Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in New Hartford
15 restaurant menus in New Hartford, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"Delicious Italian bread, beautiful cases of cookies and pastries, friendly, helpful staff, everything I bought was delicious and fresh! Great..."
Stephanie Crain
"Walked in to buy fresh tomato pie. Walked out with 2 boxes of pie, several pastries and about $25 lighter. Totally worth it. Surprised a friend..."
Nancy Marafioti
"Great bagels and baked goods. The cafe offers a nice breakfast and lunch menu. Everyone is very nice and..."
Mark Dunn
"Best Italian cookies around
Great..."
Scott
"Wonderful pastries, delicious food..."
Harry Buck
"What a hidden gem this place is! Friendly, clean and comfortable this is exceptional for a bakery in this part of the country. The baked good are..."
Jesse-Len Rouse
"Visited here recently and had a very difficult time choosing what to bring home for dessert. After hemming and hawing, I settled on the Cannoli..."
Amber Miller
"Excellent food and service at a great price. They have lots of breads and baked goods for in store and to take home. We had a muffin, bagel breakfast..."
"It’s Saint Joseph’s day and also my daughter’s 24th birthday. What started out to be a nightmare was turned into a fantastic night. The only..."
Sam C
"Very nice place. The bar area is a little small and people who are waiting are right on top of you, but that is what you have. The food is very..."
Mark Dunn
"The place was clean and the food was good. Decent prices and great service. Fish oreganata was..."
J
"$55 in total (+$5 tip). For all of this from Cafe CaNole. They claim it feeds 4-6.....but it’s more like 6-10!! This is an unbelievably generous..."
Sihab Mahmud
"First time visit. Ordered Bistro Chicken with risotto. Possibly the best chicken dish I've had in a very long time. (3) of us ordered this entree and..."
Mike Morotti (NY Mike)
"Very pleasant dinner and amazing flavour in each course. We travelled for work and ended up staying in the hotel near the restaurant.I am so glad we..."
Iryna McK
"One of the best dessert places in the Utica area. This is a staple for both homeowners as well as travelers. I personally like the cannollis and..."
"Excellent place, and highly recommend this place, lot's of options, some nice daily specials, and 2 for 1 drinks is a real nice bonus. I had the..."
David S
"Excellent fresh baked warm bread with seasoned butter! Our waitress, Catie, is absolutely a gem! She got our orders absolutely perfect, a cheery..."
Molly Cecil
"Used to be a huge favorite of mine, but they fell off for a couple years with food quality. Very happy to say that it seems they are back to their..."
Paige
"Great service and delicious food! Love the atmosphere as well, the antiques are..."
Chrissy France
"To put in bluntly...Carmella's is a great place to eat!! Excellent food, great service, with an extensive menu, best describes this eatery in Utica,..."
"Went for the first time with my fiance last night and oh my goodness. Loved the atmosphere, loved the staff, and the food was so amazing! It felt..."
Cece Caraballo
"Excellent food & portion sizes. Handicapped parking (4 spaces) not available, parking lot was full, so access was a bit further & more difficult for..."
Thomas Woods
"Went to One Genny for the first time last night, and absolutely loved my experience. As a fellow server from a different establishment, I know the..."
Corey Boice
"We had a great time, the place was very clean and looked adorable, the services were excellent and most importantly the breakfast was..."
Ida Gjinali
"Bills itself as a craft beer bar but much of the menu was 'crafty' (produced by transnational conglomerates as opposed to small craft breweries) but,..."
"The staff was knowledgable and wicked friendly. Pizzeria was super clean and well lit. Pizza was amazing! Hot and fresh even after my 10 minute drive..."
Philip Ogopogo
"Amazing Pizza! Just had that pizza with some everything sauce and I couldn't stop eating it. Top nothing service too! Walk in and see the owners..."
Frank Cotrupe
"Stopped in here with a hungry crowd of 48 people. It was a planned buffet and it was absolutely amazing!! Spot on in every aspect. Baked Ziti had..."
Patty Bosshammer
"This is the best out of the Tony’s Pizzas. Consistent food and service. Downgraded to 2 stars the pizza was over sauced which is a common mistake..."
J
"We got a few sandwiches and some fried dough. All was good, the staff was friendly, and the cost was..."
michael brown
"The pizza was pretty good. We got two 12" and we could have easily shared 1. The menu says plain, which means red sauce. Garlic means a white or oil..."
"Probably some of the best pizza in the area. As you can see by my phone all the driver screw this one up. They have a great tomato pie. Eat it cold,..."
J
"Now usually, I have no problems with Sicilian delight. In fact, their Sicilian pizza is my FAVORITE. But I was sadly disappointed today when I got my..."
Bloxer Blawk
"excellent pizza, macaroni, meatballs, rolls(pepperoni,spinach, buffalo chicken) chicken tenders french fries. best place to cater or go in and eat in..."
petey calabrese
"Their pizza was very good hot off the oven. They do pizza right prepare each pizza with..."
John Hector Heinen
"Legitimate thin crust Italian pizza...they also have rolls and ect. It was pretty amazing. Thank..."
Anna Sinigur
"I just wanted to say thank you! I lived in New Hartford from 1984-1987 (high school) and this was my favorite pizza. I took a trip to New Hartford..."
"First time having greens and chicken riggies. They were both very..."
David C
"Love it!. Always a great lunch, very reasonable price. Good..."
Lauren3517
"Fantastic. Village greens are..."
Rich
"Food is great but the place is always so noisy that it's stressful. We get takeout only from there due to the noise. Try the..."
Sqwrell
"I have always enjoyed excellent food and great service at this restaurant! Definitely a local..."
Jeckina
"The Best. Hands down one of the best and most overlooked Italian restaurants in the Utica area. THE best Greens..."
Chris
"Excellent customer service, great presentation of the food, and the drinks are fantastic. Great environment and good place to go out with friends. ..."
Wendy G
"WOW. This is the best meal I’ve EVER had. The stuffed filet is to die for. The bartender, Kayla, is GREAT. Do not skip dessert. Please just trust..."
Steph Sullin
"Everything was delicious. I would of have given it a 5 star but my chicken Parmesan was beyond tough. I took my first bite and let’s just say my..."
ReviewsWithElitE
"Took my mom and my bride for lunch. The food was very good. I especially enjoyed the greens. I also had pasta fagiole with escarole. The tiramisu..."
david gutowski
"Great for Italian and Utica flavors. Drinks are made well here too. Friendly staff, good prices, nice atmosphere. This spot is a favorite for..."
Nicholas DiGennaro
"I stopped by for lunch because I knew there was a good buffet. We were seated on a Wednesday at 1230pm right away. I like that there is outdoor..."
Tom Uzi
"It's no wonder it's the best Italian food in Utica. Had an absolutely wonderful meal and our server Alyse did an amazing job keeping up with our 9..."
"The place isn't much to look at but the prime rib is the best I've had anywhere. Wait staff is friendly and fast. Food all looked great. Get there..."
Pamela Campbell
"The food was AMAZING! I got the lobster bisque also and anytime they have it I would highly recommend it. I also wanted to thank our waitress who was..."
Savannah Martin
"My husband and I stopped in last night 3/16/22 and it was so good. The waiter was extremely busy and very patient. We love the Utica greens. We both..."
Martha Downs
"Friday night. There was a short wait time and everyone was so attentive. Making sure we were OK to wait. Kept coming back to update us. Very nice..."
Chris Rayno
"Food good but too small and cramped to feel comfortable dining..."
Cheryl Mattern
"Great service and great food. I love the house salad dressing. My favorite is the Sammy Steak and the Chicken..."
Pink Mango
"Excellent food, Excellent service. Can't wait to go..."
"Food was phenomenal and service was quick and friendly. Fresh hot bread everytime we asked for more. Highly..."
Jennifer Lemon
"Bella Cucina is a small Italian restaurant that is simply put, top notch. My recent visit was for dinner for my wife and me. Everyone we encountered..."
Bob Joy
"Fabulous food and service. Wait staff was very friendly and attentive. Took a large group and everyone was exceptionally pleased with their..."
Tamara Mitchell
"Our dinners were wonderful and throughly enjoyed. Ready when we told they would be. Even though we knew that they were extremely busy...."
SUE KOCHEM
"The food was out of this world delicious. The staff was very friendly and professional. The proportions of food were excellent. Could not ask for a..."
Dwayne Nemo
"Superb restaurant, high quality service, excellent food, very friendly people with a beautiful, relaxing atmosphere. Would definitely recommend 👌..."
Becky Sutton
"We had a perfect Christmas Office party here. Wonderful room food was great service was excellent!!!!
This is the 2nd year we have had ot here and I..."
Christine Rudd
"It's been our go-to spot. It just reminds you of going to an old school Italian American place. When you walk in you just smell the flavor through..."
Sangrias Made with a Blend of Chilled Wine Fresh Fruit and a Splash of Fruit Juices
Salad
Shrimp Alfredo Fettuccine Alfredo Tossed with Sautéed Shrimp
Chicken Marsala Fettuccine
Pesto
Sangria
Never Ending Dipping Sauces for Breadsticks
Eggplant Parmigiana
Sit down
Italian
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"We had an amazing experience. The waiter Skeeter was one of the best waiters I have ever worked with. He seemed to enjoy his job was super pleasant..."
Shannon Booth
"It's the staff that make this restaurant. I've been to quite a few olive garden's and it's hard to critique a chain restaurant. The food was..."
Shelby G
"Very pleasant staff. Food was prepared quickly and with..."
Lorenzo O. Jackson zostrive@hotmail.com
"Visited Olive Garden after being denied service at another restaurant. As we were celebrating my Brother's graduation, we were looking forward to a..."
Beverley Williams-Chandler
"Had one of the best experiences, we have had at a restaurant. Service was amazing all around. Food was fresh and and prepared to our liking. Although..."
mzinger93
"Always can count on a good quality meal as well as clean pleasant facility. Soup salad combo makes an excellent late lunch early dinner choice...."
polly anna
"Five stars to the manager. After leaving a medical appointment last week I stopped at Olive Garden for lunch. The manager took time to ask me..."
SHARON FORCEY
"Great service. We went right after church and although my husband’s steak took some extra time, the waitress was very..."
"Just ordered a large EBA pizza from Tony's. To be brief.... I don't think I have ever had a better pizza! Crust, toppings, portions, flavor,..."
Bob Joy
"Fantastic, phenomenal place. 10/10 would recommend for a date night. Only go if you are coordinating colors. Great job..."
Kelly Bishop
"Had my sons Father to Be party here. The owner is so accommodating and the hostess (Samantha) was beyond incredible! It was catered to perfection and..."
Nichole ATW
"Great food! Good atmosphere, some of the best wings in the upstate..."
Tim Fortier
"Great place, nice bar, and fresh..."
C Mease
"Excellent service and the best..."
Carvon Braziervfuvhhbjon
"Best antipasto salad. Really good pizza and wings. Super friendly..."
"Hot wings are spot on with Buffalo Wing standards and are comparable to the any wings found in Buffalo NY. The stuffed pizza is litterally one big..."
Charles A Ogin IV
"Wings, bread, blue cheese & pizza. Oh, those Tuesday wing nights from the college..."
Bca33
"Most of our food was very good. My friends son did not care for the pizza at all. We all got different things and most everyone liked what they..."
Jennie B
"Enjoyed my first visit. Everything Wings were delicious as was the stuffed shells. Loved the Guinness on draft.
The wait staff were very attentive..."
Anthony De Souza
"First time. Food was tasty. Staff was super friendly.
There were some inconsistencies--
Side salads hubby's was twice the size and included iceberg,..."
Toni Vadala
"Sandy was a excellent server .the food was delicious. And plentiful. 36 yrs ago we had our first date here brought our sons here all the time till..."
Paula Schofield
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes