Pub cuisine: the best places to taste it in Nantucket
12 restaurant menus in Nantucket, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"Great local place. Open even winter time.
Great and cozy.
Drinks are always amazing.
Food is delicious.
Highly recommending the lobster Quesadilla,..."
Stacey McKenzie
"I sat at the bar since I was on my own. Ordered the buffalo chicken sandwich with garlic tots. The sandwich was great, but the tots weren’t..."
Molly Guest
"Charlie Noble is a fantastic place, not just for the food but the history of the location it's on is interesting as well.
The lobster mac'n'cheese..."
An-D T
"We went in the mid-afternoon on a Sunday after getting off the ferry. It wasn't busy so we got a table right away and the food was great. The chowder..."
Becky S
"Wanted to find a nice dinner spot for our last night on the island. They have a large patio with a great view. The fish and chips were pretty good..."
Matt S
"Didn't matter how many bites I took, every time I lifted the fork there was another lobster chunk. I have had dozens of lobster macs, this was the..."
scooby d
"Beautiful setting, friendly staff, and amazing food! I have celiacs and must order gluten free. They easily accommodated my needs and brought me the..."
"Had the onion soup and the chicken potstickers, and everything was delicious. Had a wonderful time sitting at the bar meeting new friends. Felt very..."
Molly Guest
"$5.00 Burger night every Tuesday, can't beat that deal. Don't want a beef burger same thing goes for a chicken patty burger.
$5.00 Burger Tuesdays..."
Homer Ray III
"Crosswinds is always a great place for an affordable meal. The ambiance is warm and aviation-themed, and the staff is friendly. An establishment full..."
D.G. Roggeveen
"Nothing more Nantucket than dinner or drinks here at Kitty’s ! Roaring fireplace and fantastic meals ... try the chicken dumpling splitters or any..."
barry gilliland
"Nice pub/bar. Service was great and quick despite the fact they were busy. I would come here..."
Nicole Locklear
"Cool local place. Great service and yummy food.
We love to go there Wednesday night for a Bingo.
Tuesdays are there burger nights and is so difficult..."
"The Rustica Pizza is the best slice I have ever eaten. My favorite thing on the..."
Chris Shackleton
"Excellent!All down the line.Every meal I've ordered has been..."
Mark Reindel
"Intimate, deliciously consistent, warm and friendly....I love Pi Pizzeria almost as much as the owners. Truthfully, there isn't a better pizza on..."
Susan Jemison
"One of our favorite restaurants on the island. My husband loves the steak. We love the cold appetizer small plates, the olive tampanade. I love the..."
Patricia Victoria
"The food at Pi Pizza is insane and any review that is less that a 5 has been written by a..."
Liz Cannavo Gruber
"Ahhh Pi Pizzeria! So many reasons to go! Best pasta on the island! Incredible lunch and dinner specials! Oh, and the only wood fired oven and..."
Doreen Costanzo
"Pi Has fantastic pizza, amazing pasta and perfect tiramisu!! All served in a warm, cozy atmosphere. We love this..."
Carrie Culp
"Love it all! Best steak on the island! Friendly staff makes all the..."
Gretchen Gigi Callahan
"All of my meals here have been amazing !!! 5 stars..."
Lisa Bouchard
"Best Pizza on the Island! Try the Mozzarella..."
Lee Milazzo
"Without a doubt the fall is back and Pi is perfect for the crisp nights. John Burdock is amazing. Always so welcoming. Will gladly wait for seats at..."
Tanya Jill McDonough
"Pi Pizza if I had to describe it in one word "Quality"it's evident in every bite,And the hospitality warms me it's like visiting family (you know the..."
Robert Souza
"Great Staff and Best Food in a truly Fun Atmosphere. What every neighborhood restaurant should..."
Dave Ryan
"I never write reviews but I feel like this is what it's all about!! You completely satisfied my craving tonight!! My husband came with a margarita..."
Darya Afshari
"I love Pi Pizzeria - Pizza, Pasta and INCREDIBLE Daily Specials for Dinner! I also love to eat lunch their because not crazy..."
Malcolm Brooks
"The best pizza in Nantucket. My favorite better than NJ or NY. Get the clams as..."
Sheri Matarese
"I have had the pleasure of going to Pi Pizzeria only once as I only get to Nantucket for work, but good lord was it wonderful.
First of all, the..."
Chris Vaughn
"The pizza was great and the owners were extremely..."
Sweetburrito
"Pizza was amazing. Staff was super friendly and considering how busy it was, pizza came out super quick. Thin, cooked perfectly, and hit the spot...."
Douglas Macedo
"Charming place with good food, good service and a great atmosphere. I love their pizza and steak but my personal favorite is Esposito's Sausage..."
"I met up with a friend for dinner. We had a very fun waitress who made a fantastic recommendation for a glass of wine. For dinner we tried the Steak..."
Leigh Topham
"Raw bar was excellent and white sangria was the best. Staff is attentive and ambience is light and airy. Great spot for a few hours of summer..."
Susan Lynn Ryan
"Overall a great place to have dinner and drinks. Service is phenomenal and so is the menu. A true hidden..."
Maaks Caren
"Great new spot. Scallop dish yummy! Chicken and waffles very good but only savory option. Wanted some maple syrup! Will def go..."
Kathy Molloy
"Food, staff & atmosphere are amazing! A must..."
Erin Coffin
"Hey Nantucket peeps and EVERYONE who's planning on coming to the Island! You'll need to get here! Food and atmosphere are..."
Melody Johnson
"Awesome atmosphere and great..."
Meghan Bernazzani
"..."
Roger Levesque
"Though my family visited a few years ago, the service was friendly and the food was great..nice outdoor seating area on a quiet starry night..though..."
Michael Wisker
"Loved this place! Affordable, has down to Earth people, and their food was really good! Go in for a beer and you won't be..."
Emily Padden
"Really amazing. The food is fresh and so..."
Jovanna Fuller
"Very nice place, very good food. Quick walk from the..."
NC NEAC
"Re designed interior and outdoor seating. Good food and reasonably..."
"I met up with a friend for dinner. We had a very fun waitress who made a fantastic recommendation for a glass of wine. For dinner we tried the Steak..."
Leigh Topham
"Raw bar was excellent and white sangria was the best. Staff is attentive and ambience is light and airy. Great spot for a few hours of summer..."
Susan Lynn Ryan
"Overall a great place to have dinner and drinks. Service is phenomenal and so is the menu. A true hidden..."
Maaks Caren
"Great new spot. Scallop dish yummy! Chicken and waffles very good but only savory option. Wanted some maple syrup! Will def go..."
Kathy Molloy
"Food, staff & atmosphere are amazing! A must..."
Erin Coffin
"Hey Nantucket peeps and EVERYONE who's planning on coming to the Island! You'll need to get here! Food and atmosphere are..."
Melody Johnson
"Awesome atmosphere and great..."
Meghan Bernazzani
"..."
Roger Levesque
"I am Mexican and I can say this restaurant has great tacos! Drinks where amazing too!..."
Elissa AK
"Newly renovated space looks great. Every corner give you different Mexican style vybz.
Happy to see something different at Nantucket.
New menu is..."
Stacey McKenzie
"Mussels ,Beef Tostada and Margarita very nice this time Adios Pantolenes better then Margarita Thank you..."
Bulut Mutlu
"Absolutely fantastic experience. Excellent, attentive service along with delicious food. Only thing I wish is that I could have partaken in a couple..."
Lorcan Kelly
"Great New Spot on the island, staff is fantastic with great energy, has indoor and out door seating. Plenty of Parking, a rarity on Nantucket. Food..."
"Would very highly recommend this place. It's new, not very big, and wasn't busy, but I have a feeling that it will be much busier next time. Had..."
Amit Jain
"I have i mix feelings about this place.
Maybe after i visit one more time i will have a clear idea but now i will share my first time..."
Stacey McKenzie
"Fantastic sushi and service here . Casual and relaxed atmosphere and the staff are very..."
barry gilliland
"Secret hide-a-way…
Afterhouse is one of our summer favorites. Tucked down below the sidewalk at 18 Broad Street... it feels like a private little..."
mybeneteau brian
"Food is amazing...service is great! Not many places open this late, no crowds to fight! Wine was fabulous! I recommend the crab salad, tuna tartare..."
Sally Hall
"😍love this little place with delicious food and great choice of wine!! Servers are the..."
"If you're looking for a really chill and low-key place to drop in for lunch/dinner or to have a drink, this is it. We had the fish and chips, a..."
Terri ann Edwards
"Came for an early dinner. Ordered fried pickles,nachos , fried calamari , a cheeseburger and a veggie panini. All very good! Our server was great and..."
Jennifer Brodzik
"Fish and chips was pretty good. Caesars salad had too much dressing. Environment is fun, lots of TV's. Clean space, service was quick and..."
Jason Hall
"Great place! Bill and Kim are such amazing people. Great food and a fun..."
"I have to say, not where I thought I'd be spending my anniversary dinner. But, when this is where the taxi driver dropped us for a food..."
Danielle Flocco
"Favorite year-round establishment for great drinks and food selection from the kitchen, always tasty and delicious, great location to meet up with..."
Eric Miller
"Perfect place to hang out with friends, you can hang at the bar and watch TV or at a table or booth. Play a few games of pool and share some laughs..."
"Tried the Philly Cheesesteak, it was a perfect blend of bread, cheese and steak. I enjoyed it. Food came out quick. The side of coleslaw was kinda..."
Brian Daniel
"No wait. The Daffy crowd stormed in, but the staff was more than capable. Food and drink were good. Prices were crazy but it was the middle of a..."
Keith Darling
"Lobster Mac and cheese was so good. Good and friendly..."
Joe Diesal2
"Great servers. Good menu. Great location. What’s not to like?..."
David Friess
"Best lunch spot close to the Steamship Authority dock. Had the Clam Chowder in a Bread Bowl one day and the warm Lobster Roll the next time. Fries..."
"Really enjoyed the selections and the location is right near the ferry. Good place to kill time waiting for the boat but also looks like a fun place..."
Matt S
"Good selection of local beers and nice view overlooking the water. Seems like it’s always packed as it’s right in the downtown area. Nice place..."
Maddy A
"Our server, Kelly, was wonderful. Very attentive, friendly, helpful and not pushy at all. We were seated outside by the host immediately who knew a..."
Kate Bartholomew
"Good for having a drink while watching the island life pass..."
M Alone
"After a long trip from NY, once we got off the boat to land in Nantucket, this is the first awesome spot to get a drink, so strong that we felt so..."
M H
"Ate there yesterday. Burgers wonderful. Waitress attentive. Always go there when on..."
"If you're looking for a really chill and low-key place to drop in for lunch/dinner or to have a drink, this is it. We had the fish and chips, a..."
Terri ann Edwards
"Came for an early dinner. Ordered fried pickles,nachos , fried calamari , a cheeseburger and a veggie panini. All very good! Our server was great and..."
Jennifer Brodzik
"Fish and chips was pretty good. Caesars salad had too much dressing. Environment is fun, lots of TV's. Clean space, service was quick and..."
Jason Hall
"Great place! Bill and Kim are such amazing people. Great food and a fun..."
Shane Caledonia
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes