Best Sandwiches in Montauk

5 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Naturally Good Foods And Cafe
Naturally Good Foods And Cafe
86/100 (443 ratings)
Quick Bites
Restaurants
American
Healthy
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Cafe
Cafe
Healthy
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Breakfast
Lunch
Brunch
Egyptian Avocado Toast
Tidal Wave Smoothies
Breakfast in Barbados Smoothie
Sandwiches
Bruce Sandwich
Emma's Hummus Wrap
Hummus
Naturally Good Pancakes GF
Burrito
Pancakes
Juice & Smoothies
Juice & Smoothies
Bagels
Salad
Bagel with Cream Cheese
Tuna Sandwich
Tuna
Tuna Wrap
Cakes
Caprese Sandwich
Fish
Cheesy Quesadilla
Panettone
Tapas
Nachos
Gallo pinto
Fish Taco
Breakfast Burrito
Tacos
Bagel Deluxe
Sit down
American
Healthy
Café
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Street Parking
Seating
Accepts Discover
Wheelchair Accessible
Wine and Beer
Gift Cards Available
Free off-street parking
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Brunch
Breakfast
Lunch
Mid-range
"This is an amazing shop, they have good healthy options for breakfast, lunch and brunch, also selected products at the grocery part, friendly staff,..."
Livia Eastman
"Came in just expecting a quick bite but was pleasantly surprised by the quality and the flavor. I had a Cajun Fish wrap, nachos and a mango smoothie...."
D Euro
"Service with a smile! The Hulk juice was perfect and their special grilled cheese was delicious. Will definitely visit..."
Dan Rivera
"My favorite place in town. The Torta-Rican breakfast burrito is the best I’ve ever had. Great spot to grab reasonably priced but thoughtfully..."
Caitlin Richard
"Cajun tofu sandwich (got it as a wrap) absolutely phenomenal. Fast service. Cute back patio area with tomato plants and flowers as well. Looking..."
Becca Andersen
"Great menu, delicious food, great products. Vegan panna cotta is..."
Zeynep Gunbay
"Delicious sandwiches and wraps. Stopped by on all three days this week during a short winter getaway to Montauk. Friendly service, great selection..."
saumikde
"Great pre-made salads. They also have space in front and in the back to eat the food you buy in the deli..."
Alejandro Fernandez
"This place is always fresh and consistently delicious. From fresh juices & smoothies to wheat Sprout bagels and delicious salads, to sweet little..."
christine
"I got the hummus wrap and chips. This place had a few more vegan options and is located in a store with vegan..."
Miranda Thomason
O'murphys Pub
O'murphys Pub
84/100 (430 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Irish
Bar
Pub
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Wings
Mussels
Tuna
Salmon
Sandwiches
Chowder
Fish & Chips
Burger
Ribs
Hamburgers
Steak Sandwich
Shrimp
Pasta
Salad
"Solid dining experience. The ambience is really nice and the staff are friendly, albeit the service is a bit slow. I ordered my burger medium but it..."
Mike Wu
"Great food, pricey but worth it, good portions. Fresh seafood. Shrimp scampi was soooooo..."
SannoNYC
"We've been going to O'Murphys forever. In their new location they have a much bigger and nicer bar area, a bigger dining room. Lots of parking,..."
S Gries
"My friends and I affectionately call it Mother O'Murphy's! The food is great, wonderful burgers and shepherd's pie, and fantastic french onion soup...."
Ronald Redmond
"We visited O'Murphy's on their second day in their new location. It was hard to tell that it was a new place, the staff all seems to have moved and..."
Barney Simon
"You have to try the duck. Excellent. My wife had the shrimp scampi and loved it. My friend had the blackened swordfish also loved it. The calamari..."
Mike Weber
"Had the BEST EVER SHRIMP SCAMPI OVER LINGUINE yesterday. There was absolutely nothing wrong with it. The salad was super fresh and the staff adorable..."
Barbara Nelson
"Best Irish restaurant in Montauk!! Love everything I have ever gotten here. The wings and potato skins are the bomb. The shepherds pie is amazing...."
Michelle Kane
"This place was amazing ! A little pricey but the food is overall delicious so it makes up for it and the staff was so sweet and well manured. It was..."
Danky Daze
"We always go to O'Murphy's when we are in Montauk. The food is always good, the service and people are excellent, and the new location is really..."
George Fanno
"Had a delightful meal of fried fish sandwich and delicious homemade fries on a blustery New year's day, & Probably the best Irish coffee I've ever..."
Cory Davenport
"had dinner at omurphys last night it was great! food was excellent, very family friendly, I highly recommend the shrimp scampi, service was..."
mikaela fiscina
668 The Gig Shack
668 The Gig Shack
80/100 (1524 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Bar
Gluten Free Options
Seafood
American
International
Bar
International
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Seafood
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Goat cheese salad
Prime Rib Sandwich
Scallops
Cakes
Blackened Fish Sandwich
Mussels
Lamb
Grilled Pat La Frieda Burger
Tuna
Fish
Charred Lemon Caesar Salad - V
Sandwiches
Pork
Shack Lobster Roll
Crab Cake
Burger
Margarita
Lobster Roll
Tapas
Side Salad
Tuna Tartar Taquitos
Fish Taco
Fish Tacos
Grilled Organic Chicken Sandwich
Seared Local Sea Scallops
Tacos
Signature Cocktails
Shrimp
Blackened Local Fish Montacos - GF
Shrimp Skewers
Fennel Salad Fish Taquitos Tomato Bruschetta
Ribs
Tuna Tacos
Fish Sandwich
White Wine Mussels
Lobster
Cheeseburger
Salad
Baby Back Ribs
Key lime pie
Pain Killer
Crab
Sit down
Seafood
International
Bar
American
Wine and Beer
Gift Cards Available
Accepts Discover
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Non-smoking restaurants
Dog Friendly
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Seating
Table Service
Accepts Mastercard
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Live Music
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Pretty cool little place in the heart of town. Sat at the bar and watched the tennis match. Had a lobster slider, which was buttery and delicious...."
KGB (KGB)
"I am not a big fan of sea food and tacos, but it was a good experience. I loved the decoration and the restaurant's warm atmosphere. We ordered a..."
Sean ainechi
"The most reason why I'm here is this place is dog friendly restaurant. I took my spoiled puppy with me on a small vacation trip so everywhere I go...."
Melissa Naja
"Everyone in our party of 4 was delighted with our meals here. I got the baby back ribs: the meat was succulent and the corn bread was warm and soft...."
Tyron Pretorius
"We had a great dinner here on the patio. All of the food we tried was a riff on a classic. From the Mediterranean we had Spanakopita it was a light..."
Anna Bennett
"Best rum drink (super strong). Every time I come here they serve drinks in the coolest cups. We shared the chicken sandwich- it was 🔥🔥🔥...."
Amanda Hahn
"Food was very good. I started with the empanadas. They were amazing. After I had the grilled chicken and lobster croissant. Very good also. Service..."
Gabriel Davila
"Omg! Loved this restaurant. Plenty of space outdoors and indoors. Great place to quickly grab food and go about your day. Restaurant is in the..."
Eugenia Kim
"Already can't wait to come back to this place! It had a great atmosphere with delicious food. I ordered the ribs with cornbread & coleslaw and it was..."
Katie McKenna
"Stopped here with a girlfriend for lunch and we could not have chosen a better spot! You are welcomed by beautiful beach decor and a friendly staff...."
Sam Cosme
Shagwong Tavern
Shagwong Tavern
77/100 (1130 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Bar
Pub
Seafood
Bar
Pub
American
Seafood
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Clams
Calamari
Calamares
Lobster Roll
Sandwiches
Fish Sandwich
Fish
Burger
Hamburgers
Lobster
Salad
Wings
Clam Chowder
Sit down
American
Seafood
Bar
Pub
Full Bar
Takeout
Television
Live Music
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Dinner
Late Night
Lunch
Mid-range
"My husband and I had dinner there tonight. We tried Shagwong on a whim! We were pleasantly surprised! The food and service were exceptional! I would..."
Stephanie Pages-Gallo
"The atmosphere, the service, the food....A+! First time in Montauk and we loved it. Cold, but loved it. So, so, so happy we chose to have dinner our..."
Neina Spatola Reinert
"Best place to eat! Sarah was amazing and made great recommendations. The service was above and food absolutely delectable! We have it on our list..."
Kelli Buchanan
"A great neighborhood mainstay- filled with Montauk flavor & character! The restaurant has the best fish tacos in town! The bar has a great nightly dj..."
Colleen Sullivan
"The staff would stop at nothing to make your Visit the best. If they let you down it's because you didn't ask or mention that you were upset. They..."
Silver Back
"Nice quiet place to have a drink. The food smelled delicious but we had already eaten. The bartender was friendly as was the crowd. This was the..."
Ann Burke Larkin
"We went on a very cold and very windy day and it was very warm and toasty inside ..the staff is very nice the food was delicious and the drinks were..."
Louise Morelli Lupo
"Great food and friendly service. Loved it. Still a great place for a drink and..."
Dan Gillen
"Very good sandwiches and burgers. One of the best seafood..."
Mariusz Gorniak
"The best burger ever. Shoe string onions on the burger rules. If you do not want a tourist trap you go to shags. Many a long fishing trip in montauk..."
Joe Thomas McCune
"I was pleasantly surprised with this place. We had a long day hiking the trails and stopped in for lunch. The hostess/waitress had her work cut out..."
Anna A.
"We had been to Shagwong many years ago and wanted to go again during our recent trip to Montauk. Shagwong is one of the few restaurants open year..."
CR Walters
"The energy in the place was simply amazing, creating a vibrant and inviting atmosphere that instantly made me feel at home. The food at this..."
Goran NYC Photographer
"My recent visit to the restaurant left me with a rather average impression. The food was quite bland and the slow service did not enhance the dining..."
Denis Mantsurov
"We both had fish and chips. Very crispy. Plenty of fries came with the order. We went during lunch and ate outside. Not very crowded. Bar area seemed..."
Andrea B
"Nice local bar. The zucchini fries are plentiful and have a good spicy sauce. The Clams Casino is interesting - like Oysters..."
Jacob Harris
"Cozy little bar and restaurant. Service was good. People were friendly. We had clams which were delicious. Then we had french onion soup. Wow! It was..."
Cynthia Kirk
"Had a nice experience here! We are here off season, so I understand most of the restaurants being closed in the Winter. I’m sure this place is..."
Nathan Bush
"When you visit Montauk you’ll notice this place right away for its beautiful and historic aesthetics, but the food and the service will be what you..."
No. 7
"Amazing dinner here! Great wait staff. Cold Radiant Pig "Save The Robots" IPA on draught. The Steak and Paella were both..."
The Tapsmith
"Simple good food in a traditional tavern interior. A long nice wooden bar on the left with a nice selection of beers on tap and a dining room on the..."
philippe gabulon
"I was there end of March for work and was unable to find anything open so walked in for a quick bite to eat. To my total surprise the food was very..."
Rajib Mazhar Hasan
Goldberg's Bagels Flagels & Deli
Goldberg's Bagels Flagels & Deli
75/100 (472 ratings)
Quick Bites
Restaurants
American
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Lunch
Brunch
Breakfast
Sandwiches
Salad
Breakfast Sandwich
Bagels
American
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Breakfast
Lunch
Brunch
Cheap Eats
"A popular spot for breakfast, be prepared to wait in line. The food is great though with classic breakfast sandwiches and bagels of high quality...."
Maria A.
"Wonderful! Everyone in my group got breakfast sandwiches and they loved them. I got the honey turkey and honey mustard on an everything bagel and it..."
Kelly Johnson
"Delicious breakfast burrito with hash browns. Also really good coffee. Really friendly staff too. Short walk for breakfast on beach..."
Paul P
"Taste 100 times better then overpriced breakfast at Gurneys. Every time I come to this place there is no room for disappointment! Bagels always..."
Alexandra Rozhdestvenskaya
"The best jelly filled French croissants and young lady that helped me was the most pleasant and helpful worker I've dealt with in a long time keep up..."
Peter Vitale
"Excellent bagels and breakfast sandwiches. The "Famous Hobo" sandwich hit the spot! Long lines due to COVID and clusters right at the..."
Maria Andrianos
"Arrive here for Sunday morning bagels and got to try the veggie special on a flagel (flat bagel)! They have many cream cheeses, vegan cream cheese..."
Helen L
"Great bagels like most other goldbergs. They had ran out of plain bagels when I went but times are strange. I posted a picture of the line out the..."
Brett Goffin
"Very good food, breakfast and sandwich for the fishing trip. Very convenient. Open early. Nice staff. Will be back for..."
Aticha Gabulon
"⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Perfect spot for pre/post beach eats🤤 Lox flagel🫶🏼 Spicy Hobo👌🏼 Spicy Powerhouse💪🏽 Worth the..."
Jeffrey Pammer
"Their "flagels" (flat bagels) are fun and their BEC / Lox & Cream Cheese are solid. Will be..."
Jason Zhao
"Amazing bagels with lots of great choices, and an incredibly friendly..."
Sebastian Armstrong
"Great bagels and pleasant service. Crowded but bagels are best in..."
Bradford Buonasera
"Pleasantly surprise by this spot in Montauk! The servers were super friendly and made a great..."
Nicole Ginger