The best Restaurants in New Hartford ranking of February 2025
145 restaurant menus in New Hartford, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
"Phenomenal food and outstanding service. Best food I've had in the area in years. Definitely returning for sure!! 10..."
lynda fontenot
"Was great. It was my birthday 🎂 and me and my wife had a good time. Food was perfect. Staff was super friendly. Glad they didn't sing to my old..."
Matthew Kilbourn
"Honestly I've avoided this place bc of the peanut shells on the floor. But my brother let me know that it is not that way anymore.
I absolutely..."
Tracy Parry
"I brought my son with me for dinner, since he gave me a gift card for Mother's Day. My son is 11 and was happy to be able to take his mom out to..."
Amanda Kohler
"This place is fun, staff is friendly, rolls are amazing and the portions are certainly the size of Texas. The only reason I didn’t give 5 stars is..."
"We searched for a 2nd KFC location because the first one was out of chicken wings and almost out of chicken for a Family Fill Up. We got lucky with..."
Susan Shambo
"In the past, service has been slow, the place has been dirty, and the chicken overly greasy. That was not the case today. Our order taker was..."
Brad Cornette
"I love KFC chicken but I find everything else just disappoints. Today was the fry's how are they hot yet soggy and limp? I say stick to what you know..."
Trisha Diaz
"Place was clean and people were really nice and everything was cooked great thanks for our dinner..."
Matt Davis
"Always get a good meal here. Clean and staff is very..."
"A decent lunch option, especially for those with a taste for a little bit healthier food, or a craving for some delicious bread of all varieties...."
Paige
"Great food forba chain restaurant. Everything was fresh and good. Ordered lunch for hubs and I am it was quick. The place was really..."
Heather Phillips
"On a day when my daughter and I are really hungry, we'll go to PB and order our favorite foods. Usually the soup and sandwich deal and their mac and..."
Gma Mose
"Service was a little slow, but it was a Sunday at lunch time. Love that they offer outdoor seating. Food was..."
"This restaurant is always my favorite when it comes to sushi and RAW items menu. Daily fresh. Fast and friendly staff.
Highend atmosphere.
And food..."
Khang Le
"We celebrated my Dad's 67 Birthday at The Red Samurai Steak House and it was amazing!!! We came in as a party of 10 without needing a reservation and..."
Smarter Life
"Let me tell you something, if you havent been here yet, bring your family, choose the Hibachi service, and you will NOT be disappointed! The Chef was..."
Dead Wolf
"Went for the hibachi and really can't say what a good time it was. Food was reasonably priced and the serving size was almost obscenely large (felt..."
Wriley Nelson
"It's the best Hibachi spot in the area. Love the show they give you. Everyone is friendly. It's very clean. The only reason why I don't give a 5 star..."
angeline hildenbrandt
"Excellent food and service. Visiting from out of state, but The Sexy Lady Roll is going to be my favorite next time I come back. Great..."
Wendy’S Classic Chocolate and Vanilla Frosty Desserts
Wendy’S Coffee Drinks Hot Coffee Cold-Brew and Frosty -Ccino
Wendy’S Taco Salad and Apple Pecan Chicken Salad
Wendy’S Baked Potatoes
Wendy’S All Natural Strawberry and Tropical Berry Lemonades
Wendy's Hot & Crispy Fries
Sit down
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
"The staff does a good job, and it's good to see a restaurant with lower priced menu items right now while other chains are marking up prices. Great..."
Sangrias Made with a Blend of Chilled Wine Fresh Fruit and a Splash of Fruit Juices
Salad
Shrimp Alfredo Fettuccine Alfredo Tossed with Sautéed Shrimp
Chicken Marsala Fettuccine
Pesto
Never Ending Dipping Sauces for Breadsticks
Eggplant Parmigiana
Sangria
Never-Ending Soup Salad & Breadsticks
Pumpkin Cheesecake
Minestrone soup
Spaghetti & Meatballs 2 with Meat Sauce 680 Cal
Lemonade
PUDDING
Lettuce
Stuffed Mushrooms
Sit down
Italian
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Takeout
Reservations
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"We had an amazing experience. The waiter Skeeter was one of the best waiters I have ever worked with. He seemed to enjoy his job was super pleasant..."
Shannon Booth
"It's the staff that make this restaurant. I've been to quite a few olive garden's and it's hard to critique a chain restaurant. The food was..."
Shelby G
"Very pleasant staff. Food was prepared quickly and with..."
Lorenzo O. Jackson zostrive@hotmail.com
"Visited Olive Garden after being denied service at another restaurant. As we were celebrating my Brother's graduation, we were looking forward to a..."
Beverley Williams-Chandler
"Had one of the best experiences, we have had at a restaurant. Service was amazing all around. Food was fresh and and prepared to our liking. Although..."
mzinger93
"Always can count on a good quality meal as well as clean pleasant facility. Soup salad combo makes an excellent late lunch early dinner choice...."
polly anna
"Five stars to the manager. After leaving a medical appointment last week I stopped at Olive Garden for lunch. The manager took time to ask me..."
SHARON FORCEY
"Great service. We went right after church and although my husband’s steak took some extra time, the waitress was very..."
"The food was delicious, the restaurant was clean and had a nice seaside feel. Hailey the server did and excellent..."
Terrance Ray Trybus
"Wonderful staff there from host to kitchen staff and the managers there, everyone is so great. We went there a few days ago and Candy was our server...."
Jeanne Turner
"The waitress was courteous place was maintained up to pare. The Garlic Chicken Alfredo & Salad, Biscuits were on the money it hit the spot. It was..."
Mignonne Solomon
"This was the best Red Lobster that I have ever been to! Very good waitress, good timing between apps and the main course. The food was cooked..."
Cheryl Otero
"Took my son out for his birthday. Everything was amazing from the time we walked in until the time we left. Our waiter was very friendly and went..."
Lauren Varno
"Our party 0f six was served by the funniest waitress, very sweet. The shrimp combo dinner over linguine with Alfredo sausage was delicious and in..."
"Excellent place, and highly recommend this place, lot's of options, some nice daily specials, and 2 for 1 drinks is a real nice bonus. I had the..."
David S
"Excellent fresh baked warm bread with seasoned butter! Our waitress, Catie, is absolutely a gem! She got our orders absolutely perfect, a cheery..."
Molly Cecil
"Used to be a huge favorite of mine, but they fell off for a couple years with food quality. Very happy to say that it seems they are back to their..."
Paige
"Great service and delicious food! Love the atmosphere as well, the antiques are..."
Chrissy France
"To put in bluntly...Carmella's is a great place to eat!! Excellent food, great service, with an extensive menu, best describes this eatery in Utica,..."
"Came here for lunch and had a great time. The waitress and staff were very friendly. At the end of my meal she brought a box without even asking..."
Tom S
"Just had dinner this evening around 630 and though it was a bit busy, we got there at a perfect time, my fiance took me out for my 34th birthday and..."
Jeff
"Casual dining with a friendly staff. Food is always great and prepared as ordered. My only gripe with this restaurant is that they like to change the..."
Brian Schell
"Service is always with a smile. The food is awesome as well! You get the rarity in steak that you ask for, every time I've been it's been super..."
Jake Whitney
"Had a wonderful time, excellent food, and our waiter Tom was on point. Would definitely recommend! I had the Country Fried Chicken and my girlfriend..."
"Have been here a few times. Food is always fresh. Customer service has always been on point, and have never seen any issues with cleanliness. This is..."
Roberto
"You can't beat the fries, nothing like fresh. The prices are super reasonable. Great fries and burgers, but def check your order before you leave...."
Paige
"Good burger but cooked well done. Great selection of toppings for the..."
J
"Great service and food is always..."
Clifford Maxwell
"Fast service. Great food. Helpful staff. You can't go wrong eating..."
LJ Gorton
"My favorite burger joint here..oh yeah!..they use peanut oil to fry their all natural French Fries...its pricey but your paying for quality "pink..."
"Went for the first time with my fiance last night and oh my goodness. Loved the atmosphere, loved the staff, and the food was so amazing! It felt..."
Cece Caraballo
"Excellent food & portion sizes. Handicapped parking (4 spaces) not available, parking lot was full, so access was a bit further & more difficult for..."
Thomas Woods
"Went to One Genny for the first time last night, and absolutely loved my experience. As a fellow server from a different establishment, I know the..."
Corey Boice
"We had a great time, the place was very clean and looked adorable, the services were excellent and most importantly the breakfast was..."
Ida Gjinali
"Bills itself as a craft beer bar but much of the menu was 'crafty' (produced by transnational conglomerates as opposed to small craft breweries) but,..."
"Still our Friday night jam since the 1980s and now I don't have to read 100 books to get it! I mean, I do anyway. It tastes exactly the same as it..."
Colleen Conway
"Very clean and really nice the staff were really nice I would recommend pizza 🍕🍕🍕 hut plenty of parking and the food was great thanks for..."
Matt Davis
"Highly recommend always love the food service was great and the Cajun rub wings are the bomb loved our..."
Bullitt Hulk
"Pizza was perfectly cooked, tasted wonderful. Staff was very friendly and took care of me promptly. Very happy with the service I received..."
Elis Soto
"Always a good experi3nce here. Sometimes they are busy and only one server so it can be a bit..."
"They have the everything wings here that are known in the area, reviews from my group said they were good and they recommended them to others the..."
Tillium
"Hubby and I are new in town and this place always looked like it wouldn't be a comfy fit for us. One night, we were out of options and we decided to..."
Nicky M
"Great food FANTASTIC service Valley Girl! Great way to end/start the year. Fish fry and Angry Irishman..."
Christopher Connolly
"If you want the best wings ever, you need to try the everything wings. They're amazing! The antipasto salad was perfect for 2 and quite tasty. Great..."
Jacqueline Newton
"The "everything" wings here are all in the name, better than everything else in terms of wing sauce! Come on in, and ask for..."
Darnell Culbreath
"We went for St. Pats Day. The place was packed, but since we made reservations it was only abt 20 min til we were seated. Even tho there were only 2..."
"Our food was decent. Exactly what you'd expect from an IHOP. The service lacked a bit, our waitress did inform us that she was new. She was very nice..."
"Our waiter Jordan K. was the best! Food and drinks were..."
nancy kennedy
"I've been here a few times now and we've had a great experience. Amazing food quality, amazing service every time from the same waitress (Alexis) so..."
Tuezo Music
"Food, served hot . Wait staff was not the friendliest for a lunch time meal. Not busy only one other table in our section. Drinks were brought..."
Cheryl Nowakowski
"Our server Melissa said it was her 3rd day well, you couldn't tell! She was amazing!! Food came out timely and hot. Definitely will be..."
Stacy Giordano
"Nice hostess, super nice waitress, Melissa. When you have good service it makes everything good.
Drinks and food were..."
Mar W
"It was close to closing time, so we had to take our food to go. But, the Pina Colada I had while I waited wasn't too bad. Would return in the near..."
"Pretty sure my daughter got sick from the food. It's usually hit or miss here. The food is either fresh and taste pretty good for what it is or it's..."
Brittany
"Good fast service as one would expect from a " fast food " place . Clean also when I walked in . Had to use the wi-fi so I had a meal while I did..."
Christopher Voce
"Food was great and hot, not just thrown together like some McDonald's. However, the staff always seem to be a bit tense and snobby at this location...."
"Our family of 6 had a wonderful time! Love the dragon sushi (large sushi pictured - also pictured is tuna sushi) and habacki scallops (pictured) the..."
Dawn Farrar
"Always a great time and amazing food. My family loves it here. Kids especially love the hibachi..."
Lauren Varno
"Very good taste. Best food out there. Ton if food for your..."
Kuria Andino
"Love the food and the drinks. The quiet atmosphere is pretty amazing and staff is sweet and kind. Only place I'll go for..."
Kristie Laribee
"This place has no chill, they'll give your newborn a sake shot they don't care. It's got decent food and atmosphere. Your basically paying extra to..."
Kevin Brown
"The amount of food you get you could easily feed 2 people from one plate. The food was outstanding. The service was..."
"Hot wings are spot on with Buffalo Wing standards and are comparable to the any wings found in Buffalo NY. The stuffed pizza is litterally one big..."
Charles A Ogin IV
"Wings, bread, blue cheese & pizza. Oh, those Tuesday wing nights from the college..."
Bca33
"Most of our food was very good. My friends son did not care for the pizza at all. We all got different things and most everyone liked what they..."
Jennie B
"Enjoyed my first visit. Everything Wings were delicious as was the stuffed shells. Loved the Guinness on draft.
The wait staff were very attentive..."
Anthony De Souza
"First time. Food was tasty. Staff was super friendly.
There were some inconsistencies--
Side salads hubby's was twice the size and included iceberg,..."
Toni Vadala
"Sandy was a excellent server .the food was delicious. And plentiful. 36 yrs ago we had our first date here brought our sons here all the time till..."
"First time having greens and chicken riggies. They were both very..."
David C
"Love it!. Always a great lunch, very reasonable price. Good..."
Lauren3517
"Fantastic. Village greens are..."
Rich
"Food is great but the place is always so noisy that it's stressful. We get takeout only from there due to the noise. Try the..."
Sqwrell
"I have always enjoyed excellent food and great service at this restaurant! Definitely a local..."
Jeckina
"The Best. Hands down one of the best and most overlooked Italian restaurants in the Utica area. THE best Greens..."
Chris
"Excellent customer service, great presentation of the food, and the drinks are fantastic. Great environment and good place to go out with friends. ..."
Wendy G
"WOW. This is the best meal I’ve EVER had. The stuffed filet is to die for. The bartender, Kayla, is GREAT. Do not skip dessert. Please just trust..."
Steph Sullin
"Everything was delicious. I would of have given it a 5 star but my chicken Parmesan was beyond tough. I took my first bite and let’s just say my..."
ReviewsWithElitE
"Took my mom and my bride for lunch. The food was very good. I especially enjoyed the greens. I also had pasta fagiole with escarole. The tiramisu..."
david gutowski
"Great for Italian and Utica flavors. Drinks are made well here too. Friendly staff, good prices, nice atmosphere. This spot is a favorite for..."
Nicholas DiGennaro
"I stopped by for lunch because I knew there was a good buffet. We were seated on a Wednesday at 1230pm right away. I like that there is outdoor..."
Tom Uzi
"It's no wonder it's the best Italian food in Utica. Had an absolutely wonderful meal and our server Alyse did an amazing job keeping up with our 9..."
"The suhsi rolls is alright, pretty standard. Hibachi is pretty fun, and good portion of food. Missing 1 star is because this is the first Japanese..."
"We usually have a great experience here. I'm giving 4 stars instead of 5 today because we got room temperature pizza and warm draft beer. The flavors..."
Karlene Brazie
"We stopped in for appetizers late evening. The employees were polite and professional. Very welcoming. The food was great. We recommend this..."
Cindy Harrington Stoffle
"Good food service was very friendly and very quick at getting our food ready...definitely recommend this place if you're in the..."
Hope and Brett Winne
"Always a fantastic experience. The staff takes the time to make sure everything is right, from the host to the server to the manager. Food is..."
"Love the food, the price point and the gentleman serving is always polite, friendly and quick to finish up orders! Also has an option for email..."
El Vale
"Its always so good everytime i..."
Kristy Mccarthy
"Love this place , everything is fresh an a variety to choose from , good service and nice portion size..."
Sara Rice
"The tonkotsu ramen is amazing and the owner is great! I've had ramen in various places in NY and none of them have compared to the ramen bowls here...."
C C
"So good!
Very friendly, super clean.
Stop in you won’t regret it!..."
honore silver
"love this place so much and such a great way to eat healthy because it tastes delicious..."
Ivy Dong
"I love this place, especially because you can build your own bowl and the ingredients are super fresh! I hope they get their own place soon. The..."
"This place is amazing. Simply wonderful. The food is diverse and flavorful, the atmosphere is chic and sophisticated, the prices are reasonable and..."
Brenda Tucker
"The food here is amazing. Stuffed grape leaves and Gyro, the best!
The servers are really helpful and it was crowded when we got here! And the owners..."
St Mull
"Authentic middle eastern food from a beloved local family. Great service, great..."
Daniel Dischiavo
"One of my favorite places to eat! The food and service are..."
PJB
"First trip to the Grapevine at New Hartford Shopping Center. Overall, I was positively impressed with the meal served to me and my..."
Bob Joy
"I really loved the vegetarian platter there ..
My husband loved the Tahini cauliflower appetizer and Babaganouge. We both were full after our meal..."
Komal Shekhar
"Came with a medium sized party here. Food was absolutely delicious and fresh. Service was nothing short of extraordinary! First time ever at this..."
"Great first experience here. As soon as you walk in make sure you have room for ice cream! Cute tables, and environment. Food selection from burgers,..."
Farmahbane5oh
"I walked in after a rough day for an ice cream. I was greeted by Kayla (manager) who gave off so much positivity. I was served by Angela, quick..."
Me and My girls
"We were in town for my nieces Gymnastics Competition and we stopped here after, as it’s been years since we visited a Friendly’s. Dakota was our..."
James Patrick
"Haven't been to Friendly's for 15 years since it closed in my city. Jim Dandy was a treat we bought in little tubs from the store and were a reminder..."
Anthony De Souza
"Friendly's has been a local favorite for a long time. They always have wonderful service, and a great atmosphere. They have lots to choose from menu..."
Jason Keenan
"We came in for lunch and was greeted by Kayla who took her time with us when we were ordering. She gave us excellent recommendations. They food was..."
Sano Gene
"I frequent Friendly's so often Samra has my order in before I am even seated. She knows what I like,makes sure my soup is hot and my hot fudge is..."
"Healthy options, hot or cold options and lots of choices. Like how they will customize or you can create your own.
Plenty of seating and seems..."
Kerry Smith
"This restaurant is a gluten free / food allergy person's dream come true! We ordered the Chicken Cobb Salad and 2 freshly made lemonades, and they..."
Peter Wiernicki
"Not too bad. Lots of choices. A little on the expensive side. Example large salad around $10. Tables and floor not clean. Even after being there..."
Kenneth Parkhurst Jr
"Very nice salad bar. A bit pricey for what it is but a good variety of toppings and dressings as well as soups and..."
"I really like Chipotle. It's like a more expensive version of Moe's Southwestern Grill. It also has much less selection than Moe's. That doesn't..."
Tom Vermeulen
"The food is delicious, and it's all real ingredients cut up in the store daily. The one employee named Bonnie is always willing to help and go above..."
Darryl Miller
"What you’d expect from a Chipotle. Service was good, food was good, and the place was clean.
Was an early lunch and the place was fairly..."
Kerry Smith
"Yesterday was my first ever visit to a Chipotle. It was really clean and nice walking in, and the staff was very friendly. Thank you for keeping rice..."
Christina Marie
"Fast service, open when they say they are, good quality food. Now if only the other Chipotles in New England could figure out how to do their jobs..."
"Probably some of the best pizza in the area. As you can see by my phone all the driver screw this one up. They have a great tomato pie. Eat it cold,..."
J
"Now usually, I have no problems with Sicilian delight. In fact, their Sicilian pizza is my FAVORITE. But I was sadly disappointed today when I got my..."
Bloxer Blawk
"excellent pizza, macaroni, meatballs, rolls(pepperoni,spinach, buffalo chicken) chicken tenders french fries. best place to cater or go in and eat in..."
petey calabrese
"Their pizza was very good hot off the oven. They do pizza right prepare each pizza with..."
John Hector Heinen
"Legitimate thin crust Italian pizza...they also have rolls and ect. It was pretty amazing. Thank..."
Anna Sinigur
"I just wanted to say thank you! I lived in New Hartford from 1984-1987 (high school) and this was my favorite pizza. I took a trip to New Hartford..."
Karen Stewart
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes