For carry out, call well in advance. Expect wait times of at least 30+ minutes. There will always be a soft spot in my heart for Sicilian, but this just seemed undercooked and there wasn’t much flavor. Staff was extremely friendly.
Stopped in for lunch. Tasty sauce, plenty of cheese, yes, please! On the thinner side, which I love. Tbh not a fan of thick, doughy crust. I think I've found a place that I can love. A+ on fast service and real pizza tossers. Also points for real deal pizza ovens. 🍕
We ordered 2 lunch specials, one slice spinach pizza, and one order of hot wings and paid $34... the online menu posted by a reviewer is outdated. Prices are higher.
They forgot the wings when they gave us our order so we got them later. Overall, the food was pretty good but for the price we could've had an entire pizza and wings elsewhere.
Good NY style pizza, cold beer and nice staff.
Amazing pizza. That thin NY style crust, loaded with cheese and toppings. We drive the extra 20 minutes just to eat here.
I had a steak and cheese sub, a slice of pepperoni pizza, and a order of hot wings. The pizza and sub were pretty good. I would get it again, but I would pass on the wings. The wings were too dry and tough. You could get better wings from pizza hut. Service was quick and awesome.
Love it here! Food is always fresh & tasty, service always feels welcoming & homey. The only issue is how hot it gets in there during the spring & summer. Open air kitchens can be tricky just prepare for it if you're dining in and have an issue in heat. Other then that ya can't beat the prices for the amount of food given & location.
If you are looking for REAL New York Pizza or delicious Italian food this is the place. After a long day of moving my family and I were done for the day with no energy left to cook. So I had everyone look at the menu that was available on Google. It definitely needed a revamp so I have provided a better picture. The only thing missing on their menu are the multitude of dessert options which I will be trying on my next go round. I wish they had their options listed on the menu, but if your calling in your order ahead of time, just don’t forget to ask. I have also provided a picture of all the dessert and salad display below. I decided to go and order in person to give myself a chance to get better pictures for my review, since this is the 3rd or 4th time I’ve been here and every time has been amazing. Last time, I had their lunch special 2 pizza slices (from their pizza display, shown below) and a drink.
They’re setup inside is so clean with a good atmosphere and friendly customer service. As I walked up to the counter I was greeted right away, and the lady at the register was very accommodating. I gave her my order which I also took pictures of all the plates below except the spaghetti and meatballs plate which was for my 7 year old. While I getting everyone’s meals out, he was so excited about how BIG and tasty the meatballs were in his spaghetti he dug in and ate half the dish before I could get a picture.
Each of the noodle dinners comes with a side salad. We ordered the Lasagna, Stuffed Shells (which come with Marinara sauce), and Spaghetti & Meatballs. My mom loves the Margarita Pizza slice, and also ordered a slice of the Sicilian (but was so full she hasn’t tried it yet, so I will update my review as soon as soon as she lets me know, but it looked awesome).
The pizza crust flavor is amazing. I know there are some places that have “New York Pizza” but when you get it it feels like your eating cardboard. I’m here to tell you... this is the best Pizza crust. It has flavor with a crispy outside and soft inside. I chose to try their Calzone and added my 5 favorite toppings which I ate over 2 meals, lunch and dinner.
The last picture I took was of the hot sub my nephew order, a small Italian sub. It came with all the fixings and when I say small that’s just what they call it. The sub in the picture below is only showing half the sandwich so you can see it with the inside ingredients. He said he would be ordering it again.
I can definitely say this will be our family pizza spot from here on out until we get a chance to visit New York again.
Great New York style pizza. Already been there numerous times. Try the pinwheel. You won't regret it
I really want to give 5 stars but can’t since something’s been annoying the past three times I picked up my order from there. I keep coming back because the pizza is amazing. This time my order had been ready the entire time I was there. When I arrived, I walked up to the counter and told the cashier my name and order and she told me it wasn’t ready. I then waited 30 minutes until I decided to go up and ask for an eta only to find that it was ready when I got there. Like…. How and why? It’s not hard… you say a number and the cooks tell you if it’s ready or not. Last time someone who I won’t mention but seems to be the one that always is messing peoples orders up forgot to put meatballs on the pizza so he “fixed it” by cooking waaaaaaaaaaaay too many meatballs and putting them on top. Which is cool I guess but I really didn’t want that many, just wanted a normal amount. However, I appreciate the sentiment. And the last time before that they made the entirely wrong pizza so I cancelled it and ordered papa John’s. So all this to say that your pizza is always amazing, but your staff really needs to pay attention, read the tickets, call the right order numbers, etc. I’ve been a chef for 15 years…. I know good work is hard to find, but I also know that reading tickets and calling correct numbers is easy. You guys are doing great and your pizza is amazing, but there’s a lot of room for improvement. Here’s the key to success with this…. Just pay attention and make every order as if you were making it for yourself. I also want to add that I can’t even tell you how much money y’all have missed out on by not allowing tips on cards! Just sayin
So far the best pizza I've found in Myrtle Beach. Close to the New York pizza I'm used to.
Prices are reasonable. A very casual atmosphere, comfortable and enjoyable.
As a former New Yorker from Queens, I can attest this is REAL NY pizza. Believe their high reviews their food is that good as well as the atmosphere. Sicilian is to die for lol. Here's a pic. Have to stop by the restaurant if you're a local or if you're visiting out of town (I'm working from Florida closeby)
We ordered the pepperoni and the white pizza. This is REAL NY pizza! It was very good!! Flavor was great, crust was tasteful! 100% recommend!! Staff was extremely nice and welcoming, even with our large family! Will be coming back!!
Pizza was amazing! Love the thin crust and plenty of toppings. We all ordered pizza by the slice and it was hot and fresh. We tried buffalo chicken pizza, pepperoni and white pizza. Delicious!
Relaxed atmosphere. Amazed that we were served so quickly! We ordered an entire pizza and followed about five others who had done the same. Very short wait to get excellent food!!
TRUE NY PIZZA!!! So good!!!!!!!
Limoncello cake was so amazing!!
Not only is their pizza absolutely amazing, but the people who work their are so incredibly kind. It’s just an all over great place to go!
My first time there and I wasn't disappointed, if I ever return to Myrtle Beach I definitely will go there again, it was great to actually see pizza dough being thrown up and stretched, so yummy 🤤
Lisa Lopes (Lisanimals)
+5
Husband and I are from out of town and decided we wanted pizza. this was so delicious. Probably the best pizza I’ve had in so long !
I’ve been coming here weekly for the past 3 years and never disappoints! Their buffalo chicken is the best around. Great atmosphere and friendly staff.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes