5 restaurant menus in New Castle, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"I try to get here with some regularity - like once or twice a year - and they never have been a disappointment. Love the atmosphere and the food..."
Brad Billet
"The food was great, I had chicken pot pie and my husband the pilgrims platter. Great food and a good price. My only complaint is that it’s small..."
Janel Flanagan
"Love the Colonial atmosphere! A fantastic variety of beers! The Belgian beers are the best �.
The food is very good. Good service. Good music...."
Bieke Lieckens
"The Thanksgiving dinner was excellent. Our waitress was great even with a packed house.
The portion was large and we took home enough for another..."
Mike Oller Sr.
"The food is good. The place is historic with a cozy atmosphere and the service was friendly. Most satisfying of all, the number of Belgian ales on..."
Bill Derksen
"The food was excellent. If you order the meatloaf you will need to share it or take a portion home for a later meal. The atmosphere is fantastic! I..."
Geary Hower
"I have eaten here several times and I am never disappointed. The staff is friendly, the food is delicious and the atmosphere is authentic! I truly..."
Amy Reese Britz
"I had a hot roast beef sandwich and my better half had the hot pastrami both sandwiches were over the top deliscous and so were the sweet potato..."
John Asbury Cooper
"My daughter and I had a delicious dinner here. Started with waffle fries with “cheesy crab goodness “ on top. Yummy! She had salmon and I had..."
Tina Pasini George
"Excellent food, service, and atmosphere. I'd recommend this place to..."
Joe Williams
"The place is a great atmosphere, terrific staff, and fabulous..."
Ken Warner
"This place is so cool, it’s a Colonial tavern type setting. The food is fantastic, and the beers are equally as good! The service here is..."
Ryan Hester
"Great hearty food! Service and atmosphere is in..."
Erin Langford
"Great food and atmosphere! Don't miss the Shepard's pie or the peach cobbler! Nice wine selection, I recommend the the red..."
Patti Ann
"Awesome Bar, if you are looking for wings don’t stop here! This isn’t our ordinary bar, this is a Colonial style bar, featuring comfort food like..."
Milton Maisonet
"Every bit as good as advertised. Hands down the best food and service I had on my vacation. Great atmosphere and decor. Nestled walking distance from..."
Dennis Bagwell
"This is a hidden gem in gorgeous New Castle downtown area. The Shepheard,s Pie and Fish and Chips are award winning and people come from all over..."
Cindy Ruth
"Overall, this is a good place to eat. The crab dip was good but the items that came with it like the hard thin toast , the celery, and the carrots..."
Greg Reed
"Wow, great food! Great atmosphere! Step in the door and step back 300 years! The mussels were delicious. The pot pie so savory. Leave 2022 behind and..."
Diana Kenny
"It was so fun to eat at this restaurant!! I would call to make a reservation though. We made a reservation for 5 on the computer and it didn't go..."
Victoria Simpson
"This wasn’t an ordinary dinner. It was an event where the event was the meal. From the appetiser, to the main course, to the desert the food was..."
"Phenomenal! It’s a dive in the very best way. Staff is too sweet. Shrimp was on point. Crab queso with house-made flour tortilla chips is literally..."
Tina Everitt
"My crabs were very tasty. Second trip there. Great staff and friendly atomsphere. The crabs were hot and fresh out of the pot. Very juicy and well..."
Yolanda Bowman-Lipscomb
"5 star Service along with the best crabs hands down, actually all their food is amazing, you won’t leave..."
Jamie L Nolte
"The blue crabs were very tasty...first time I believe I had Texas blue crab. Service was great, waitress was very nice, all around great place!..."
Sophia Brittany Chiampas
"Fat heavy crabs perfectly seasoned and excellent service. If you're spending your hard earned dollars on crabs get your money's worth. This is the..."
Butch Lokey
"I love their service!!! Krista is the best!!! The staff always makes sure you have a good experience whenever you come..."
Jamal Henderson
"One of my favorite places for Crabs and seafood. The customer service and atmosphere is always great. I have recommended them to everyone I know and..."
Nadiyah Shuron
"Love this place. Exceptional food and service. Owners are fabulous..."
Jeff Webber
"Delicious and well seasoned full crabs. Service was good and staff friendly. Great place for..."
Noreen Petruccelli Furth
"I had the Cajun steamed crabs tonight they were amazing !! Was there for my birthday dinner I never had them that way before but think I found my new..."
Carrie Evans
"The best crabs I've EVER had. Omgoodness really delicious! Highly..."
Carolyn Bonelli
"Awesome place..great staff...great crabs..we will go there..."
Deborah Scales
"I the food is excellent and cooked the way you want it . They are friendly people. The place is clean. It's a great family place. I can't wait to..."
Barbara Lang Johnston
"I love Lestardos, the crabs were excellent, they were nice and full with great taste! The seasoning were a great asset😋🦀 The honey barbecue..."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes