Best Bagels in Mount Sinai

2 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Strathmore Bagels
Strathmore Bagels
86/100 (158 ratings)
Bakeries
Cafe
Cafe
Lunch
Breakfast
Bagels
Café
Café
Breakfast
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Great place, great staff, classy ownership. 5 stars don't do it justice, they should get..."
Christian Carbone
"My family is so particular about their bagels and will only go here! And the staff is always so polite and engaging! Great job! Thank..."
Karen Dargo-Mullahey
"We're new to the area! We've been passing the shop for months now. I decided to take my husband to breakfast since he's been working so much! It was..."
Lucy Miller
"The Staff, Food and Service at Strathmore Bagels has been Great since day 1. You're Always Welcomed with a Warm Smile and Can I Help You by either..."
Sil Crino
"My first visit to Strathmore's was today. Staff went over and beyond to accommodate me. Great place! Spotless!..."
Catherine Calia
"Great owner, great bagels, great staff... Welcome to the..."
Abbe Garfinkel-Johnson
"Best Bagel shop in the area, and the workers are all..."
Duane Stearns
"Great food!!!!! Very nice people with a sense of humor!!!! Delivery is..."
Joanne O'Neil
"Just want to say they are the best bagels by far around here. The people that work there are very nice. Give them a try next time you are in the..."
Betty Gorecki
"Made pizza bagels for dinner the other night with your bagels. They were..."
Jennie Laager Cecere
"Best bagels around. Fantastic egg..."
Brian Taranto
"Bangin'..."
Dan Amendola
"My go to bagel place. Fav is toasted super egg bagel w cream cheese. Egg sandwiches are good, service and pricing are good as..."
Amy Lee
"This is my new go-to place. It's so clean, the staff is so accommodating, and the choices are perfect. I tried the avocado toast today and I'm in..."
Toni Ann Kashata
"Best bacon egg and cheese! The bagels are great..."
Jess Dean
"We only go here when we decide to use TooGoodToGo. So far, pretty good surprise bags but it's really a dangerous parking..."
Kristin Battaglia
"This bagel shop is the best. The bagels are the best on Long Island! The staff there is fantastic. Farrah, her sister and Zack make you feel so..."
David Arnold
"I am a frequent customer at Strathmore as of about half a year ago. Not only are the egg sandwiches delicious; the deli sandwiches are just as good !..."
Hailey Lois
"Great bagel place. The bagels are delicious and my sons favorite thing there is the fruit lemonade, it has great flavor. The girl that worked the..."
Danielle Maeda
"The staff is amazing! They were friendly and professional. The platters I ordered looked fantastic and were delivered on time. My guests and I were..."
lesley diamond
"⚡Lisa -The BEST Bagels I've Ever Seen. I had to get one. The Strawberry 🍓 one! Oh Man Out of this World! And the Crew is So Nice and efficient!..."
Lisa Lichelle Hill
"Great Food, Great Service, The Staff is Great, There's Welcoming Atmosphere that is Family Oriented which is what you would expect from a Family..."
sil crino
"i got delivery in the snow and the bagels came in around 15-20 minutes!! so tasty and fresh thank you! call up the store and order and don't use a..."
Jackie Guma
Bagels Your Way
Bagels Your Way
78/100 (67 ratings)
Bakeries
Lunch
Breakfast
Bagels
Breakfast
Lunch
"I don't write reviews really but, the bagels were very large light and fluffy. They were great and Anna the girl that helped me was such a nice..."
Dave Fry
"I’ve tried pretty much every deli in the area and they make the best Breakfast sandwich so..."
Ryan Munkwitz
"Excellent egg sandwich this morning. Home fries are absolutely delicious! Will be back..."
Shelley Smith
"VERY grateful to Brian for waiting after closing for me to pick up my order. Not a good week for a multitude of reasons and I forgot I placed my..."
AnnMarie Pszybylski
"I grew up nearby & was visiting my family on LI over Easter. We were in the area & stopped by, and I am so glad we did! I always try to grab a bagel..."
Kid Charlemagne
"Fantastic experience every Sunday morning. They have the most delicious pastries, the coffee is always brewing and of top quality. Most importantly,..."
James Canale
"Hailey, Sam, Jules, Daniel, Joan, Josie and Cathy have exceptional service as a resident of Mount Sinai and a customer, door dash and Ubereats driver..."
Anthony Boodhai
"Good food friendly staff prices skyrocketed from 5.75 to 8.50 for a simple bacon egg a cheese on roll which is an absolute insult to customers but..."
mark lewandowski
"There can be small, minor inconsistencies but I feel the other low reviews are off base. Maybe it's not the same place it was 20 years ago but it is..."
Chris Somerlot
"This place is amazing. Big and fresh bagels..."
Echo Five Photography
"Best bagels I've found. Always soft. Good variety of coffee creamers..."
Cassandra DiSalvo