Great authentic dishes and a decent seating layout. The food options are visible through the counter and everything is flavorful. The black beans and rice is pretty awesome and the portion sizes are just right for a full belly that you can rub after the last bite.
Goat was good but I could use a bit more habanero<--Jamaican. Love the staff. A must stop reach time in in town.
This place is amazing, must try if in the area — the food is authentic and spot on, I tried all of their chickens and beef, very juicy and scrumptious
Sweet Bananas not good. Every time I ordered they looked and tasted like they were cooked days ago. They were stuck together and had no taste.
Food so good your taste buds will slap your momma. Bread pudding is to die for. You will need to order a to go plate before you leave that's how good the food is.
Delicious food, well done meat. Amazing customer service. May God bless them.
I’m Puerto Rican from Brooklyn. I hadn’t eaten Spanish food in 2 weeks while doing business in Liberty NY. I rolled the dice and made a 13 mile drive to Nelly’s. The food was exactly what I wanted. Hands down authentic Spanish food.
The food was delicious! Reminded me of my Dominican grandmother’s food, it was kind of like tasting home
Great food, nice environment and very good service!
I recommend.
I randomly thought about this place and decided that I’d leave a review just based off of my memory of how much I loved the food and the actual restaurant. It’s been almost 4 years since I’ve been to in the states, after moving back home to the USVI. Was in the East Coast for Job Corps, and visiting Monticello was a gift for me, making sure to stop at Nelly’s on Broadway every time I went. The food is like a piece of home, and did not disappoint in the slightest. Everything on the menu is amazing. My personal favorites are the pernil, stew beef, and baked chicken. The seasoned rice tastes like home too. Servers were always so sweet and welcoming, and dining in was a nice, calm pleasure. If I ever make it back to the area, first thing I’m doing is getting me some Nelly’s lol!
I'm a picky eater. The food was great!!! Amazing service too.
Delicious, authentic, Spanish food, located in the little town of Monticello. Soon as you walk in your greated with the amazing aroma of the good they have to offer. Everything has been fantastic, but definitely try the roasted chicken, pollo and Carne guisado, and red beans!
Food was amazing!! Good option if you have a taste for some Dominican Food.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes