Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in New Buffalo
6 restaurant menus in New Buffalo, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
"An absolutely lovely dining experience. Somewhat affordable for a more high end restaurant! Great food with excellent presentation. Almost all..."
Michelle Biggs
"Nice little place inside the Harbor Grand Hotel. You can eat in or outside on the patio. The staff was friendly and the food was delicious. We had..."
shauna
"Small, quaint, excellent! This place is a small hidden gem that has a great environment and even better food! The staff is friendly and easygoing...."
Patrick Kozy
"Amazing food. Do not miss the blueberry or carrot bruschetta. Excellent pasta and chocolate cake. Service was incredible. Would highly..."
Magan Newton
"My husband and I came here for our anniversary. We did wait about 15 minutes at our table with no service due to some confusion with the servers...."
Kylie Howey
"Food, service and atmosphere was excellent! Loved that our server had been there with his wife. Great recommendations and nothing disappointed. The..."
Erin McKechnie
"Picked this restaurant as it was a perfect spot to watch 4th of July fireworks. It did not disappoint. Food was great and reasonably..."
Sheila Llanes
"Had my first experience there this month. The food is on point! The homemade pasta is so good. Our server (Monica I think) was so polite, very..."
Josh Shook
"Outstanding dining experience! I was immediately interested in the lamb shank special and it was done to perfection! Perfectly braised in a rich and..."
Mark K
"Beautiful table/view on the terrace. Service was very good if a little rushed.
Food was ok. Caprese and roasted pepper bruschetta were quite good...."
"I almost always get one of specialty pizzas. The toppings are inventive and fresh. I've had anything from potatoes to cherries to habanero infused..."
Aubrey Mora
"Yum!!!! Would definitely come here again! We got dinner for 2 and split between the three of us. Girls day out!! Best pizza!! Great entree. Service..."
Donna Toms
"Passed by en route to eastern Michigan and came across this place. It was slow being chilly weather and mid-afternoon, we sat in the atrium bar and..."
Eric Mason
"Wonderful, intimate atmosphere. I love the outside dining in the summer. One of my favorite places to eat for over 10..."
Critterbug
"I'm a big fan of becoming a regular at a restaurant -- everything seems to get better. So, we have come to really enjoy this place-- very good..."
Louisemarion
"Great place!. After seeing the reviews, and since this was "on the way" to the Dunes, took party of 8 here yesterday for lunch. Altho' didn't have..."
Hobbes
"Italian at Its Best. Great food! Everything is fresh and homemade. House dressing is to die for and the couple meal is a deal! Two salads, one pasta..."
Lisa A
"Befriend Brewster's. You can't go wrong with Brewster's in New Buffalo. Just a short drive from the Four Wind's Casino. I have been back many times...."
Wes Coast
"Go-To for Italian. Been going to Brewster's for over 10 years of consistently good meals. If you're a fan, don't skip their spinach and artichoke dip..."
Jennifer
"Absolute best thin crust pizza! If you like pizza Brewster's is a must. Good beer list, pasta a little pricey - device mediocre at best, probably due..."
T. Cotten
"What's really unique about this resturant is that their menu changes EVERY DAY. So what you get might not be there the next time you go..."
The MC Foodie
"Stopped here on our way home from Northern Michigan. There was a short wait for a table on a bust Saturday night. My husband ordered a spicy pizza,..."
shauna
"We went for dinner- had the sausage and peppers, house salad and a Detroit pizza. For dessert the hummingbird cake and peanut butter pie.
Sausage..."
Indmom11
"Amazing Italian restaurant with an intimate patio. Reservations are a must. Their menu changes with the seasons. Their Detroit style pizza is..."
Thomas Fenzl
"Wow, I’ve been coming to New Buffalo for a long time and always overlooked this place. Never again! Enjoyed the Dinner for two. My boyfriend was..."
Eileen Rohan
"Another AMAZINGLY staffed New Buffalo restaurant. They did a great job working with my allergies. Had the build your own pizza, with a perfectly..."
Mike Aylor
"This is a top 3 dining experience in the New Buffalo area. The atmosphere is really wonderful, especially outside in the garden-like atmosphere. ..."
Nate K.
"Had lunch here and it was the best experience and food I’ve had here in New Buffalo! Our waitress was the sweetest and super attentive! Lunch..."
Donna Hughes
"Enchanting Italian dinner on our last night in New Buffalo. Food was amazing - husband got pizza and I got sausage and shrimp pasta. The patio /..."
Sarah Siath
"Fantastic service, delicious food, lovely outdoor patio with enough distance to feel comfortable.
We got the special dinner for two. Great value but..."
Chuck Losch
"Great atmosphere, wonderful food & good service. We loved the variety of..."
Debbie Crownover
"I absolutely love Brewster's. The atmosphere is so sweet, inside and out. This past time we went for lunch. We all tried something new; spinach and..."
Samantha Eaton
"What a wonderful place! My wife and I stopped in for breakfast and we could not be happier about our decision. The wait staff were warm and..."
Michael Conway
"Visiting from Charleston, SC and was in MI from a friends wedding… so glad we found this place and tried it. Half of our group was about to miss..."
Valarie Winkleman
"This is one of our new favorite places to go. We had dinner here on Friday, September 1st, and it was so fantastic that we had dinner again on..."
Jeffrey Matson
"This was a fantastic meal! I made reservations, highly recommend the terrace. It is cozy and nice. I love spinach dip and their hot spinach dip..."
Emily Krajec
"Fabulous restaurant, great service and food. Caroline was our server and she was excellent as well as the Manager Amanda. Very personable and made..."
Lisa Dalton
"The dining experience was exceptional, featuring a delightful white pizza and a stellar salad that truly impressed. Our visit even included a..."
Lidia Jarmuz Real Estate
"We dined here on a Friday evening, so given the crowd our service could have been affected by a staff that was busy. We were hesitant about dining..."
John Kroll
"Absolutely amazing atmosphere and amazing food. Particularly the detroit style pizza, the triple crown, phenomenal!!! Must must..."
"Oh my gosh the food was amazing and prices were fantastic! Well definitely go back when we travel that way..."
Denise Hamilton
"Got off the beach later than expected. Ordered 3 pizzas not a bad wait for a Friday evening. Pizza was delicious, the dough and the sauce was might..."
Steven
"Service was amazing. I phoned in my order, the person that answered was very friendly and helpful. After asking a few short questions, we were on..."
Mark Mac
"Newly remodeled. The prices reflect the remodel. We paid $40 for a large deep dish pizza for 2 ppl, with water. We won't be..."
David Martin
"After all the years of eating romas and even though the ownership change Romas pizza is always our go to pizzeria in new Buffalo MI.love it!!!! Thank..."
Shannon Escamilla
"Amazing Pizza and amazing service! We ordered carryout, so I do not know what dining in is like, however I cannot recommend their pizza..."
Spencer MIller
"Last time I ate here was 32 years ago when I came to visit my cousin's for the summer. It was nostalgia to the max... great tasting sauce and the..."
Teddy Bundy
"Very quaint cozy place for couples to go to to have some Italian pizza after the beach along with some wine. I was not disappointed by the new owners..."
Wendy Roethler-Osterkamp (Wen)
"Thanksgiving week hopefully bar will be finished with remodeling. Take out only a little while..."
Lorne Dickinson
"The pizza was very good with soft crust. But the pasta.... Ah...the pasta was AMAZING! Their sauce is homemade. Our server said 85% of the food is..."
Pam Siedler
"Excellent pizza and the service was top notch. Our family has a great meal and a great time.
It seems like they got better quality ingredients and it..."
"We had great service from Lexi. The gluten free pizza is the best around and it's cooked in a separate kitchen!
Lexi suggested kettle chips for the..."
Carol Pozos
"We sat at the bar outside, those heaters are awesome! French onion soup, Gnocchi with vodka sauce, all fantastic!
I had a banana old fashioned that..."
Adam “Infinius” Lesniewski
"Stopped here by chance and omg we will be back! Buffalo pizza...outstanding! Cucumber Breeze drink was perfect! 6 kids and 2 adults happy! Place was..."
Asli Weil
"Let me just say I have never gave a 5 Star review for a restaurant but at last I have found the perfect place for what I like. The food is absolutely..."
Robert Bugajski
"Fresh ingredients are always on the pizza 🍅🫑🥓🧅🧀 🍕.. Don't forget the French fries 🍟 .. Always Great tasting..."
Annie 1
"First time here. We ordered pizza sausage/mushroom, and it was so delicious. I am a thin crust lover so it was perfect. The sauce is very good. Will..."
Diane Rickert
"Our first visit there with the kids. We did the family size and garlic cheese bread. Everything was fantastic! The crust was great with no flop. ..."
Stupd Flanders
"The pizza was very good, cooked well. The fries came out cold from the sandwich, not sure what's up with that. I appreciate them being open on a..."
Pastel Hart
"Thin crust pizza was flavourful for the size, though at $7 I was kind of expecting a more fulfilling slice. There was 5 workers by the register and I..."
Yumsah's Website Design
"Best thin crust pizza I've had in a long time! Big chunks of sausage and if you love cheese they take care of ya! I ordered extra cheese and the..."
Laura Levin
"Breadsticks are amazing! Topped with a delicious Parmesan and garlicky seasoning. Pizza is a thin, crispy, cracker style crust. The outdoor seating..."
Noah Roth
"being from Chicago, our group was a little hesitant about going out for pizza but villa nova was delicious. The service was very good and the outdoor..."
Lisa Kacerovskis
"In today's culinary exploration, we turn our gaze to a modest yet remarkable establishment nestled in the heart of New Buffalo: Villa Nova Pizzeria...."
Aaron Wells
"I was in Villa Nova Sunday night trying to enjoy a pizza and a gentlemen approached our table unsolicited and just kept talking and wouldn't stop...."
"Went to a corporate event and was pleasantly surprised by the quality of their meat and cheese appetizer spread with fruits and nuts... best bread..."
Bill Lynch
"Amazing food, amazing beer, great vibes. Overall, 10/10 want to go again.
We got 2 pizzas, which were some of the best we’ve ever had, to go along..."
Nate Hamilton
"I tried a flight of beers and the Calabrese pizza and the Beer Church, and I was very happy with that for lunch. The beers were solid, and the pizza..."
Mateo Gebon
"Loved all of the food here, the communion bread was fantastic! Love the church aesthetic and the beer recommendations are on point. Bought some beer..."
Erika Melby
"Good beer, good food, and good vibes. My favorite beer was the Pontius Pilate. We also tried the burrata communion bread which was tasty.
Quite of..."
Tony Gabrielse
"If you don't know, this is a really cool restaurant from a retrofitted church building. They have a big pizza oven that they cook breads and pizzas..."
Michael Robinson
"Food solid 5 loud… solid 4 unless you sit outside.
Drink, Eat. Repent. Repeat solid mantra while you dine in signature cocktails and home brewed..."
Amy Janel Haaseth-Massey (AJ)
"Fennel Sausage Pizza was great. The Communion bread was excellent. The server was nice and friendly, but it took 10 minutes to get greeted after..."
Harvey Oh
"It's a really nice place. The sandwiches are really good. So is the pizza, but too pricey for a small pizza. Drinks were really..."
Victoria Sanchez
"So we finally found a place where the pizzas taste like what we had when we were in Italy. It was the perfect amount of chew to crust ratio, the..."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes