I have to admit that I had a hankering for burger & fries when I arrived at Stehly's. I didn't get what I wanted, and I am glad to say do. The meat and potato pastie was excellent, the meat was obviously ground beef, not mystery-meat, the potato was cubed and fresh, seasoned just enough to compliment the meat and potatoes but not so much as to overwhelm everything else. The pastry was crisp on the outside and soft on the inside. The pastie was moist inside, not too wet and certainly not too dry. In my experience, pasties can be too dry, spoiling the meal. But not here.
Stehly's chef obviously cares about the food that they put in front of people.
I highly recommend this eatery, and I challenge people to find better!
All food is fresh food. Cannot go wrong with the Justin. Bakery items are top notch. It is a little pricey but worth it considering the excellent flavor for fresh, homemade food. Breakfast sandwiches are hearty. Made sure you feed the parking meter.
My wife and I have eaten here twice now. Breakfast was tremendous if you're looking for a breakfast sandwich. Kaiser rolls were great. Now we had dinner here. We ordered some soup and sandwiches. The creamy tomato soup was excellent and the sandwiches were also spot on. Bread was fresh and my wife was able to build her own sandwich. The owner is extremely kind and the place is really neat inside. It's important that people in town go here next time they want a sandwich and second guess their thought to hit up McDonald's or Arby's down the road! The town needs more places like this.
I absolutely love their food!! They have so many great vegetarian options--I love the Mediterranean salad (which is also fabulous as a wrap)! They really pay attention to detail, and the portion always leaves me with left overs. Definitely a must try!
My wife and I ate there for the first time. Had 2 bacon, egg and cheese on Portugal rolls, excellent sandwich. Just as good as sandwichs we used to get in nyc. kiffles and coffee for desert, wife said coffee was very good. Anthony the owner, real nice guy. Atmosphere very cool. They have bands on the weekends, open mic and karaoke during the week. Will definitely stop back in for the crab cake or prime rib sandwich. Place reminds me of Central Perk from friends with the couches. Great local place. Also right across from Emily's.
My girl and I walked to Stehly's with our dog and I waited outside as she walked in to buy some breakfast pasties. As I was talking to my dog about not being able to follow his fur mom into the restaurant, she walked out and said, "We can bring him in here!"
To my surprise, they allow dogs in their establishment and are working on a permanent spot up front to keep your pets while you dine. We had some great pasties and coffee and even walked out with some kiffles after sampling a few other baked goods. We will be back and I recommend everyone try Stehly's more than once in your life !
Ilka Hanselmann O'Donovan
+5
Having the New York Strip special. It is incredible! Made just the way I like it. Hubby had the pastie. Being from England he is hard to impress. He was impressed. Child had a chef salad. Fresh greens and meats. Paired all with homemade potato and cheddar perogies. Oh, so good! Add to that karaoke night and we had a great time. We will return. Still need to try the kiffles!
This place is awesome, and it's super cool to have an establishment like this here in Nazareth!
The food is amazing! The pastries are amazing! And the people who work here are even more amazing!! Love this place
I love the food, and the open mic that Bill Hosts every Tuesday 7-9
The owner is awesome and accommodating
Sue Csilinko Messinger
+5
Been here for lunch & dinner. Great food, entertainment & friendly staff. You must stop in!$
Really fun place to eat and watch local bands on a Sunday night. Major pursuit all girl band was really great
Good food good people good music. Would recommend!
Nice comfy place with GREAT food. Their baked goods are worth the trip alone!!
I bought the Wild Blueberry Kiffles & Blueberry Crumb at the farmers market in Pen Argyl! The Kiffles are Amazing!!!! Can't wait to try the pie!!! Thank you!!!
Had sandwiches and pie yesterday. Excellent! Bought some pasties for lunch & dinner during the week. Thanks Mike!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes