9 restaurant menus in New Buffalo, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"An absolutely lovely dining experience. Somewhat affordable for a more high end restaurant! Great food with excellent presentation. Almost all..."
Michelle Biggs
"Nice little place inside the Harbor Grand Hotel. You can eat in or outside on the patio. The staff was friendly and the food was delicious. We had..."
shauna
"Small, quaint, excellent! This place is a small hidden gem that has a great environment and even better food! The staff is friendly and easygoing...."
Patrick Kozy
"Amazing food. Do not miss the blueberry or carrot bruschetta. Excellent pasta and chocolate cake. Service was incredible. Would highly..."
Magan Newton
"My husband and I came here for our anniversary. We did wait about 15 minutes at our table with no service due to some confusion with the servers...."
Kylie Howey
"Food, service and atmosphere was excellent! Loved that our server had been there with his wife. Great recommendations and nothing disappointed. The..."
Erin McKechnie
"Picked this restaurant as it was a perfect spot to watch 4th of July fireworks. It did not disappoint. Food was great and reasonably..."
Sheila Llanes
"Had my first experience there this month. The food is on point! The homemade pasta is so good. Our server (Monica I think) was so polite, very..."
Josh Shook
"Outstanding dining experience! I was immediately interested in the lamb shank special and it was done to perfection! Perfectly braised in a rich and..."
Mark K
"Beautiful table/view on the terrace. Service was very good if a little rushed.
Food was ok. Caprese and roasted pepper bruschetta were quite good...."
"Absolutely incredible dinner and service. Dressed up for each other and had a wonderful date night at the Bentwood Tavern in New Buffalo, MI. 🥰 My..."
Rebecca Hehr
"This was a delicious place… We eat on the terrace and it was really nice. They made me an incredible Mezcal margarita with charcoal, which was so..."
Eileen R
"Beautiful Sunday afternoon to dine on the deck. A favorite destination for sure! The fish and chips were perfect, the Tavern burger with bacon onion..."
Mark K
"We can not say enough about our beyond amazing experience! The renovation is gorgeous, sophisticated, & unbelievably cozy.
Our waitress Olive was..."
Ginger Hollenbeck
"Food 5☆ quality, DELICIOUS! Had the the Lobster Benedict ...and Squash Flatbread
Atmosphere 5☆!!! Great place to meet a friend....very open/..."
AskAnnalisa OnlineLifeCoaching
"We celebrated an anniversary dinner here and we enjoyed everything we got. We got the branzino fish special, the 16 oz bone in ribeye, and the green..."
Ashley Catizone
"Had an excellent dinner. The view was pretty. Food was delicious. Service was on point. Our server Carissa was attentive and hospitable. Really..."
Benjamin Konrad
"This is my second time here for brunch and food is awesome! Service is great! All staff were so sweet! But can you please bring back the lemon..."
Kim James
"I happened to stop by here at random and found it is located in a resort. Ordered the hamburger and tavern chicken. They were pretty good, the..."
Karl Merkner
"Overall, great time. The prices are little over the top for the product. $33 for an Angel's Envy Old Fashion is a little much. I get the "top shelf"..."
2 Scoops of Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream in a Waffle Cone
Mint Chocolate Ice Cream Cone
Raspberry Chip Yogurt
Café
American
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Non-smoking restaurants
Late Night
Drinks
Cheap Eats
"This is what you would expect from a small town ice cream shop that has been around for decades. Great ice cream with an enormous selection and one..."
Ajenm5
"Awesome ice cream! Fun family place and a must stop while in town :) staff is always friendly, even when it's crazy busy. Lots of fun trinkets all..."
Sam
"Old Fashioned awesomeness. Long lines,but efficient. Pricey yet worth it. Loads of memorabilia. Perfect family stop. I had the butterscotch chip...."
Coco Cooks
"Very small, crowded place, but the ice cream was delicious. The shop itself is very unique in decoration, but it's small and super crowded so it's..."
Sonia
"Always a fun place full of character and awesome ice cream. Good fast service. They really know how to move the crowds through there..."
ElkhartMomof4
"Always busy but FAST service with their "pick a number" plan. Have TONS of hard ice cream flavors including my hard to find favorite, choc PB, and 2..."
Priscilla
"Stopped by at 10 pm on a Wednesday night....and stood in line. Nice I've cream..."
Tom Figg
"Oink’s Dutch Treat is on Buffalo Street southwest of Barker Street not too far from downtown New Buffalo. The building looks like an old Quonset..."
SW Michigan Dining
"Ice cream was super smooth, creamy and delicious! I recommend looking online for the menu before you visit.
Visiting New Buffalo, MI and walked..."
Hewe Wong
"I was traveling from Charleston, SC wedding for a friends wedding. She recommended this place for a thousand reasons but also mentioned how much the..."
Valarie Winkleman
"We came here from Chicago and word in the street was this place... was the place to visit. The best ice-cream I have ever had. Had the pumpkin and..."
Stephanie R
"My daughter favorite ice cream in new Bufallo
Very good creamy ice..."
kacper123ful
"Delighted by the fantastic ice cream and the charming decorations inside! Ample parking is a plus. Although they were out of my initial ice cream..."
Jeff W
"One of two independent ice creameries in New Buffalo; this one was recommended to us. Well-established place with townsfolk as well as tourists. Many..."
Guy Newland
"Awesome late night Ice Cream Shop that didn't disappoint! I got 2 scoops of mint chocolate chip ice cream in a waffle cone and it was delicious..."
Chazzy
"Such a cute ice cream place with yummy flavors and excellent..."
Jacob White
"Came here with family to get some after dinner treats, and it did not disappoint! This was my first time here and you could definitely tell this..."
Michael Robinson
"Joe Biden has been there. Marisa Tomei has been there. You aren't better than them. So get your ice cream..."
"Such a cute spot in New Buffalo located on the channel with water views. Cozy, fun atmosphere with charming decor. Any restaurant with a fireplace is..."
danicajhey
"My dad recommended stopping here and oh boy did he get that right. Absolutely LOVED the experience, the food was on point and beer selection was..."
Ann Chovy
"The Stray Dog Bar & Grill is very nice. The restaurant is super clean with indoor and outdoor dining. We dined on the rooftop which was pretty..."
IndyKevin317
"We were visiting the area for a few days and stopped in for some dinner. I was worried it would be low quality tourist food but was pleasantly..."
Indmom11
"Delicious…everything here is delicious! The beet and goat cheese salad is out of this world! But, right when you think your palate has been..."
Yesenia Rybarski
"A Culinary Ode to The Stray Dog
In the heart of New Buffalo, Michigan, where the waves of Lake Michigan serenade the shores, sits a place of..."
Aaron Wells
"I'm giving The Stray Dog five stars because of the rooftop seating. Wonderful views of the marina area, fresh bright white umbrellas and bright..."
Laurie Spilman
"Oh my goodness!!!! They really take care of celiac folks, like myself, here. They went over and beyond. I didn’t get sick. I wish all places took..."
Olivia Palak
"Everything was outstanding at this restaurant. The atmosphere is very beachy feeling and the inside is very neat. We did not sit on the rooftop as..."
Trey Copeland
"Love the atmosphere! We look forward to dining here every time we visit New Buffalo. Expect a long wait during the summer months. If everyone in your..."
"I almost always get one of specialty pizzas. The toppings are inventive and fresh. I've had anything from potatoes to cherries to habanero infused..."
Aubrey Mora
"Yum!!!! Would definitely come here again! We got dinner for 2 and split between the three of us. Girls day out!! Best pizza!! Great entree. Service..."
Donna Toms
"Passed by en route to eastern Michigan and came across this place. It was slow being chilly weather and mid-afternoon, we sat in the atrium bar and..."
Eric Mason
"Wonderful, intimate atmosphere. I love the outside dining in the summer. One of my favorite places to eat for over 10..."
Critterbug
"I'm a big fan of becoming a regular at a restaurant -- everything seems to get better. So, we have come to really enjoy this place-- very good..."
Louisemarion
"Great place!. After seeing the reviews, and since this was "on the way" to the Dunes, took party of 8 here yesterday for lunch. Altho' didn't have..."
Hobbes
"Italian at Its Best. Great food! Everything is fresh and homemade. House dressing is to die for and the couple meal is a deal! Two salads, one pasta..."
Lisa A
"Befriend Brewster's. You can't go wrong with Brewster's in New Buffalo. Just a short drive from the Four Wind's Casino. I have been back many times...."
Wes Coast
"Go-To for Italian. Been going to Brewster's for over 10 years of consistently good meals. If you're a fan, don't skip their spinach and artichoke dip..."
Jennifer
"Absolute best thin crust pizza! If you like pizza Brewster's is a must. Good beer list, pasta a little pricey - device mediocre at best, probably due..."
T. Cotten
"What's really unique about this resturant is that their menu changes EVERY DAY. So what you get might not be there the next time you go..."
The MC Foodie
"Stopped here on our way home from Northern Michigan. There was a short wait for a table on a bust Saturday night. My husband ordered a spicy pizza,..."
shauna
"We went for dinner- had the sausage and peppers, house salad and a Detroit pizza. For dessert the hummingbird cake and peanut butter pie.
Sausage..."
Indmom11
"Amazing Italian restaurant with an intimate patio. Reservations are a must. Their menu changes with the seasons. Their Detroit style pizza is..."
Thomas Fenzl
"Wow, I’ve been coming to New Buffalo for a long time and always overlooked this place. Never again! Enjoyed the Dinner for two. My boyfriend was..."
Eileen Rohan
"Another AMAZINGLY staffed New Buffalo restaurant. They did a great job working with my allergies. Had the build your own pizza, with a perfectly..."
Mike Aylor
"This is a top 3 dining experience in the New Buffalo area. The atmosphere is really wonderful, especially outside in the garden-like atmosphere. ..."
Nate K.
"Had lunch here and it was the best experience and food I’ve had here in New Buffalo! Our waitress was the sweetest and super attentive! Lunch..."
Donna Hughes
"Enchanting Italian dinner on our last night in New Buffalo. Food was amazing - husband got pizza and I got sausage and shrimp pasta. The patio /..."
Sarah Siath
"Fantastic service, delicious food, lovely outdoor patio with enough distance to feel comfortable.
We got the special dinner for two. Great value but..."
Chuck Losch
"Great atmosphere, wonderful food & good service. We loved the variety of..."
Debbie Crownover
"I absolutely love Brewster's. The atmosphere is so sweet, inside and out. This past time we went for lunch. We all tried something new; spinach and..."
Samantha Eaton
"What a wonderful place! My wife and I stopped in for breakfast and we could not be happier about our decision. The wait staff were warm and..."
Michael Conway
"Visiting from Charleston, SC and was in MI from a friends wedding… so glad we found this place and tried it. Half of our group was about to miss..."
Valarie Winkleman
"This is one of our new favorite places to go. We had dinner here on Friday, September 1st, and it was so fantastic that we had dinner again on..."
Jeffrey Matson
"This was a fantastic meal! I made reservations, highly recommend the terrace. It is cozy and nice. I love spinach dip and their hot spinach dip..."
Emily Krajec
"Fabulous restaurant, great service and food. Caroline was our server and she was excellent as well as the Manager Amanda. Very personable and made..."
Lisa Dalton
"The dining experience was exceptional, featuring a delightful white pizza and a stellar salad that truly impressed. Our visit even included a..."
Lidia Jarmuz Real Estate
"We dined here on a Friday evening, so given the crowd our service could have been affected by a staff that was busy. We were hesitant about dining..."
John Kroll
"Absolutely amazing atmosphere and amazing food. Particularly the detroit style pizza, the triple crown, phenomenal!!! Must must..."
"Love eating at Timbers. The Daily Double is a great deal with plenty of food. You get 1/2 a sandwich or 1/2 a salad with a bowl of soup or chili. The..."
Genny Powell
"Had the roasted turkey and seasoned fries. Very good flavour on both. Service was great..."
Carry Oneal
"Love Timbers!! Everytime we come to 4 Winds we always have an excellent experience and of course the food is delicious. Such a wide variety for a..."
Sega Sean
"We ate here for a late night dinner because it was all that was open. It was good but more like fast food. The service was very slow but the staff..."
Katie
"The food was pricey but I ordered the special. The burger & fries were good, but the bun was a little tough. Otherwise..."
Nomad Travel S
"There was a short line but the food was good and the severs was..."
Doug Newbanks
"Food is Always Great Friendly Staff can't say Nothing Negative about the Place! There Whole Menu is Great just Miss the Big Pancakes an Waffle's..."
Beatrice McMichael
"Everything I have ever ordered has has been really good! Love the Reubens, the Asian chicken salad and the garlic fried mushrooms especially!..."
Vicki
"Fries were the best I ever had! Crispy on the outside and tender on the inside. Also grilled chicken caesar salad was very tasty. I enjoyed eating..."
C E
"Every time we eat there we are pleased .We were disappointed 😞 that they took potato tots and the cheese STEAK pizza 🍕 off the menu . I was..."
Roberta Trzcinski
"Only 1 nice gentleman was taking orders when they had such a long line. He was trying so..."
"William was a great waiter, he seved us quickly and gave us hot food. The Hamburgers were juicy and tasted! I definitely would come..."
Natalie Smith
"The food was delicious. I had the Mac n cheese and added shrimp. The shrimp were perfect but the Mac was a little bland. My bf had a pot roast..."
Amy Leigh
"This place was awesome 😎 food was so good! We got a lot as you can see! Drinks were on point and there was a band! Good times and..."
Drewann Nobles
"Fantastic cocktails, friendly service. Best crab cakes I’ve ever had! The pot roast stroganoff will live rent free in my dreams. Can’t wait to go..."
Rachel Conn
"Absolutely perfect dining experience. Food and drinks were perfect. Service was impeccable. Can't wait to go back. We had cheese curds, the rib..."
Brandy Manville
"A friend of mine and I both had the fish sandwich and both of us liked it. Two other guys had fish tacos and liked those. Cup of coffee was nice and..."
stnee 333
"Suzanne was amazing and the Southwest Salad was as good as any I have ever had. Great conversation at the friendly bar. You never know which..."
Bob Buttke
"Absolutely loved this place. The location is so cozy near the beach area here. Kaitlyn (I think that’s her name I saw it on our bill) was just SO..."
Sonia Ninan
"Lovely little restaurant just a couple of blocks from the beach. My burger and my wife's chicken sandwich were very good straight from the kitchen...."
Aaron N
"Stopped in on a Tuesday at 1 pm. Sat in back patio section. Took the waiter a bit to get to us but he was very busy. I had the Mahi Mahi tacos..."
Glenda Kilpatrick
"Has a cool backyard bar & patio area to enjoy live music. Great service, Nice beer selection. We enjoyed the mahi tacos, crab cakes, and fried..."
L. James Mitchell
"Great spot for grabbing food or watching a game (if at or near the bar). We stopped by for drinks and apps and it is much easier to get food here..."
Nicolette Tech (Nikita)
"Very good food, good service, nice atmosphere, just a little loud for the over 60 crowd. Live music entertainment is outside with seating for diners...."
Route 45
"Fun times great atmosphere, they had a live band that was funny because the young lady did not know the songs she was singing 🙂 but she gave it a..."
Krystal Lang
"First time at Casey's and loved everything about it. Great food, nice outside venue with live music. The service was very helpful in guiding us..."
Kathryn Ragains
"Decent experience overall. Good food and good atmosphere. However, let me be clear about why I gave the Service component of my experience a mediocre..."
Stephen F. Takach
"This was a fun place to experience, and the bartenders in the back patio were great. We went straight back to the patio once we got there and ordered..."
"Went to a corporate event and was pleasantly surprised by the quality of their meat and cheese appetizer spread with fruits and nuts... best bread..."
Bill Lynch
"Amazing food, amazing beer, great vibes. Overall, 10/10 want to go again.
We got 2 pizzas, which were some of the best we’ve ever had, to go along..."
Nate Hamilton
"I tried a flight of beers and the Calabrese pizza and the Beer Church, and I was very happy with that for lunch. The beers were solid, and the pizza..."
Mateo Gebon
"Loved all of the food here, the communion bread was fantastic! Love the church aesthetic and the beer recommendations are on point. Bought some beer..."
Erika Melby
"Good beer, good food, and good vibes. My favorite beer was the Pontius Pilate. We also tried the burrata communion bread which was tasty.
Quite of..."
Tony Gabrielse
"If you don't know, this is a really cool restaurant from a retrofitted church building. They have a big pizza oven that they cook breads and pizzas..."
Michael Robinson
"Food solid 5 loud… solid 4 unless you sit outside.
Drink, Eat. Repent. Repeat solid mantra while you dine in signature cocktails and home brewed..."
Amy Janel Haaseth-Massey (AJ)
"Fennel Sausage Pizza was great. The Communion bread was excellent. The server was nice and friendly, but it took 10 minutes to get greeted after..."
Harvey Oh
"It's a really nice place. The sandwiches are really good. So is the pizza, but too pricey for a small pizza. Drinks were really..."
Victoria Sanchez
"So we finally found a place where the pizzas taste like what we had when we were in Italy. It was the perfect amount of chew to crust ratio, the..."
"We have been here every time we drive through or stay in New Buffalo. Burgers are great, wait time is not fun and the fact that they don't take..."
Ajenm5
"Nothing fancy just good fresh juicy burger. Wait staff was very friendly. Make sure you take cash they are still old school and don't except debt..."
Jeremy Middleton
"Great for a Summer Place. Decent food, good for kids and families. They do not have lettuce or tomato for burgers and sandwiches. I assume it is in..."
So Late
"A great summer evening destination. The interior reminds you of an old camp dining hall. The cheeseburger with velveta is amazing! The cheese melts..."
Iugrl80
"Didn't live up to the hype but it was a good..."
Kirk Lampert
"Went here for a late lunch today on my way to Chicago. For YEARS I've heard how this place has the best burgers in all of Michigan, and for YEARS..."
Grub 'n' Brew In Da Zoo
"Best burgers in Michigan!. We regularly drive the 75 miles from Kalamazoo to New Buffalo just for a Redamak's burger...if that's not a rave review, I..."
MorningMan
"Redamak’s deserves their distinction as one of Michigan’s best restaurant. You’re not going to get anything fancy. You’re going to get your..."
SW Michigan Dining
"This place is in a great location - plenty of parking! The apps were good. The burger was ok. The meat was dry. But I would definitely come back and..."
Alex Sandoval
"My first visit. Great sports bar atmosphere. Loved the sports memorabilia that adorned the walls. Service was prompt, efficient, friendly. A..."
Stephen F. Takach
"Redamak’s is a fantastic restaurant that serves mouthwatering cheeseburgers, hot dogs, and chicken wings with incredible flavors. Their burgers are..."
JC’s Adventures
"Redamak’s is an American staple. The food is good. Stick with what made them great. The burger is cooked to my liking. Staff was really nice. It is..."
Steven Ford
"The service was quick friendly and fast. It opens up at 12 noon. So I suggest you get there early because it seems like it's a very popular spot and..."
Sanqwana Giles
"Redamak’s in New Buffalo lives up to its legendary status with burgers that truly stand out among the best in America, as endorsed by George Motz...."
David Peters
"Man, Redamak’s in New Buffalo? That place really ties the culinary room together, if you catch my drift. Been cruisin' over there, like, many times..."
Aaron Wells
"Redamak's is so great! We had their Wilson Street Burger and Patty Melt, which both come with fries, along with a strawberry milkshake - an amazing..."
Jeremy Lee
"My girlfriend brought me here for the 1st time ever, and I was blown away by the food and atmosphere. This was the 1st time she's been back since her..."
Tyler Jamieson
"We wanted a place to get supper without a long wait. A local in the area suggested Redmak’s. The hamburgers were delicious and service was good...."
Trey Copeland
"The food here was awesome! We will be coming back here next time we visit. Service was fast and helpful with accommodations. Atmosphere was family..."
Colleen Worden
"***Cash only***
Overall I really enjoyed this place. Lots of energy both from the staff and the other guests. The food was really tasty as well. Can..."
Darren Demis
"Great burgers! Old fashioned flavor. Not greasy. Love this..."
Frank S
"Food was tasty, but the burger was a bit gristly for the price. Server was busy but did a good job. Cool..."
Sheli Naumann
"Interesting place. A local said I’d love it or hate it. I didn’t love it or hate it but it was good. Nice waiter. Nice atmosphere. Fun stuff..."
James Hall
"Bison burger was amazing! Quick service and friendly staff. Definitely homemade..."
wanbligleska howaste
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes