Best Ice Cream and Cake in Montauk

There is only one restaurant
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
The Crow's Nest Inn And Restaurant
The Crow's Nest Inn And Restaurant
78/100 (394 ratings)
Restaurants
Mediterranean
Mediterranean
Dinner
Halibut
Autumn Spaghetti
Kabobs
Local Fluke & Yellowfin Tuna Crudo
Pesto
Spring Vegetables and Chicken Souvlaki
Garlic bread
Chocolate Cake and Lemon Cake
Chocolate Brownie
Maple Brooke Burrata
Vegetarian Morrocan Curry with Naan
Blue Crab Claw Tagliatelle
Flourless Chocolate Budino Cake
Oyster Platter
Grass-Fed Rib Steak
Mezze Platter
Pasta
Goat Cheese and Pistachio Cheesecake
Lobster Tagliatelle
Crab
Bagel
Scallops
Halibut
Oyster
Ice Cream and Cake
Risotto
Montauk Day Boat Scallops
Sit down
Mediterranean
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Private Dining
Waterfront
Beach
Valet Parking
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Parking Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Dinner
Fine Dining
"The Crow’s Nest is great! We only went for late night drinks however noticed they have an amazing post dinner atmosphere. There were multiple bars..."
Jeffrey Pammer
"Had the best meal the other night at crows nest. From start to finish everything was perfect. The gentleman at the host stand was very nice and..."
Jewel Feldman
"The restaurant was nice and very family friendly. It was great seeing kids play and enjoy themselves. I loved the smell of the wood burning from the..."
Cody Powell
"A bit pricey but the Lobster tagliatelle is amazing — we also tried the ricotta toast and it was delicious. Service was great and everyone was so..."
Alexis Sabbaghian
"The Crow’s Nest is, without a doubt, my top pick for dinner and drinks in Montauk. Yes, the prices might make you raise an eyebrow, but every penny..."
Lloyd
"A beautiful spot with a beachfront bar and incredible indoor and outdoor restaurant seating. The food is delicious. Also the place has a charming..."
Tom Byam-Cook
"As an event planner we love working at Crows Nest. The service staff is excellent at events and the management team some of the best. Its hard to..."
Ashley Dru Douglass
"With so many amazing restaurants and locations in Montauk you chose from its not easy to pick the best but I would say Crows Nest is clearly the best..."
Paul Shepherd
"Great restaurant. Incredi le location and views of the water from the sprawling lawn. Love thermally bar inside. Expect a crowd on..."
Joseph Berkowitz
"Always super crowded, hard to find a parking but other that it is a fantastic place to see. Montauk totally diffrent then whole entire hampton. It is..."
mehmet pala
"Great little restaurant. It gets very busy and there is generally a long wait for a table BUT they have a great beach bar to go and hang out while..."
Chris Winger
"Went for dinner, no hotel stay. Great food & location- extremely overpriced. Halibut & appetizers we’re amazing, lobster pasta was so so but too..."
Christina Romano
"I dream of Lobster pasta all day every day. And if I could have Crows Nest every night for dinner, I would! It’s a truly magical experience. I love..."
fareesa abbasi
"We went to the restaurant , it was a good experience and they had lots of staff although everything felt very rushed. The prices are insane so be..."
Thomas Clegg