5 restaurant menus in New Buffalo, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
"Great ice cream and really cute place! Family loved it! Very busy tho...expect to wait a bit during peak..."
Audrey Smith
"Oh so yummy! Their ice cream is so good, and reasonably priced. The staff is super friendly. They didn't kick us out even though we came in right at..."
Valentina Kniess
"The woman who took my order was so nice and friendly! I got the dairy-free chocolate chunk ice cream and it was some of the best ice cream I’ve..."
Paige Matejek
"We love Beachside! It’s our favorite ice cream store in the area by far! Cute decor, great location and service...and so many delicious flavors. We..."
Ann Looby
"The best ice cream place in New Buffalo. Amazing flavors, employees, owners, and experience. All the employees welcome you with open arms. The price..."
Alex S
"Loved the blueberry cheesecake flavor on my chocolate dipped cone and the outstanding customer..."
Matt G
"Our kids love this place and we’ve long been fans. But I really want to commend them in regards to their handling of the COVID situation. They’ve..."
Dawn Schneider
"Cute ice cream shop near the beach with tons of flavors to pick from at a reasonable price. We tried both ice cream shops in new Buffalo, the flavors..."
Michelle Golden
"New food menu is amazing. Flavors are on point! Thank you for still offering carry out during the busy season when the other restaurants are only..."
Dr Bryan Strother
"Ice cream was awesome! Very busy all weekend, but like goes by fast. Prices are reasonable & so many flavors it's hard to..."
Lauren Filer
"5* for Covid precautions and delicious ice cream (ice cream is pre-scooped for pick up). Minus a star for inconsistent hours. Our family tried to..."
Katherine Pillai
"Such a nice place in a great location. Delish ice cream! Sorry to get there for ice cream, only to find that they are already closed for the season..."
Virgie Lusk
"Delicious ice cream, super friendly staff and reasonably priced. The kids loved being able to try a couple different flavors before..."
Simon Zarife
"A great little ice cream stop. I was with a group with someone who is allergic to tree nuts and the friendly girl behind the counter was happy to..."
Aaron Gudeyon
"They had multiple sorbet flavors and a dairy-free chocolate soft serve that was really good, hard to find dairy-free options. Reasonably priced..."
Melissa S
"We went here Two days in a row! The mint chip is awesome and I like that you can order online so you don’t have to..."
Alison McCarthy
"Great ice cream super..."
Michele Tillapaugh
"Great staff. Very friendly and helpful. Ice cream choices are numerous and great prices ask this..."
2 Scoops of Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream in a Waffle Cone
Mint Chocolate Ice Cream Cone
Raspberry Chip Yogurt
Blue Moon Ice Cream Cone
Vanilla Ice Cream Cone
Ice Cream
Café
American
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Non-smoking restaurants
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Drinks
Late Night
Cheap Eats
"This is what you would expect from a small town ice cream shop that has been around for decades. Great ice cream with an enormous selection and one..."
Ajenm5
"Awesome ice cream! Fun family place and a must stop while in town :) staff is always friendly, even when it's crazy busy. Lots of fun trinkets all..."
Sam
"Old Fashioned awesomeness. Long lines,but efficient. Pricey yet worth it. Loads of memorabilia. Perfect family stop. I had the butterscotch chip...."
Coco Cooks
"Very small, crowded place, but the ice cream was delicious. The shop itself is very unique in decoration, but it's small and super crowded so it's..."
Sonia
"Always a fun place full of character and awesome ice cream. Good fast service. They really know how to move the crowds through there..."
ElkhartMomof4
"Always busy but FAST service with their "pick a number" plan. Have TONS of hard ice cream flavors including my hard to find favorite, choc PB, and 2..."
Priscilla
"Stopped by at 10 pm on a Wednesday night....and stood in line. Nice I've cream..."
Tom Figg
"Oink’s Dutch Treat is on Buffalo Street southwest of Barker Street not too far from downtown New Buffalo. The building looks like an old Quonset..."
SW Michigan Dining
"Ice cream was super smooth, creamy and delicious! I recommend looking online for the menu before you visit.
Visiting New Buffalo, MI and walked..."
Hewe Wong
"I was traveling from Charleston, SC wedding for a friends wedding. She recommended this place for a thousand reasons but also mentioned how much the..."
Valarie Winkleman
"We came here from Chicago and word in the street was this place... was the place to visit. The best ice-cream I have ever had. Had the pumpkin and..."
Stephanie R
"My daughter favorite ice cream in new Bufallo
Very good creamy ice..."
kacper123ful
"Delighted by the fantastic ice cream and the charming decorations inside! Ample parking is a plus. Although they were out of my initial ice cream..."
Jeff W
"One of two independent ice creameries in New Buffalo; this one was recommended to us. Well-established place with townsfolk as well as tourists. Many..."
Guy Newland
"Awesome late night Ice Cream Shop that didn't disappoint! I got 2 scoops of mint chocolate chip ice cream in a waffle cone and it was delicious..."
Chazzy
"Such a cute ice cream place with yummy flavors and excellent..."
Jacob White
"Came here with family to get some after dinner treats, and it did not disappoint! This was my first time here and you could definitely tell this..."
Michael Robinson
"Joe Biden has been there. Marisa Tomei has been there. You aren't better than them. So get your ice cream..."
"Nice little ice cream store. Has plenty of outdoor seating in front or on the side. Selection is about what you would expect for this type of..."
Dave Miller
"Place was super busy. But they moved through us really fast. I felt like I got more than I normally get for what I paid. Like the prices were..."
Jeremiah Chism
"All of my mozzarella sticks except for one were hollow but the icecream was..."
Iris Fedorchak
"Fun service and good food here! I ordered the burger and it was so good, like really good. And we got a chili hot dog which was gas too. Ice cream..."
Ruth Crisp
"After a very long bike ride, the Chicago dogs were perfect and the thick shakes de-licious!! Always nice to get cheerful service as..."
Arleigh Reichl
"20 stars if we could all around!!!! Such a great place to hang out and enjoy the surroundings of New Buffalo!!! Awesome!! Truly..."
Steven McHugh
"The strawberry milkshake is an absolute must try! Even though there was a line around the block for labor day which would have been understandably..."
Andrew Tradewell
"Been here a couple times now that Oinks doesn't serve Sherman's anymore. Nancy's sells hudsonville ice cream, which I have been quit pleased with. ..."
Josh Zacher
"Nancy’s was the best ice cream I’ve had. I tried Oinks but Nancy’s is way better ice cream. Their chocolate peanut butter is to die for. The..."
Kristi Shaw
"Hands down the best strawberry shake I have ever had! I drive down 40 mins just to get it. The staff is always friendly and the service is fast. They..."
robert holbrook
"Great staff! I ordered a mango smoothie it was delicious. I was surprised how fast I got it considering there were three employees and they were very..."
Pete Boulahanis
"Very good ice cream and sunday here
I tryed the hot fudge sunday, it’s tasty and the hot chocolate is delicious
The snickers ice cream is just..."
Michel Darras
"My friend and I stopped here on our way back from swimming at Warren Dunes all day, and this was SO good. We wanted fries and shakes and this came up..."
Olivia Roland
"Really wasn’t expecting this place to be this good. I was pleasantly surprised. Not the best burger we’ve eaten, but still a respectable taste...."
Ali Kefeli
"I just wanted to say this place’s customer service was outstanding, they had been closed for a half hour the two employees were cleaning and doing..."
Almost Anything
"Nancy’s is a definite highlight of my trip to michigan. Tons of ice cream flavors to choose from, and all of them delicious!! portion sizes were..."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes