Best Ice Cream in Nantucket

7 restaurant menus in Nantucket, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
The Juice Bar Homemade Ice Cream
The Juice Bar Homemade Ice Cream
93/100 (1055 ratings)
Dessert
American
American
Late Night
Juice & Smoothies
Ice Cream Cone
Cookie Sandwich
Fresh Waffle Cone
Waffles
Rum and Raisin in Waffle Cup
Juice & Smoothies
Coffee Cake Ice Cream
Ice Cream
Coffee Ice Cream with Oreos
Jamaican Smoothie
Cakes
Café
American
Accepts Visa
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Late Night
Cheap Eats
The Proprietors Bar And Table
The Proprietors Bar And Table
92/100 (605 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
American
Vegan Options
American
Healthy
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Brunch
Scallops
Pancakes
Charcuterie
Flatbread
Salmon
Pasta
Swordfish
Avocado Tartine
Tapas
Cheese N Biscuits
Foie gras
Hamachi Crudo
Burger
Ribs
Fried Pig Ears
Red Lentil Hummus
Cavitelli
Shrimp
Hummus
Beet Little Gem Lettuce Salad
Beef
Sweet Potato
Octopus
Burata Toast
Tart
Cannelloni
Squids Stuffed
Lobster
Vesper
Ice Cream
Pancakes
Strawberry Shortcake
Halloumi
Bok Choy
Fish
Salad
Kimchi Pancake
Pork
Sit down
Healthy
American
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Reservations
Accepts American Express
Street Parking
Seating
Table Service
Accepts Discover
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Brunch
Dinner
Fine Dining
"This is my favourite restaurant on the planet. One dining experience per visit is never enough. Their menu is so creative and so extensive that I..."
Hannah Stone
"Excellent meal. Not your usual menu but everything we ordered was fabulous. I recommend the shishito peppers for an appetizer. Also the scallops were..."
Linda Austin
"Best food on Nantucket. Bone marrow and pig ears are a must..."
Kristie Ferrantella
"Great atmosphere, great staff and delicious food! Great experience..."
Jason Irving
"Drinks and apps at the bar! What the hell is this place!?!? Amazing cocktails...and the food was shockingly awesome! What a find...I am..."
Marissa Mathews
"Two nights in a row! Kevin and the crew at Proprietors took great care of me! I’ll keep coming..."
Chris Smela
"Our favorite place to eat on Nantucket!! Don't miss the pig ear..."
Rebecca Hammond Vaughan
"Outstanding food and excellent atmosphere. You owe it to yourself to try this place..."
Ed Nugent
"Love all the veggie options! And all of them are so..."
Jessica Sosebee
"Wow! I love farm to table restaurants ....this one is off the charts!! The food is amazing....,, full of flavor and so unique! You will not find..."
Karin Klarides Marinaro
"I loved it !! Slightly overpriced but I was on Nantucket the land of the..."
Peter Campisani
"Was seated on the second floor which had really nice vibe. All the plates were unique and vintage which were beautiful. Portion is bit small, but all..."
Joseph Kim
"Unique dining experience. Gourmet flavored food. NOT your traditional dining place. If you are open to try something new and discover new flavors..."
Stacey McKenzie
"Delicious and creative dishes! Our Server was wonderful. The atmosphere is so charming. We loved our meal and specialty cocktails- scallion..."
Your Other Woman Under the Umbrella
"Holy you know what. The Chicken Fried Trout was nothing short of incredible. In Oklahoma, we love anything wrapped in unhealthy fried goodness and..."
Graycen Mashburn
"Exceptional, unique dinner options, promptly served, with creative flavors in each bite. My definition of heaven. Don’t be afraid to try things on..."
Robin R Johnson
"This was a highlight of our Nantucket visits each of the past two summers. Creative, well-prepared food with layers of flavors, great staff who are..."
Michael
"I typically love this place. But last time we went we had a below average experience. All the food was great, but they brought out three of the four..."
Christina Flood
"Fantastic menu, service and atmosphere. It came highly recommended and did not disappoint. Really delighted that we spent our Saturday night in..."
Anton McMenamin
Yummy
Yummy
89/100 (94 ratings)
Restaurants
American
American
Lunch
Breakfast
Taco
Lobster Roll
Green Life Smoothie
Ice Cream
Muffin
Juice
Sweet Potato Fries
Falafel Salad
Ice Cream
Acai Bowl
Chicken Sandwich
Café
American
Parking Available
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Accepts Discover
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Breakfast
Lunch
Mid-range
"Fantastic little cafe with tasty treats and good coffee. The friendly staff showed personal care to my unique order (coffee to go so I could take it..."
Robin R Johnson
"Yummy is great! Have been multiple times are tried a few different things, and everything has been great! It is a nice place to stop going to or from..."
Joe Hutson
"Aleah was the best, beautiful smile, beautiful heart, can't wait to go back..food and service was..."
Marie Valero
"Yammy is always yammy!!!! Great stop for a quick bite on your way to the beach. Great sandwich options also this year they have many more - shakes,..."
Stacey McKenzie
"Amazing place to come eat with friends. The price it not bad as for parking space not much space. The service is great food is amazing and sitting..."
Onieka Richards
Nantucket Pharmacy Lunch Counter
Nantucket Pharmacy Lunch Counter
89/100 (105 ratings)
Quick Bites
Dessert
American
American
Lunch
Sandwiches
Grilled cheese
Tuna
Ice Cream
American
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"I went to Nantucket the day after Christmas. Almost everything was closed. I heard someone say the pharmacy had a lunch counter. They had sandwiches,..."
Billie
"The best pharmacy on-island hands down. Amazing staff, who will help you with everything you need. They have everything you might have forgot plus..."
Liz Skokan
"One of the best places to grab a bite to eat in the morning. I eat the Elvis at least 3 times a week! Also the breakfast sandwiches are the best! The..."
Ethan Bayzack
"Nantucket Pharmacy is the only pharmacy in downtown Nantucket and they do a GREAT job providing a variety of products and brands so there is..."
Emma Knutti
"A community conscious business. When out of Covid 19 masks, they gave them out at no charge. Always friendly, informative and customer focused. Their..."
Kevin Davidson
"A great neighborhood pharmacy with Ken the owner who makes it a very special..."
Joseph Keller
Ventuno
Ventuno
87/100 (1000 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Drinks
Dinner
Late Night
Meatballs
Salad
Suckling Pig
Crab
Ice Cream
Gelato
Scallops
Crostini
Clams
Lamb
Duck
Pesto
Oyster
Broccoli rabe
Fish
Risotto
Pork
Antipasti
Crostino
Swordfish
Halibut
Shrimp
Lobster
Polenta
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Seating
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Reservations
Table Service
Drinks
Dinner
Fine Dining
"After reading all of the mixed reviews on here, we didn’t know what to expect! We were pleasantly surprised to find delicious food and incredible..."
Anthony Saltarelli
"Great fresh food and awesome drinks. Can’t say enough about this place…. A must try if you like Italian when on Nantucket. The meatballs are..."
Scott Briggs
"Nice what I would call italia style restaurant. Nice selection of small plates, pasta and then mians. We were in for a light quick meal and it..."
Richard Stratton
"I started with the rabbit pasta and it was fantastic, I would place it in my top 3 pasta dishes ever! My main course was a very tender and jucie lamb..."
Connor McKeon
Stars Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt
Stars Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt
85/100 (53 ratings)
Dessert
Ice Cream
Sit down
Wheelchair Accessible
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Mid-range
"Love this place! Inexpensive compared to juice bar. Same great flavor. Definelty recommend the black raspberry..."
Alexandra Hart
"Super friendly staff and great ice..."
Rachel Michalek
"They have some of the best ice cream and best prices nantucket. The staff our very nice and very..."
Charlie A
"Best ice cream on the island. September 2003. ..."
Paul Manoli
"Lovely staff and great ice cream..."
kai bowker
"The vanilla milkshake was great on a hot..."
Mark Antilla
"Great ice..."
Oilevil
"Been going there for..."
John Smith
Jack And Charlie's Ice Cream
Jack And Charlie's Ice Cream
78/100 (247 ratings)
Restaurants
Quick Bites
Dessert
Cafe
Sorbet
Cotton Candy
Chocolate Chip Cookie
2 Scoop of Ice Cream
Bagel
Acai Bowl
Breakfast Sandwich
Rownie Waffle Cone
Vanilla and Salt Caramel Ice Cream
Ice Cream
Avocado toast
Cheap Eats
"Amazing ice cream! My favorite is the brownie batter - it's so rich and creamy! The homemade waffle cones are sooo good too! I also love the..."
Susan Renzulli
"The white chocolate macadamia cookie nut ice cream sandwich was to die for ��. Great family who own this..."
Carol Burdiss Miller
"Great place to grab a cone, sit outside and enjoy the..."
Peter Rockett
"Delicious ice cream and nice place to relax. Can't wait to go..."
Kristen Fish Warner
"Best ice cream around and awesome family! We stopped by daily during our recent island..."
Jessica Gelb
"Best ice cream on the island. They use real ingredients and you can taste the difference. It's so cute and so..."
Karen Gales