect place to stop for an ice cream...."
Martin Angus
"Delicious. Great people serving you. Waffle cones made fresh on..."
Christopher F.
"Love B&J - has been a family tradition to come at least once while in the..."
Tina Stipak
"Fast service, delicious ice cream. Fairly priced compared to other ice cream shops in the..."
R G
"It's Ben and Jerry's. Tons of flavors. Always delicious. And of course it's a bit pricey. It's in..."
Chris
"Is there a better ice cream than Ben and Jerrys?.....No. There is..."
Chris Medina
"Super friendly staff. Best ice cream..."
Si D
"Good Icecream, but the creators should keep the political thoughts to..."
Mark Leonhardt
"BEST ICE-CREAM EVER, I would go here if I was..."
April Th
"Ben & Jerry's ice cream...you'll enjoy..."
Bill Rank
"Smoothies are delicious staff did..."
Rolando Melendez