11 restaurant menus in Nantucket, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"Omg !!!! That food ... and this drinks ... speeches... just incredible delicious.
Place is really small and really crowded.
Really difficult to make..."
Stacey McKenzie
"Incredible food and service! Everything we had was so delicious. Would definitely recommend and will definitely be back.
You have to get a..."
Anthony Saltarelli
"A must go!!! For now they are only doing phone call booking after 2pm for the same day dinner, so make sure you call right after 2pm. They are..."
gammeelovemusic
"The Nautilus is an Asian-fusion restaurant, and it was our favorite restaurant on the island. We tried a few dishes, and the Peking duck was our..."
Joey Allen
"We went to the Nautilus based on positive reviews online. Our server Sam was very friendly and professional. We ordered the tuna poke, tempura oyster..."
Dan Yong
"This place was DIVINE! Food was delicious - the poke bowl was elevated and delicious, crab fried rice was soooo yummy, the pork buns rocked, and the..."
Joanne Weaver
"Delicious food and drinks. Lamb was the best. Need to reserve a table ahead of time but definitely a must go to while visiting..."
"I think it's 4 stars. My partner thinks it's 5 so compromising to a 5.
Overall, I think this place has great ideas but the execution is slightly..."
Jesse Tao
"Great place with Intimate atmosphere.
Drinks are great.
Food for most of it taste delicious.
Some of the dishes are overpriced for the their size.
I..."
Stacey McKenzie
"I’ve been in the restaurant business for 30 years. I’m incredibly discerning and live to eat. I usually don’t expect much from Nantucket..."
mvjason1
"Delayed review but we loved this restaurant. I love the chicken dish and my fiancé loves the pork chop. So..."
Emily Smith
"Great atmosphere and amazing service. Stellar food options I would recommend the kale salad and octopus for starters. The lobster pasta did not..."
Matthew DePorre
"This was one of the best meals I had in a long time. Great quaint place, great service. The kale Caesar salad was out of this world, and I typically..."
Marc Pagnier
"Just had an outstanding experience here. After not having been to Oran Mor in years, I finally decided to give it another shot. Love the overall vibe..."
"The food is good! I got the fried clam with slaw. The price is good too. The place was small inside only enough to order and buy fresh fish, so you..."
Anna Mae Remaneses
"Nice fried food spot. The scallops and salmon were great. The fries were pretty good. The crab cakes were covered in breading and were not good to..."
Todays Present
"This place has the freshest fish and seafood! Everything we ordered was super delicious and fresh! One of our favorites! Not much seating but a lot..."
Ali & Nic
"Great fresh seafood. A local suggested it for us and we were not disappointed. You have to take it to go or eat it outside, but it is so fresh and..."
Cathy Mathias
"Great place for fresh and tasty seafood! My son, who previously visited what seems to be a hidden gem, insisted we visit and it didn't disappoint! ..."
Tracy Clark
"This is one of those places that is absolutely not high end, fancy, or anything like that. Don't get me wrong....it's by no means a dump. It is a..."
Deb D
"Ordered a bunch of seafood for the family and they packaged it all up and we ate it at home. Lobsters were pre-cracked everything was delicious and..."
Conrad Miller
"Good and cheap, for Nantucket. I love their honey chicken and calamari. Their chowder tastes just like what my grandma used to..."
"On the water and the decor is perfect! Cozy, stylish rustic - chic yacht theme. But aside from that the service was great and the food was..."
Jennifer Dawn Hubbard
"CRU Nantucket, enviously located on the harbor waterfront with a spot-on classic interior design aesthetic. Chic factor?: I shared a cushioned..."
Geoffrey von Barton III
"Cru Nantucket- wonderful place, excellent service, Würzburger Hofbräu from my hometown in Germany. The best Calamari I ever had! Worth coming from..."
Uwe Roblick
"I loved it ... Food and service were excellent .We had an awesome meal . The Fluke was to die..."
Marthahall Ramadan
"Excellent place that is more professional based atmosphere! Higher prices than the average on Nantucket but you get what you pay for... excellent..."
Lois Vigue
"Cru provides the most amazing food, beverages, atmosphere, staff and customer service in general! It was so wonderful we went back a second time...."
Gretchen E Vaughan
"Had drinks and appetizers on their gorgeous, comfy patio. The local oysters were by far the best I have ever had. Also had a beet hummus that was..."
Linda Preble Swanson
"Best Bloody Mary's hands down! Service ,food and atmosphere awsome ! Muscles and shrimp cocktail highly recommended! Chris was out server he was..."
Andrea Barney
"Fabulous food, service, ambiance and view. Highly recommend a visit to..."
Terri Ryan Sullivan
"The ambiance was great. The service was excellent and the food was amazingly delicious!!. I had the fried calamari and the buttered lobster. They..."
Crichton De la Haye
"A must go to on the island!! Have the lobster roll at night. It's orgasmic!!!!..."
Karyn Pallotta
"Best lobster roll and shrimp cocktail on the planet and amazing service. Thanks..."
Peter E. Hutchins
"The hype is real and well-deserved. The waterfront views and the atmosphere are unbeatable. First time here, came for a birthday dinner on Memorial..."
Pablo M
"Went for dinner last night and everything was outstanding. Our waiter was very attentive and had great recommendations. We had some oysters, the..."
Scott Briggs
"Great spot for long lunches and fancy dinners. Food is New England seafood that they take up a notch. The warm and cold lobster rolls are amazing...."
Doug Leighton
"My husband and I celebrated our 30th anniversary here, and the service and food were amazing! I had no issue with making our reservation (made July..."
Kathleen Flora
"You can’t get reservations here, but the bar is first come first serve so we just walked in and sat down for lunch. And if you were mildly shocked..."
Robin R Johnson
"Must do in Nantucket. We had a lovely New England experience seated by a window inside over looking the boats. The lobster roll was one of the best..."
Colby Harris
"Very good food, great party atmosphere. We ate here before catching the Ferry and it was worth the wait. Lobster Roll was amazing and my wife's..."
Sean Keeley
"CRU’s location is great, right by the harbor, with wonderful view. The service is very good, deserves 20% fixed tip, especially when you compared..."
"Make a reservation prior to dining. The restaurant was packed and very busy. Thankfully our server Kenzie was amazing! She was pleasant and attentive..."
Julianna King
"A delicious dinner, great wine selection and friendly staff. Every course was plated beautifully. The wait time was short. No reservations needed...."
Lucia Briones
"We were one of the first customers, wanted to try the place and sat at the bar as they were very busy. We had tuna tartare, mussels and fried clams ,..."
Paula Jaros
"The Sea Grille was quite a distance from downtown, however it was good. The surf n turf was just "good". I passed on both the appetizers and dessert...."
Nicole Remsburg
"Such a good supper. The salmon was so delicious. And the seafood tower was so..."
Kimberli Maki-Smith
"Susie our server was fabulous. Had the Scallops and Ceasar to start. Sole Picatta Lobster Ravioli and Yellowfin was delish!!!
Nice atmosphere away..."
Aunt Barbara
"We were greeted quickly and put at a comfortable table. Our Server was on point especially for a group of nine. Our server kept the drinks flowing..."
"The Rustica Pizza is the best slice I have ever eaten. My favorite thing on the..."
Chris Shackleton
"Excellent!All down the line.Every meal I've ordered has been..."
Mark Reindel
"Intimate, deliciously consistent, warm and friendly....I love Pi Pizzeria almost as much as the owners. Truthfully, there isn't a better pizza on..."
Susan Jemison
"One of our favorite restaurants on the island. My husband loves the steak. We love the cold appetizer small plates, the olive tampanade. I love the..."
Patricia Victoria
"The food at Pi Pizza is insane and any review that is less that a 5 has been written by a..."
Liz Cannavo Gruber
"Ahhh Pi Pizzeria! So many reasons to go! Best pasta on the island! Incredible lunch and dinner specials! Oh, and the only wood fired oven and..."
Doreen Costanzo
"Pi Has fantastic pizza, amazing pasta and perfect tiramisu!! All served in a warm, cozy atmosphere. We love this..."
Carrie Culp
"Love it all! Best steak on the island! Friendly staff makes all the..."
Gretchen Gigi Callahan
"All of my meals here have been amazing !!! 5 stars..."
Lisa Bouchard
"Best Pizza on the Island! Try the Mozzarella..."
Lee Milazzo
"Without a doubt the fall is back and Pi is perfect for the crisp nights. John Burdock is amazing. Always so welcoming. Will gladly wait for seats at..."
Tanya Jill McDonough
"Pi Pizza if I had to describe it in one word "Quality"it's evident in every bite,And the hospitality warms me it's like visiting family (you know the..."
Robert Souza
"Great Staff and Best Food in a truly Fun Atmosphere. What every neighborhood restaurant should..."
Dave Ryan
"I never write reviews but I feel like this is what it's all about!! You completely satisfied my craving tonight!! My husband came with a margarita..."
Darya Afshari
"I love Pi Pizzeria - Pizza, Pasta and INCREDIBLE Daily Specials for Dinner! I also love to eat lunch their because not crazy..."
Malcolm Brooks
"The best pizza in Nantucket. My favorite better than NJ or NY. Get the clams as..."
Sheri Matarese
"I have had the pleasure of going to Pi Pizzeria only once as I only get to Nantucket for work, but good lord was it wonderful.
First of all, the..."
Chris Vaughn
"The pizza was great and the owners were extremely..."
Sweetburrito
"Pizza was amazing. Staff was super friendly and considering how busy it was, pizza came out super quick. Thin, cooked perfectly, and hit the spot...."
Douglas Macedo
"Charming place with good food, good service and a great atmosphere. I love their pizza and steak but my personal favorite is Esposito's Sausage..."
"The service and staff was great and the food is amazing!!! Delicious! The street corn is to die for (amongst other great food). The location is great..."
Brenda Lee Cáceres
"Always our fave place when we come to Nantucket. The food is phenomenal and so are the drinks...."
Theresa Harmon
"Absolutely best calamari! Always make it a point to stop in and have it each..."
Marla Stoddard Booker
"Great restuarant for lunch and dinner. Loved their raw bar offerings, great casual dionong experience with delicious food and..."
Rene Gilbert
"Really, really good food. Steak. Scallops. Tuna Steak. All insanely good. Thanks to Affordable Rentals for the..."
David Nicholson
"A hidden gem on Nantucket. Good drinks, great service and amazing..."
John Buckey
"We always enjoy dining or "sipping" with you. Yesterday was no exception. Great service and delicious food in a beautiful..."
Rance M. Sanders
"Best Rum Runner on the Rock Jonas and crew kick ass...."
Rick Peterson
"Amazing food and service! The dynamite sauce is so good. Great..."
Samantha Hackney
"Tasty! Great cup of chowder and lots more! Great service! We enjoyed it a..."
Lisa Norris
"For first time we visited This restaurants fresh foods and good..."
Nuntinee Kungsawarn
"Excellent food, delivered to our slip behind the restaurant. We are able to have our fancy anniversary dinner while the kids watch movies in the v..."
Amy Ballentine
"We rented out Slip '14 for our wedding welcome party, and had an absolute BLAST! Brennen & Tim were so easy to work with! Our guests were thoroughly..."
Marissa Meli
"Fun place for lunch or dinner. Right at the end of the dock. Super casual. Prices are good for Nantucket. Friendly..."
Aunt Barbara
"Nice spot tucked in by the pier. Only went for cocktails which were good. Friendly staff. Nantucket prices..."
Jake Lee
"The oysters were so good I ate them with out cocktail sauce. And the espresso martinis kept us warm against the wind..."
Sara Ann
"Best place on Nantucket for food and..."
TheMilencio213
"Scallop roll was really excellent on a brioche roll. Perfect..."
"We had a fantastic experience at Fusaro's! The atmosphere was beautiful and clean. Our waiter was very pleasant and professional. The food? Oh the..."
Maine Point Marketing
"One of the best values on Nantucket. Authentic Italian food served by a nice staff. Their Caesar salad is really good too one of our favorites. Pasta..."
Jon Zack
"The best Italian food on the island!
Comfy setting and wonderful staff. A must visit for visitors. Especially because no resy..."
Vishvaruchi G
"Wonderful place , excellent service so friendly and the food yumiiiii I got the scallops pasta was very very well done love it..."
claudia valle
"Great service and awesome food. Had the Nantucket Scallops, Fettuccini Alfredo with chicken, Linguini and Clams, Scallop Chowder, and Eggplant..."
"Really enjoyed the selections and the location is right near the ferry. Good place to kill time waiting for the boat but also looks like a fun place..."
Matt S
"Good selection of local beers and nice view overlooking the water. Seems like it’s always packed as it’s right in the downtown area. Nice place..."
Maddy A
"Our server, Kelly, was wonderful. Very attentive, friendly, helpful and not pushy at all. We were seated outside by the host immediately who knew a..."
Kate Bartholomew
"Good for having a drink while watching the island life pass..."
M Alone
"After a long trip from NY, once we got off the boat to land in Nantucket, this is the first awesome spot to get a drink, so strong that we felt so..."
M H
"Ate there yesterday. Burgers wonderful. Waitress attentive. Always go there when on..."
CAROLYN STAHLER JIGERJIAN
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes