3 restaurant menus in Nantucket, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"After reading all of the mixed reviews on here, we didn’t know what to expect! We were pleasantly surprised to find delicious food and incredible..."
Anthony Saltarelli
"Great fresh food and awesome drinks. Can’t say enough about this place…. A must try if you like Italian when on Nantucket. The meatballs are..."
Scott Briggs
"Nice what I would call italia style restaurant. Nice selection of small plates, pasta and then mians. We were in for a light quick meal and it..."
Richard Stratton
"I started with the rabbit pasta and it was fantastic, I would place it in my top 3 pasta dishes ever! My main course was a very tender and jucie lamb..."
"The Rustica Pizza is the best slice I have ever eaten. My favorite thing on the..."
Chris Shackleton
"Excellent!All down the line.Every meal I've ordered has been..."
Mark Reindel
"Intimate, deliciously consistent, warm and friendly....I love Pi Pizzeria almost as much as the owners. Truthfully, there isn't a better pizza on..."
Susan Jemison
"One of our favorite restaurants on the island. My husband loves the steak. We love the cold appetizer small plates, the olive tampanade. I love the..."
Patricia Victoria
"The food at Pi Pizza is insane and any review that is less that a 5 has been written by a..."
Liz Cannavo Gruber
"Ahhh Pi Pizzeria! So many reasons to go! Best pasta on the island! Incredible lunch and dinner specials! Oh, and the only wood fired oven and..."
Doreen Costanzo
"Pi Has fantastic pizza, amazing pasta and perfect tiramisu!! All served in a warm, cozy atmosphere. We love this..."
Carrie Culp
"Love it all! Best steak on the island! Friendly staff makes all the..."
Gretchen Gigi Callahan
"All of my meals here have been amazing !!! 5 stars..."
Lisa Bouchard
"Best Pizza on the Island! Try the Mozzarella..."
Lee Milazzo
"Without a doubt the fall is back and Pi is perfect for the crisp nights. John Burdock is amazing. Always so welcoming. Will gladly wait for seats at..."
Tanya Jill McDonough
"Pi Pizza if I had to describe it in one word "Quality"it's evident in every bite,And the hospitality warms me it's like visiting family (you know the..."
Robert Souza
"Great Staff and Best Food in a truly Fun Atmosphere. What every neighborhood restaurant should..."
Dave Ryan
"I never write reviews but I feel like this is what it's all about!! You completely satisfied my craving tonight!! My husband came with a margarita..."
Darya Afshari
"I love Pi Pizzeria - Pizza, Pasta and INCREDIBLE Daily Specials for Dinner! I also love to eat lunch their because not crazy..."
Malcolm Brooks
"The best pizza in Nantucket. My favorite better than NJ or NY. Get the clams as..."
Sheri Matarese
"I have had the pleasure of going to Pi Pizzeria only once as I only get to Nantucket for work, but good lord was it wonderful.
First of all, the..."
Chris Vaughn
"The pizza was great and the owners were extremely..."
Sweetburrito
"Pizza was amazing. Staff was super friendly and considering how busy it was, pizza came out super quick. Thin, cooked perfectly, and hit the spot...."
Douglas Macedo
"Charming place with good food, good service and a great atmosphere. I love their pizza and steak but my personal favorite is Esposito's Sausage..."
"We had a fantastic experience at Fusaro's! The atmosphere was beautiful and clean. Our waiter was very pleasant and professional. The food? Oh the..."
Maine Point Marketing
"One of the best values on Nantucket. Authentic Italian food served by a nice staff. Their Caesar salad is really good too one of our favorites. Pasta..."
Jon Zack
"The best Italian food on the island!
Comfy setting and wonderful staff. A must visit for visitors. Especially because no resy..."
Vishvaruchi G
"Wonderful place , excellent service so friendly and the food yumiiiii I got the scallops pasta was very very well done love it..."
claudia valle
"Great service and awesome food. Had the Nantucket Scallops, Fettuccini Alfredo with chicken, Linguini and Clams, Scallop Chowder, and Eggplant..."
Brian MacDonald
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes