97 restaurant menus in New Castle, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"We celebrated my birthday at EAT Bistro and Drinks and it did not disappoint!! This was one of the best meals I have ever had! We had drinks,..."
Sara
"These photos don't even do this place justice. Our visit here was so phenomenal we forgot to take photos.
Thank you Jeff, Molly and your entire..."
Earth Angel
"Great service, lovely meal choices, and wonderful presentation. We always come to Eat when we want a good..."
Wendie Dodge
"Food is consistently creative and delicious. Service is nice as is the seating area. Would highly..."
Sage W
"I just want to truly say WOW! I love this restaurant. I wish I lived closer so I can always eat there. The food was amazing, an experience that I..."
Amy Reyes Wikstrom
"First time at Newcastle CO - locals fave & culinary delight. Only a stranger once because staff will take care of you personally. Greatest food on..."
Frank Pilkington
"Very unique place for Downtown New Castle. I like their VERY friendly and helpful service. The Asian salad was definitely a healthy and delicious..."
"The pizza was steamy and delicious! The dessert options are NEXT LEVEL AMAZING 👏 😋 We got a pastry box to-go full of delicious sweets. We will..."
Liz Swank
"Perfect for the whole family, plus beer and good deserts!
The pizza shop is set back from the main road in a small shopping center. They have indoor..."
Nick Alessi
"If I’m going on a road trip and I-70 is the slightly longer route, I will still take it because that means I’ll get to stop and eat here. Every..."
Makena Granger
"We stumbled upon this place on our cross country trip. A local said it was a great place and it was! It was my sons birthday and the whole staff..."
Brett Woffinden
"No better place for local pastries, pies, and pizza all wrapped up in one stop! The staff is fast and friendly, and they make you feel right at..."
gary shaw
"My husband and I love the food here. They offer some amazing freshly made pastries which I cannot pass up; tasty sandwiches and pizzas. We do alot of..."
andrea Brogan
"Krista was awesome! She was super busy but very calm and personable and handled the chaos like a star. The food was also great - good portions, great..."
"I stopped today to buy the Cranberry Walnut Bread and Raisin Cookies
They are EXCELLENT!!! Everyone is so Friendly and there is so much to choose..."
Diane D'Amore Mangino
"I ordered a raspberry pie yesterday for someone's birthday! (Birthday girls request!) The pie was amazing! Everyone loved it! Everything I've ever..."
Marcie Lambert
"I’ve missed Wedding Cookies since DeRosa’s Closed down.. Two Fat Guys has the best bakery and I am in love with the Wedding Cookies. We also..."
Lindsay Brooke
"The best chocolate chip cookies EVERRRR. And the pumpkin squares are amazing..."
Courtney Carbone
"You have become my go to place when I travel home! This time we made it early, and can I say the three of us wanted to try one of everything. We..."
Terri Lynn Smith
"YUM!!! New Castle's hidden gem, their mad baking skills whip up delicious treats and..."
Mary LaDuke Turner
"Best place to live next to. I love all the baked goods. Workers are very respectful. Wedding soup and beef stew is the best I ever had even better..."
Susie Goosby
"Cannolies, doughnuts, fresh baked bread and friendly..."
Lisa DeSantis
"The stuff pepper soup was amazing!! It is mine and my other half's favorite place for lunch and snacks! Amazing bread and..."
Amber Rose Wilson
"Finally tried this place today and it was SO good! Sandwiches are awesome, wedding soup amazing, and the desserts are all so good! Wanted to try..."
Rachel Giancola-Beasley
"Superb. Just finished off the Biscotti. It was divine. Bought cannoli's and bread also and they were delicious. Highly recommend and will stop..."
Randy DiFrischia
"Mom and I had lunch there today. And we couldn't resist bringing home extra breads and pastry. Both the people and the food was wonderful. We will..."
Beth A. Miller
"I took my son in Thursday morning for donuts. We left with pizza, bread, donuts, pastries and desserts. There were so many other things he wanted..."
Lindsay Williamson Ramage
"Yummy food. I can't wait to get food from this place..."
Tyler Dombeck
"I have been eyeballing the pictures from Two Fat Guys and an Oven for weeks, but the time had come to put those sandwiches into my mouth, and they..."
Julie Kwiatkowski Schuler
"We tried Two Fat Guys and an Oven for the first time this morning and we are hooked! My husband, daughter, and I shared a bear claw, a cinnamon roll,..."
"Attended a Baby shower here, it was my 1st time to visit The Confluence Community Coffee Shop & Eatery. It is a wonderful space for a party! The food..."
Kristina Gramsky
"Love this place. The food is great and the frapes are 10xs better than Duncan, and so is there service. To top it off proceeds help..."
Kattree 213
"Nice place for a quick easy bite to eat! It was around lunch time too and the service was really fast! Nice atmosphere and I love the chalk board on..."
Melodie Campbell
"Wonderful! Great music, friendly atmosphere and just a great..."
Sharon Buttermore
"Very nice ladies work there! Got a delicious frappe and friendly conversation. The atmosphere is very nice and the conference room is very..."
Steve Van Horn
"What a gem! The staff was lovely. This place had so many delightful rooms and elements. Good coffee..."
Timmi-Jo Pashuta
"Great atmosphere, better food, and amazing coffee! Thursdays feature live music and there is an art gallery to peruse as well. All around an..."
Graham Bellassai
"Great meeting place for appointments if your on the go. The coffee, pastries & food is very good & reasonable. Hard to believe it is a nonprofit..."
"Wow! Great coffee, great service, great food. We stopped by expecting to grab a cup of coffee and ended up ordering brunch (they serve breakfast,..."
Daniel Becker
"I came to Cafe New Castle for a quick bite w/ my friend, and the food was great! Service was phenomenal, and the staff is extremely friendly. 10/10..."
Jairo Pineda
"Cozy little Restaurant/ Cafe on New Castle main Street. Good food. Right portions. Done well. Has a bar too if venturing for a night out. No..."
Jagan Pillarisetti
"Excellent coffee shop with a great brunch and reasonably priced. Large open area with both indoor and outdoor seating. A nice walk up counter for..."
Alex Darby
"Loved this quaint Cafe and look forward to writing a blog review. #DelawareBlogger..."
Antionette Blake
"Our party of four, fortunately likes to share, so we were all able to experience 4 different delicious menu items on our visit. Everything was fresh..."
Scott Adams
"First thing to know, everything about this place is slow. If you are in a hurry, don't go.
I ordered an egg cheese bacon muffin, my wife did eggs..."
Stephen Lerch
"Great breakfast spot. We tried Cafe New Castle for the first time this weekend and it was great! The food was good, came out quickly(which seems to..."
"This restaurant is exactly what it looks like good food, cheap prices, and good service. Everything was clean. The tables were arranged with plenty..."
Joss Slagle
"Literally sitting atop of a rolling hill (with a rolling, heavily-sloped parking lot), is the Hill House. Places like this have vanished from much of..."
Yetemar-Kenyell Cross
"If you haven't been to hill top in a while. It's well worth the trip as you can tell.great food and great prices for the food you..."
"This may be the best Wentworth restaurant. Right on the water at the marina. Beautiful sunsets. Open air dining. Simple and fast menu with gluten..."
Fred Lybrand
"Beautiful view of the marina, nice place for quiet lunch with water..."
Parag Shah
"We visited at the end of August with the pandemic restrictions still in place, but really liked the place. Actually, a little surprised that it was..."
Tariq Khan
"Casual and relaxed. View and breeze make it nice anytime. Prices are reasonable and fair. Worth a pop in! No parking? Try the hotel parking and..."
Chris Maxwell
"The drinks and food was great! Of you go on a warm (hot) sunny day the seating is a bit sketchy. Inside when busy is very loud. Service people are..."
Brian Berry
"This place is our secret place for breakfast sandwiches. The food is out of this world, and the scenery is also. Leisure breakfast with a view of the..."
Jim Prendergast
"One of my favorite summer food destinations! Excellent Turkey, Bacon, Pesto sandwich. Outside dining, overlooking the Wentworth..."
"Bellezza! A great piece of pizza that eats like a..."
Anthony Romano
"My most favorite pizza around! I come here alllll of the time! Always done exactly how I love..."
Mai-Linh Cruz
"We have to stop each time were in De. My husband's FAVORITE..."
Dawn MacDonald
"I got their Mexican pizza pie and absolutely loved it. Baked in a brick oven, which is delicious! The only downside is they ask for cash only but if..."
Marie New
"A pizza snubs dream Best Pizza around not a statement but challenge. If you know if better please let me know. We come from miles braving traffic. to..."
Russell Little
"This pizza is HANDS DOWN the best local pizza place in the area. Levels above Domino's, Papa John's and any other commercial 🍕 shops. Preferred..."
NeNe Flowers
"I love the white pizza with spinach and ricotta cheese. The prices are decent. The pizza is awesome. They only accept..."
Nina Griffiths
"Best pizza around these parts. Sal Mamma Gina is the..."
Frank Lagola
"Good pizza😋seating area should be cleaner..Got my pizza to..."
"This place is awesome. Great food and great service. Portion sizes are huge... prices are good for portions you get. Will definitely go back, and..."
Linda Hanrahan - Cavanaugh
"Excellent food and service. Beef Manhattan was huge and so very tender and lots of flavor! Ribeye was tender and great taste. Big piece of..."
Holly Haskell
"We have eaten there many times the food is always good and service is excellent on Thursdays and Saturdays their ribs are outstanding we love this..."
Michael Cronin
"Home for the holidays and wanted to get my Indiana tenderloin fix, my friend suggested Park Restaurant. 💥 I was definitely not disappointed! The..."
Linsey Susalla
"My wife and I took a Harley ride to New Castle. I googled restaraunts and Park Restaraunt came up. I read reviews and they were all great so we..."
Donnie Teeters
"I love Park Restaurant and especially Jo, the best server. Lots of delicious meals prepared by the best..."
Julia Rudloff
"We stopped in a couple weeks ago. Had only been there once before and at that visit my husband asked if they had steak fries. Waitress was very..."
Mariellen Tipton
"The brisket is absolutely amazing! It has such a great, smokey flavor. ..."
Kyle Laurie
"This place is amazing! I can't wait until I go through IN again on 70. I'll be stopping here for what ever meal it's time for. The service was..."
Megan VanMierlo
"Best food in town ! Try their pan fried chicken and onion rings, they are delicious �The serve is always good as..."
Tracy Denny
"If you leave here hungry it's your own fault.
Very tasty, probably the best breaded mushrooms I've had in a long time. Breaded Tenderloin was..."
Terry Deavers
"I needed a breaded tenderloin sandwich while I was in Indiana and boy did I get one. Had to take half to go but I assure you I ate every bit of it...."
Rick Ciesla
"Let's just say "Wow". I didn't think this level of service and hospitality still existed after Co-Vid 19! Sat right down. Within a minute we were..."
Alan King
"Huge portions, best waitresses, great price. Had meatloaf Manhattan biggest thing ever seen. Forgot to take a picture before. Great pea salad...."
J Denney
"Really great place to eat and the staff are you kind and nice to talk..."
Dustin Ruckman
"Home cooking! Really enjoyed our visits...so good we ate dinner two days in a..."
Sharon Ohler
"Today was our second visit and I was a little disappointed compared to our first. Service was good and my family's meals were great but the BBQ..."
"Great diner with attentive staff. A local spot with regulars but you'll feel welcome and leave full. A never empty cup of coffee is high on my list..."
Robin S
"Really good food. Great service. All of the staff are very..."
Liz Goebel
"Great mom and pop shop. Friendly servers good home style food. I will be..."
David Lucas
"Wonderful food! It's busy for a reason but worth the..."
Lisa McGuire
"Great food and the atmosphere was very nice couldn't get any better, the cook was great hot food thank you very..."
Vickie Thornton
"Awesome welcoming place, has all classic comfort foods. Highly..."
Anna McD
"One of the best, home cooked meals you'll ever eat!! This little restaurant takes you back in time when the food was fresh, people were friendly with..."
"It was my first dining experience. I Loved the menu options. A plethera of food choices. Televisions to keep you busy while your food was prepared...."
Eric Lutz
"This restaurant is a big surprise to anyone who visits. You'll see when you sit down in the friendly environment and glance at your menu its not..."
Kathleen Funk
"I've been here several times to eat and the food is always fabulous... but this place holds a lot more value to me as it was my dad's favorite place..."
Autumn Mentzer Cairns
"Hugger-Mugger has wonderful food. Was there with family and it was a wonderful experience. We had breakfast.
The waitress was so good with my great..."
Twila Zendt
"Always an awesome time there Food is great Service is excellent Anita and Brad are wonderful at night and Kathy in the morning i recommend this place..."
Cheri Kulnis
"This restaurant has the best food and service it is definitely my favorite place to..."
Rick Clingensmith
"Best food, great management and staff...can't say enough good about them. I will always return when in New..."
Marsha Bliss Leighty
"I had appetizer combo.. was fried just right, best ranch dressing hands down, my friends had chix salad, steak salad, and chicken parm, they were..."
Kelly Rowland Houk
"We lived here going on 2 years. I have always wanted to try eating there and its not too far from home so we decided to give it a try. We went..."
Kimber Simpson
"Love going at for breakfast. Portions a huge and prices are great. Large menu selections for all times of the day but if you are looking for a..."
Jennifer Timm Shields
"I recently moved back to pa from Oklahoma and have been in New Castle on business for about a month now. This is the first place that has displayed..."
Aly
"Good food, awesome service. Just moved to New Castle. Ate dinner here tonight. Young waitress, Deanna, was excellent! Food very reasonably priced...."
Paula
"Stupid Name, Decent Food, Great Prices. When this place first opened, i was skeptical to go because of the TERRIBLE name and the stupid picture of..."
Brandon Swogger
"I eat a Hugger Mugger on a regular basis, I highly enjoy the philly steak sub, I get it on most visit, but the burgers are good also. The service is..."
EB
"Great meal deals like Monday is burger day you get any burger on menu with fries and drink for..."
Md
"We wanted to find a place to stop to eat before we went to Hill view Manor for the tour. I’m glad I chose this place because it turned out to be..."
Debra T
"All of the food was amazing!! They have such a wide variety of food to choose from. The service was impeccable. All of the waitresses are very..."
Scarlet Silencer
"Was recommended by a local. As we were lead to our seats, I was looking at everyones food. Looked amazing. We both had the open faced roast beef..."
Kemberly Shaw
"We moved to the New Castle area 2 years ago and we have made several trips to this place! The food is fantastic, the place is clean, and the staff is..."
Valerie Fey
"Now this is a great breakfast and great service at a great..."
"Place is a legend. Great pizza. I love their sauce, has a nice sweet kick to it. Bread and crust has that old school Italian taste and smell. It..."
Buck
"Quaint little Italian eatery. Try the DUGOUT. Its basically a half a loaf of homemade Italian bread hollowed out and stuffed with a meatball sub..."
melissa bresky
"Pizza’s thicker than Donald Trump playing golf. Literally an inch thick. We had the eggplant pizza and it was one of the finest pizza pies we ever..."
Dalton Uber
"I should have had 5 stars so I added another one. I buy the wedding soup and more every month. It is the best and really a joy to..."
Trudy McEwen
"They have the best wedding soup. I love it paired with a pizza green. They're always nice and ready to serve..."
jennifer baxter
"Food is fantastic!! The staff is very friendly and helpful. The place smells amazing when you walk through the door!! I go almost every time I come..."
Kim Ellington
"The best Canolli, definitely recommend getting the large one. Excellent spinach and pepperoni rolls. Nice..."
Nikki Gleghorn
"Mangino's is simply the best pizza I've ever had. It's my long time favorite by a huge margin and I can't think of a higher compliment. There is just..."
"This coffee shop seems to have had a bad rap over the last few years. It has the atmosphere of a big warehouse and the customer service seemed to be..."
Randy Tooley
"Carl, Angie, and the rest of the staff outdo themselves when it comes to customer service. Be patient, good food and great service take time and both..."
Jillian Radford
"Great place for Coffee and Food. The Owner is very Awesome and great person to talk..."
Dustin Ruckman
"Good place for a good morning coffee and the bagel are..."
Sudip Joshi
"I was craving my morning latte after a night of traveling. This iced latte hit the spot! I am lactose intolerant and they had oatmilk! Thanks for..."
oNeigeo
"We had the pulled pork and the chicken ceasar wrap. The mac n cheese was delicious! The sweet tea was made to perfection. Nice, quiet atmosphere...."
Rachelle McCorkle
"So thankful for this amazing coffee shop. I proposed to my wife a year after our first date here, so it's pretty memorable for me as a place to enjoy..."
Daren Marlow
"One of the best places to eat in town. Wide variety of food & drink choices. Many healthy options. Grab one of their spritzers, they are delish!!
(A..."
"Best Pizza King in Henry, Hancock and Madison County! Pizza Kings slogan is "good to the edge" and this place truly follows that! Very generous with..."
Tina Cornett
"Best pizza king in the state...."
Lucas Mattix
"The best pizza king I've had, in 2 counties. Drive through window was hard to find at first, and the alley is nothing but potholes...but it's worth..."
sarah scott
"This is the best quality PK pizza. They don't short you on toppings, service is always friendly. My family and friends all know this is where you get..."
Mike Price
"This is the best pizza in town but depending on who is working.. sometimes when I ask to get my pizza cooked lightly so not to get hard crust around..."
"I hate tuna fish .but I love there tuna melts on a spinach bagel here . The employees are friendly and kind it seems like a famley business from the..."
Sr20boostjunkie
"Best breakfast place if you love bagels! They have almost every flavor. Your sandwich will always be made fresh and the owner is very nice &..."
Milyra Brielle
"Great experience over all. 10/10 if you want a real breakfast sandwich way better than wawa, dunkin or any other place to be honest. Tasted like you..."
Jay Doerr
"Came here based on reviews. No everything bagels left cuz I got here too late 🙃. But my bacon egg n cheese on a plain bagel was yummy anywayz...."
"My staff has been telling me to visit Hector for a cup of coffee. I went to meet him on Saturday morning. I shared my coffee predilections. He made..."
Brenda Ann Bacich
"Some of the very best coffees that Ive ever enjoyed was created with passion by Hector. 5* 's is not enough. Two Rivers and The Dirty Pickle!..."
Vincent Todd Van Voltenburg
"This place is fantastic and the folks are wonderful. The coffee is incredible and the service even better! I definitely will be back when I come home..."
Scott Robinson
"Nothing but good things to say. Excellent coffee, great music (Frank Sinatra, Dean Martin, etc.), amen defjnitely try the Key Lime Scone and white..."
Tom DiVittis
"I loved it the barista was so nice & the coffee was great. This is truly a hidden gem! I found a new love in the..."
Raychelle Ward
"Absolutely amazing cup of coffee and the atmosphere was so hip and cool !! Really enjoyed my first visit there and I cannot wait to return..."
Laura Ahmed Franks
"Some of the best coffee, food, and service..."
Eric Harper
"Literally the best coffee shop I've ever been to. Hidden gem to say the..."
Michael Capo
"This is a hidden the gem for coffee in new castle. I haven't had a better cup anywhere..."
Alex AT
"Two Rivers is such an asset to the city of New Castle! The place brings an art culture with an inspiring and relaxing atmosphere to the city. Thanks..."
Suzanne Bobosky Matteo
"The perfect place if you're looking for a really good cup of coffee. Great atmosphere, friendly owners, and just a cool place overall. Definitely..."
Valentine J. Brkich
"Delicious coffee, wonderful atmosphere, and delightful..."
Gwen McConahy Soares
"Great coffee, service and view. We will be..."
Nonie McD
"Coffee is ssssoooo good!! I'd have to say the Bliss tea is my favorite though. Wonderful happy staff. They host great events and have a patio for the..."
Aliciabare4477
"This place has a good feel, although perhaps a bit eccentric as far as coffee shops go. Food was good. Coffee was good. Service was good. Outside..."
Jerry Christensen
"One of my favorite places to just sit and relax on my laptop. Amazing people and delicious coffee in a friendly atmosphere! A must go if you are a..."
Shannon Green
"Great coffee and great service. The caramel latte is amazing. It doesn't need any sugar. It's so..."
Matron Malice
"Best Cappuccino I've ever had. I really enjoyed my time here sitting by the river or enjoying the inside lounge. Great people, space and..."
Ryan McCullough
"Even though Two Rivers Artisian Coffee Works has been here for several years, it's a new discovery to me. Wow what a great coffee shop. Not only an..."
Michael Mansour
"I found my new home away from home. Anyone who says coffee is coffee has certainly not experienced Two Rivers. I was so impressed with the..."
John Yingst
"Great place for coffee. I'm a resident of New Castle and this place is a gem. Coffee is great and food is good,..."
Landon Stuart
"Not a big coffee drinker, but my friends love it. The atmosphere is great, it's our go to hangout downtown. Docking them a star cause their hours..."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes