Best Bagels in Mystic

3 restaurant menus in Mystic, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Lis Bake Shop
Lis Bake Shop
96/100 (367 ratings)
Dessert
Bakeries
Quick Bites
American
Cafe
American
Breakfast
Almond Raspberry Thumbprints
Breakfast Sandwich
Blueberry Cornbread
Tomato Basil Bagel with Pastrami
Bagels
Quiche
Cranberry Cornbread
Cinnamon roll
Schooners Lemonade
Blueberry Muffin
Cupcakes
Raspberry Almond Cake
Cakes
Raspberry Brownie
Pastries
Butterscotch Blondie
milk tea
Quiche
Cider Doughnut
Breve Latte
Apple Crisp Cheesecake
Crazy Bagel
Raspberry Oat Bar
Strawberry Cheesecake Blondie
Cranberrylemonpoppy Muffin
Café
Café
American
Seating
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Breakfast
Cheap Eats
"I LOVE this shop. I highly recommend it to everyone. I've not had one thing that isn't excellent. I now visit weekly for coffee and bring home a few..."
Charlene Marie Malbaurn
"The best baked goods I have ever had- the peanut butter, oatmeal, chocolate-chip cookies are to die for. And the staff is lovely- they make my day..."
Pamela Stone
"I try to limit how many times I go into this tempting shop, but it's a losing battle. I first found their chocolate croissants, then I spotted some..."
Liz Viering
"Lis Bakery is a must stop whenever we are in Mystic! The most friendly staff and delicious food! They always put the exclamation point on our..."
Todd Strickett
"We are visiting from Missouri and this bakery has fabulous tasty treats as well as frosty drinks. Wonderful delightful..."
Elizabeth White Sparks
"The best I've ever had...visiting from VT and on our way home stopped,in for some goodies for my mom. Hubby and I shared a blueberry corn cake..."
Christine Morin Hutchins
"LIS is absolutely the BEST! The cupcakes are AMAZING!❤️ This morning we had the egg sandwiches (on a bagel or croissant) which, by the way were..."
Candace Copp Jacobs
"Love,love,love this bake shop! This a a definite stop in Mystic every time we are in the area! You will not be..."
Diane Smicherko
"What a great place! Definitely don't find quaint bake shops like this one in New York! Cupcakes were out of this world! Even thinking of heading..."
Alane Sofia-Caridi
"The only bakery I've ever been in - anywhere - where everything actually looks homemade and tempting, not artificial - looking, lacquered with tons..."
Emily Balducci-Cardone
"Best cupcake I've ever had, and I can't wait to come back and try some of the many other delicious pastries and cakes you bake. I regret that I..."
Gail Belliveau Brooks
"The quality is amazing, the choices are limitless, all with great customer service. It's the only place to go in..."
Desiree Paquette
"Wanted to eat everything I saw. They offered my peanut butter cookies right out the oven - YUM! we shared apple..."
Jacquie Cohen Roth
"Do yourself a favor and get a cheddar jalapeno bagel. Don't forget one of their delicious chocolate croissants, and while you're at it you won't find..."
Pat Gotham
"While waiting for our little Boat Ride; We got coffee and scratch cinnamon Buns and an Egg Sandwich. It was Quaint & so Delicious. Just a..."
Debra Webb
"Wow! I stopped in for almond raspberry cookies that Li (pronounced Lee) posted on Facebook. They're great! The cookie is very buttery shortbread with..."
Mike Sullivan
"List Bake Shop has the best cinnamon rolls! I am also a big fan of their chocolate chip caramel sea salt cookies! I love that they have a takeout..."
Cassandra Meyer-Ogren
"Excellent place to have breakfast..bagels with pastrami or chorizo..both are..."
j dunaway
"Great dark roast coffee! They had the best lemon bar with a great biscuit bottom. Couldn't help myself and ended up ordering one of their almond..."
I'm One
"Mouthwatering baked goods. Cupcakes, brownies, croissants, quiche, bagels... I've never had anything less than truly exceptional from Li's. It's a..."
Molly Homchenko
"Amazing little bakery! Their apple cake is the tastiest sweet treat I’ve had for a while, and their gingerbread and devil dogs are also great. I..."
Alyssa Jones
"I recently found out I had to go gluten-free and Lis Bakeshop had so many choices for My Birthday plus bought yummys for my family - everything was..."
deb mercier
Vault Coffee Roasters
Vault Coffee Roasters
89/100 (446 ratings)
Coffee & Tea
Quick Bites
Cafe
American
Breakfast
Bagels
"Excellent espresso, best I've ever had! And on the weekend their "Deviant Donuts" are to die for. Absolutely incredible experience, I will be..."
Samantha Liotta
"Great place! Everything was so delicious and fresh. You can taste the quality of the ingredients they use. A must..."
Kristen Wimberly
"Wow! I used to pass by you guys until a friend insisted I try your coffee and now I find myself going as much as possible! You guys are a new..."
Stephanie Owens
"This is my favorite spot to enjoy amazing coffee and atmosphere if on ever on that side of the bridge. They are always kind, & make u feel at home. ..."
Anita Marcelo Lucas
"Enjoyed Vault's super-delicious iced chai latte! -- but even better, the thoughtful staff found my lost wallet and returned it safely to me. Such a..."
Bridget Clark Rymer
"Delicious coffee, amazing service, with beautiful foam art. A must visit in..."
Sarah Grace
"Delicious beverages and great baked goods! A place with real barista's who care about what you..."
Corina Malbaurn
"Seriously great coffee! In an area surrounded by Starbucks, McDonald's, and Friendly's, Vault is a breath of fresh air. We live in lower Manhattan,..."
Lynda Lippin
"Hazelnut latte was excellent!! Superb..."
Amir Solan
"Great coffee and a very friendly staff. Definitely be going..."
Christopher Bruckner
"New favorite in Mystic! Awesome coffee and..."
Jacque Simpson Gilson
"Delicious coffee, great service, prepared by great..."
Dan Postupack
"I may have a bias, but Vault has a great atmosphere, great staff, and the products taste great! I'm not an iced coffee person, but the Black Velvet..."
Christof Ambrosch
"The vault may be the best coffee I have ever experienced. Boston and New York coffee shops cannot compare. They also have deviant donuts on the..."
Dabcrate
"Cute little coffee shop inside olde mystic village. I would highly recommend the treasure island smoothie or the coffee frappe. Both were tasty..."
Tracey K Denholm
"Our second visit to Vault in Mystic... Their coffee and tea are excellent. A great little coffee shop tucked away where you'd least expect it. The..."
Mike Easter
"**Vault Coffee is also Deviant Donuts.** Good, solid mocha. Wasn't crazy about the blueberry cinnamon roll, but that happens. I really wish that..."
Jenna McKinney
"Not just a great coffee shop. You must check out Deviant Donuts selection offered on the weekends! Also offer bagels, smoothies, and teas. Also, have..."
Sindi Mannochi
"I love their Village Latte (Hot Chocolate and Coffee) which pairs very well with any of the Deviant Donuts that are available there. Short wait and..."
Donovan Maguigan
"The coffee and tea are good, and the blueberry muffin was exceptionally good (I can only assume the rest of them are excellent too!) No WiFi though,..."
Brian Barnett
"I stopped in mystic and stumbled upon this coffee shop. Friendly staff and good cold brew. A bonus was discovering the Deviant Donuts they sell on..."
Vincent Finelli
Green Marble Coffee House
Green Marble Coffee House
75/100 (253 ratings)
Coffee & Tea
Cafe
Dinner
Breakfast
Bagels
"Great coffee! They had almond milk which I appreciated because we have a milk allergy in the family. The house-made cream cheese was amazing. I used..."
Maggie P
"Hits the spot. Great coffee. Amazing bagels and in house cream..."
Greg
"This place is great! I was passing through Mystic and when I was walking around I stumbled upon this place. The lady working at this coffee house was..."
Sue She
"I really like this coffee shop, despite two serious liabilities: 1.) No bathroom, 2.) Temperature disregulation that leaves the inside of the cafe..."
Dane Muckler
"A wonderful hidden coffee shop off the main street. Head down the alley way and enter this quaint and fairly spacious shop with friendly staff and..."
Charles Silvey
"Great place and great coffee, ground and brewed all day! This plaxe has a great variety of house roasted beans! A great selection best Bagels you..."
Michael Coulter
"Coffee was mediocre but I thoroughly enjoyed their bagels. I was so disappointed to find out that they ran out of the sunflower seed bagels (it is..."
Pinky Chan
"This shop is more about feel than about 'did they get my order perfect'? The menu is not bad, the service is pretty decent, maybe you need to add..."
Bradley Dahl