I don't write reviews really but, the bagels were very large light and fluffy. They were great and Anna the girl that helped me was such a nice person. It was a great experience
I’ve tried pretty much every deli in the area and they make the best Breakfast sandwich so far.
Excellent egg sandwich this morning. Home fries are absolutely delicious! Will be back again!
VERY grateful to Brian for waiting after closing for me to pick up my order. Not a good week for a multitude of reasons and I forgot I placed my order for pick up. I called, he said no worries, if not today another time I can pick up a replacement order. THIS is why I travel there. So kind, accommodating and always a kind word. And let's not forget the yummy bagels. ALWAYS a hit in my household. Oodles of thanks Bagels Your Way, we will be back.
![5]( "Recensione")
I grew up nearby & was visiting my family on LI over Easter. We were in the area & stopped by, and I am so glad we did! I always try to grab a bagel locally when I'm visiting because there's NOTHING like a good Long Island bagel (& I lived in the city for almost 20 years and still -- LI has got the best imho). Anyway, Bagels Your Way did NOT disappoint! I had an everything with scallion cream cheese & it was, quite frankly, one of the best I've had in a while! The bagel was nice and crisp on the outside with a slight chew, and soft on the inside without being too doughy - I personally judge how good a bagel is by eating it un-toasted (to me toasting is only for stale or subpar bagels lol). It had just the right amount of salt, too, and the cream cheese was delish. The coffee was also robust & brewed fresh, not weak or bitter like you might find in some spots. We also had a few bakery cookies and they were equally tasty. The staff was very friendly and helpful, too. I look forward to returning - definitely bringing some home next time! If you haven't been there yet, do yourself a favor & check it out!
Fantastic experience every Sunday morning. They have the most delicious pastries, the coffee is always brewing and of top quality. Most importantly, the chicken cutlets are the best I have ever had; always fresh and delicious. Many delis have sub par chicken cutlets, but this place has the absolute best!! Totally recommended.
Hailey, Sam, Jules, Daniel, Joan, Josie and Cathy have exceptional service as a resident of Mount Sinai and a customer, door dash and Ubereats driver they go above and beyond. Thank you for your hard work!!!
Good food friendly staff prices skyrocketed from 5.75 to 8.50 for a simple bacon egg a cheese on roll which is an absolute insult to customers but apparently everyone in the country has to screw the consumer these days
There can be small, minor inconsistencies but I feel the other low reviews are off base. Maybe it's not the same place it was 20 years ago but it is still the best bagel shop in the area.
This place is amazing. Big and fresh bagels 🥯
Best bagels I've found. Always soft. Good variety of coffee creamers too.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes