Best Cakes in Montauk

9 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Naturally Good Foods And Cafe
Naturally Good Foods And Cafe
86/100 (443 ratings)
Restaurants
Quick Bites
Cafe
Cafe
Healthy
Gluten Free Options
American
Healthy
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Brunch
Breakfast
Lunch
Burrito
Pancakes
Juice & Smoothies
Juice & Smoothies
Bagels
Salad
Bagel with Cream Cheese
Tuna Sandwich
Tuna
Tuna Wrap
Cakes
Caprese Sandwich
Fish
Cheesy Quesadilla
Panettone
Tapas
Nachos
Gallo pinto
Fish Taco
Breakfast Burrito
Tacos
Bagel Deluxe
Egyptian Avocado Toast
Tidal Wave Smoothies
Breakfast in Barbados Smoothie
Sandwiches
Bruce Sandwich
Emma's Hummus Wrap
Hummus
Naturally Good Pancakes GF
Sit down
American
Healthy
Café
Wine and Beer
Gift Cards Available
Free off-street parking
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Street Parking
Seating
Accepts Discover
Wheelchair Accessible
Brunch
Breakfast
Lunch
Mid-range
"This is an amazing shop, they have good healthy options for breakfast, lunch and brunch, also selected products at the grocery part, friendly staff,..."
Livia Eastman
"Came in just expecting a quick bite but was pleasantly surprised by the quality and the flavor. I had a Cajun Fish wrap, nachos and a mango smoothie...."
D Euro
"Service with a smile! The Hulk juice was perfect and their special grilled cheese was delicious. Will definitely visit..."
Dan Rivera
"My favorite place in town. The Torta-Rican breakfast burrito is the best I’ve ever had. Great spot to grab reasonably priced but thoughtfully..."
Caitlin Richard
"Cajun tofu sandwich (got it as a wrap) absolutely phenomenal. Fast service. Cute back patio area with tomato plants and flowers as well. Looking..."
Becca Andersen
"Great menu, delicious food, great products. Vegan panna cotta is..."
Zeynep Gunbay
"Delicious sandwiches and wraps. Stopped by on all three days this week during a short winter getaway to Montauk. Friendly service, great selection..."
saumikde
"Great pre-made salads. They also have space in front and in the back to eat the food you buy in the deli..."
Alejandro Fernandez
"This place is always fresh and consistently delicious. From fresh juices & smoothies to wheat Sprout bagels and delicious salads, to sweet little..."
christine
"I got the hummus wrap and chips. This place had a few more vegan options and is located in a store with vegan..."
Miranda Thomason
Surfside Inn
Surfside Inn
84/100 (286 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Seafood
American
Seafood
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Crab Cake
Dumplings
Lobster
Filet Mignon
Pasta
Halibut
Salad
Ribs
Clam Chowder
Bass
Baby Back Ribs
Crab
Cakes
Clams
Pesto
Duck
Calamari
Fish
Mussels
Tuna
Calamares
Salmon
Shrimp
Sit down
American
Seafood
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Outdoor Seating
Live Music
Waterfront
Reservations
Valet Parking
Seating
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
South Edison
South Edison
81/100 (1114 ratings)
Restaurants
Seafood
Asian
Seafood
American
Contemporary
Italian
Fusion
American
Gluten Free Options
Fusion
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Drinks
Tacos
Fish & chips
Pasta
Filet Mignon
Salad
Ribs
Bass
Crab
Octopus
Scallops
Ice Cream
Clams
Oyster
Kale Salad
Calamari
Panzanella
Profiteroles
Cakes
Tuna
Pesto
Calamares
Fish
Sashimi
Chowder
Fish & Chips
Lobster
Tapas
Sit down
Asian
American
Contemporary
Italian
Seafood
Fusion
Reservations
Accepts Credit Cards
Seating
Outdoor Seating
Table Service
Takeout
Wheelchair Accessible
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Serves Alcohol
Private Dining
Accepts American Express
Wine and Beer
Street Parking
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Accepts Discover
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Dinner
Drinks
Mid-range
Fine Dining
"Out of all the restaurants in Montauk, South Edison is truly the best culinary gem. The Chef is an absolute genius, each dish is more complex and..."
Lauren Jahoda
"The yellowfin tuna main course was delicious and highly recommended. We also tried the sashimi fluke, which was good and had a little bit of spice to..."
Jaclyn O'Day
"Best food I had in Montauk. Atmosphere could use some improvement. It's loud. But the waiter was super nice and the food was just fantastic. The duck..."
Wim Bonjean
"We had dinner here during our stay in Montauk. The restaurant is bigger than it looks, the staff are all friendly and attentive. Parking lot and..."
S Gries
"Our server Olivia was friendly, authentic, and extremely attentive. The Buffalo chicken bites and fried olive appetizers exceeded expectations...."
Austin Feinberg
"Insane food!!! First time in Montauk and we’ve been to five of the best restaurants here……hands down the best food around. Super friendly,..."
Adam Pattisall
"South Edison is a great casual bar/restaurant. The ambiance is very good and the service is perfect. Food is so good and the Oysters were so fresh..."
Sepehr Asadizadeh
"Beyond one of my favorite restaurants in Montauk. From the drinks to the food everything is on point. My favorite main dish is their Tuna and my..."
Gina Vega
"A solid four stars plus. Nothing exceptional, but an overall good experience. The staff is wonderful. Food and drink better than..."
Mack Vismusic
"Awesome! The drinks were great. Especially the espresso martini. Definitely get the duck fat fries. I wanted to eat all of them in one sitting but..."
Michael Peterson
Montauk Bake Shoppe Limited
Montauk Bake Shoppe Limited
80/100 (831 ratings)
Quick Bites
Dessert
Bakeries
American
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Breakfast
Breakfast Sandwich
Bagels
Cupcakes
Eclairs
Cakes
Lobster
Sit down
American
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Breakfast
Cheap Eats
"So many tasty options here! We had breakfast wrap & sandwich and even went back another day to try another option. Even with a mixup on someone..."
Laura Johnson
"Adorable European style bakery in the center of Montauk. What stood out to me most - the efficiency of the staff. They are paying attention and..."
T H
"It's such a wonderful local bakery.. Taste 👍 Coffee..."
Mark Choi
"Pastries were cheap and delicious! A friend of mine grew up on these and told me to pay a visit during my stay. Needless to say it did not..."
Josephine Foong
"This is a Montauk institution, I've been coming here for almost 50 years. Inventive cookies, fantastic jelly rolls, and really nice customer service...."
Petra Holden
"Number one bake shoppe out East! Amazing assortment of donuts, muffins, crumb cakes, fresh rolls. They are famous for their delicious jelly..."
Nina Forcello
"This gem of a bake shop has some of the BEST cookies and pastries I’ve ever had. Their rainbow cookies are particularly fantastic - really thick..."
Jake Steinerman
"Awesome old fashion bakery, had coffee here every morning of our vacation. No nonsense delicious coffee. Also had the crumb cake and jelly filled..."
K may
"Beautiful and delicious custom vanilla fresh strawberry 8 inch birthday cake with whipped cream icing. Called 24 hours ahead and the pastry chef was..."
Vivian Janeo
"Had one of the most unique delicious breakfast sandwhiches here! Got the #8 on a roll. #8 2 Eggs, Mushrooms, Ricotta, Spinach, Swiss Cheese -..."
Amanda Hahn
"The food is excellent, but you must stay open minded to receiving and enjoying a meal other than what you what you ordered. This morning, I missed..."
M R
"Cool little bakery. The coffee cake is really good. There’s no seating inside..."
Jason Braun
"Linda helped us with a Bridal panic when we picked up a 2 layer not 2 level tiered cake some sort of miscommunication between myself, my mother and..."
Anne Carmel Davis
"Lovely food and drinks if you’re Irish you will appreciate they sell Barry’s..."
Victoria Graham
"Great pastries! Try the chocolate chip muffin. You wont regret..."
Cameron Vidrine
"When I first got to Montauk everyone was hyping on the bake shop. I'm here to tell you it's worth the hype. They have an array of pastries and they..."
Raphael Gorjian
668 The Gig Shack
668 The Gig Shack
80/100 (1524 ratings)
Restaurants
International
Bar
International
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Seafood
American
Gluten Free Options
Bar
Seafood
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Lobster Roll
Tuna Tartar Taquitos
Tapas
Side Salad
Grilled Organic Chicken Sandwich
Fish Taco
Fish Tacos
Seared Local Sea Scallops
Tacos
Signature Cocktails
Shrimp
Blackened Local Fish Montacos - GF
Shrimp Skewers
Fennel Salad Fish Taquitos Tomato Bruschetta
Ribs
Tuna Tacos
Fish Sandwich
White Wine Mussels
Lobster
Cheeseburger
Salad
Baby Back Ribs
Key lime pie
Pain Killer
Crab
Goat cheese salad
Prime Rib Sandwich
Scallops
Mussels
Cakes
Blackened Fish Sandwich
Tuna
Lamb
Grilled Pat La Frieda Burger
Fish
Charred Lemon Caesar Salad - V
Sandwiches
Pork
Shack Lobster Roll
Crab Cake
Burger
Margarita
Sit down
Bar
American
Seafood
International
Non-smoking restaurants
Dog Friendly
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Seating
Television
Table Service
Accepts Mastercard
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Live Music
Wine and Beer
Gift Cards Available
Accepts Discover
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Pretty cool little place in the heart of town. Sat at the bar and watched the tennis match. Had a lobster slider, which was buttery and delicious...."
KGB (KGB)
"I am not a big fan of sea food and tacos, but it was a good experience. I loved the decoration and the restaurant's warm atmosphere. We ordered a..."
Sean ainechi
"The most reason why I'm here is this place is dog friendly restaurant. I took my spoiled puppy with me on a small vacation trip so everywhere I go...."
Melissa Naja
"Everyone in our party of 4 was delighted with our meals here. I got the baby back ribs: the meat was succulent and the corn bread was warm and soft...."
Tyron Pretorius
"We had a great dinner here on the patio. All of the food we tried was a riff on a classic. From the Mediterranean we had Spanakopita it was a light..."
Anna Bennett
"Best rum drink (super strong). Every time I come here they serve drinks in the coolest cups. We shared the chicken sandwich- it was 🔥🔥🔥...."
Amanda Hahn
"Food was very good. I started with the empanadas. They were amazing. After I had the grilled chicken and lobster croissant. Very good also. Service..."
Gabriel Davila
"Omg! Loved this restaurant. Plenty of space outdoors and indoors. Great place to quickly grab food and go about your day. Restaurant is in the..."
Eugenia Kim
"Already can't wait to come back to this place! It had a great atmosphere with delicious food. I ordered the ribs with cornbread & coleslaw and it was..."
Katie McKenna
"Stopped here with a girlfriend for lunch and we could not have chosen a better spot! You are welcomed by beautiful beach decor and a friendly staff...."
Sam Cosme
Gosman's Restaurant
Gosman's Restaurant
73/100 (2668 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Seafood
Seafood
American
American
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Fish
Shrimp
Crab Cake
Lobster
Chowder
Pasta
Fish & Chips
Salad
Lobster Roll
Clam Chowder
Fish & chips
Tapas
Tacos
Crab
Steamers
Scallops
Cod
Clams
Swordfish
Oyster
Calamari
French Fries
Mussels
Surf And Turf
Tuna
Fried shrimp
Calamares
Burger
Cakes
Salmon
Pesto
Sit down
American
Seafood
Outdoor Seating
Street Parking
Waterfront
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Non-smoking restaurants
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Mid-range
"We ordered the salmon, burger & shrimp basket. It was great. Update - my mom got really bad food poisoning that lasted a month after this. She thinks..."
C Sjoen
"I love food! So I am a wannabe food critic! LOL. The crab cheese dip did not taste like it had crab in it, and I didn't see any either, so that was..."
Robin Ax
"Me and my family were wondering where to eat until we can across Gosman’s Restaurant. The service were amazing and the food couldn’t be worse...."
Yuze Fang
"Nice place, beautiful view of the sea, excellent service but it lacks a background music, the food is delicious but they could include more ceviche..."
Carlo baldu
"I've been visiting Montauk for many years. Gosmans is always a consistently great experience. Love the food and..."
Heather Dolland Tamam
"Such a nice cozy restaurant with great dishes and nice service! I loved their outdoor seating, they had good shaded area for seating. I chose the..."
Shima
"The best New York strip I've ever had and great dessert. We chose to sit inside but the view was still..."
Sean E Smith
"This restaurant holds a monopoly stake in the dining scene of Montauk. Pretty much anyone who has ever visited the town has dined here, and for good..."
Sushi Sue
"Nice seafood restaurant. Food are fresh. My favorite is the east coast Oyster because the sweet..."
Sue Su
"Wonderful family restaurant with outer and indoor seating , bar, and awesome Sound into Ocean..."
Jessica Cooper Foltin, MD
Duryea's Lobster Deck
Duryea's Lobster Deck
71/100 (1112 ratings)
Quick Bites
Restaurants
Seafood
Seafood
American
American
Dinner
Lunch
Crab Cake
Cobb Salad
Shrimp
Duryea's Lobster Cobb Salad
Cakes
Lobster
3lb Grilled Octopus
Fish
Salad
Peel N' Eat Shrimp Pot
Iced tea
Clam Chowder
Crudités Platter
Sea Bass
Cheery
Tuna Tartare
Crab
Sweet Potato Chips and Coleslaw
Clams
Clam Bake
Hamburger and Fries
Oyster
Lobster Claws
Fish of the Day
Calamari
Corn on the Cob
Mussels
Calamares
Shrimp Cocktail
Crab Cake
Breaded Calamari
Chowder
Burger
French Fries
Lobster Roll
Hamburgers
Lobster Roll
Steamers
Blue Point Oysters
Sit down
American
Seafood
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
BYOB
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Food was excellent and the sunset views were magnificent !!!! Staff was very friendly and knowledgeable. Ordering style was unique but food was fast..."
Gregory Rivera
"Great location on the sea shore, sunset full on, nice deck, food delicious, lobster yum, french fries hmmm (freedom tasty!) and staff adorable...."
Catherine Lillingston
"Love this place so much! The food is great. The service is excellent and the ambiance is charming. Best sunsets in..."
Val En Tina
"The BEST meal I have had in Montauk in many years! The Lobster Cobb Salad was AMAZING, the crudités appetizer had some of the freshest vegetables I..."
Heather Murray
"Great food and a gorgeous view!! Get there early or you will have to wait. Highly..."
Leisa Woodson Stewart
"The food was super fresh and delicious! The water side view..."
LucyRob Gulli
"Simply, great location, best seafood, awesome atmosphere and Beautiful people! Highly recommended ! Looking forward to going..."
Melissa Petsco
"So beautiful and the best chowder I have ever..."
Amy Patt
"Great Sunset! Great ambiance! Superb food! Excellent..."
Victoria E. Mancuso
"Phenomenal food and location... A little overpriced but worth it. Make sure you Are hungry and go in..."
James A Marcolin
"Amazing. Beautiful view and romantic. Spent my last night in New York here with my husband and by far one of the best meals and I love my seafood...."
Sarah Brown Boggs
"5-Star! Thank you for a wonderful..."
Natalie Cervera
"Best experience ever, food, sunset, atmosphere, location, just what you want from a lobster spot in..."
Bettina Fuchs McCarthy
"For anyone who’s left a poor review, it seems they are usually unhappy with long wait times or the price. It’s pretty simple, they don't take..."
Aleena A
"Nothing beats that sunset view. It got cold and windy, but there were blankets available to borrow. The food was very tasty, but indeed expensive so..."
Paige DiFiore
"Lobster roll is the highlight of the menu (Next to the lobster salad which can feed at least 3-4 individuals easily). Lobster meat was fresh ,..."
Kunnel S Zachariah
"Such a great environment for a lunch or early dinner! Food was very delicious, cooked to our liking and just over all great quality. They did forget..."
Christina Romano
"A great place to relax and have good food. Its a little isolated but still not far from the center of town. Great views and fresh food. Is it a..."
Stratmangler 27
"I really enjoyed lunch there. This place has a strong Ibiza vibe. The food was great and perfect for sharing. The lobster roll was outstanding with a..."
Ally Wu
"Gorgeous spot on the water, fresh seafood dishes, beautiful people and a little bit of a Hamptons scene. Yes, the food is overpriced, but so is every..."
J Marchese
"Delicious food, wonderful view. Amazing customer service all around. Everyone is so friendly. One of my favorite places! Special thanks to the..."
Rachel L
"Lobster salad is ❤️‍🔥 Crab cakes and fries are also..."
Haley Read
"Outstanding setting, excellent service and meal. Lobster cob salad was over the top good with a hint of taragon-the calamari, perfectly cooked and..."
Gabrielle Binler
Mr. John's Pancake House
Mr. John's Pancake House
70/100 (1318 ratings)
Restaurants
American
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Brunch
Breakfast
Lunch
Pancakes
Eggs Benedict
French Toast
Toasts
Omelette
Waffles
Crepes
Cakes
Burger
Sit down
American
Wheelchair Accessible
Highchairs Available
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Lunch
Brunch
Breakfast
Mid-range
"Good American experience. You will get your full breakfast/brunch based on a menu with pancakes options, eggs and crepes, all joined by coffee and a..."
R E
"Old school, American dinner experience that only accepts cash. The day omelet was fresh and tasty, with a significant portion. The 6 a.m. breakfast..."
Sean ainechi
"Atmosphere, yes. Cool hostess, either owner maybe, yes. Spinach & feta omelette, and my rye toast w/butter, yes. My friends steak & eggs, yes...."
Brette Grice
"CASH ONLY * My travel companion and I enjoyed our lunch at John's very much. We were not aware that it was cash only, so glad we had cash on us. I..."
Amanda Miller
"Food was very good. Little pricey. But expected for the area. The eggs Benedict was delish. Corned beef hash was yummy. Husband got a waffle and said..."
Laura Steeneck
"What an excellent classic American breakfast we had, the sausages were especially delicious. So menu offers many options that all sound fantastic,..."
Leo Lapassat
"Best breakfast in town. Place hasn’t changed like the rest of town. It’s timeless. Not to mention the pancakes are delicious. It’s an always..."
Richard Cheek
"I came here for breakfast twice during my stay in Montauk and I really liked the food and service. The staff is friendly and the food comes out fast...."
Lisa S
"Pretty Dang good breakfast. A pretty penny too but delicious..."
Nicole Caracola
"Who doesn’t love perfectly crisp bacon! I ordered the no 2 special. 3 pancakes, 2 eggs and a handful of perfect bacon. The pancakes were a little..."
Anna A.
Anthony's Pancake & Waffle House
Anthony's Pancake & Waffle House
70/100 (842 ratings)
Restaurants
Diner
American
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Brunch
Breakfast
Lunch
Turkey Sausage
Pancakes
Feta Spinach Omelette
House Coffee
French Toast
Toasts
Eggs Benedict Salmon
Omelette
2 Eggs and Toast
Waffles
Belgian Waffle with Mixed Fruits
Crepes
Peanut Butter and Chocolate Chip Pancakes
Steak and Eggs
Cakes
Gluten-Free Waffle
Cheese Sandwich
BLT Sandwich
Omlete with Fries
Beyond Meat Burger
Feta Omelette
Fluffy Pancakes
Our Famous Home Fries
French Toast
French Fries
Gluten Free Pancakes
Smoked Salmon Avocado Toast
Sit down
American
Diner
Highchairs Available
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Brunch
Breakfast
Mid-range
"Great little breakfast spot. I was solo dining so I sat at the bar and was greeted right away. My server was quick and friendly. Food was..."
KGB (KGB)
"My experience at the pancake house was a bit mixed. While the menu had a variety of options, I was disappointed by the slow service that seemed to..."
Denis Mantsurov
"The staff greeted our group of 10 people quickly and warmly. We got there around 7:30AM and they were so accommodating. The food was prepared with..."
Kai Kalino
"10/10 breakfast spot. A well oiled machine. The staff is so friendly. The owner himself works hard alongside his employees. The food is such a great..."
Kate Bainbridge
"It is a very clean place, great energy inside!! Sometimes took the server a few minutes to come check on us but otherwise a great experience and..."
Charles SSS
"A great breakfast place choice for Montauk Point. Price and service and ambiance was very nice as compared to another breakfast location we tried..."
Vince Asuncion
"When in Montauk, definitely try a pancake house. Reservations not taken at this restaurant so there will be a wait time. This place takes only cash..."
Eugenia Kim
"It was a clean and Fancy breakfast place but was relatively crowded by 8..."
Sean ainechi
"We came here 3 times in a row and loved it each time. The food was excellent (I recommend the famous fluffy pancakes). The service was amazing, our..."
Nathan Yakubov
"I came here yesterday for breakfast. This place looked a lot more modern than their competition across the street. They don't have a real extensive..."
Lisa S