Pizza cuisine: the best places to taste it in New Milford
16 restaurant menus in New Milford, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"Excellent Service. Accommodated a party of 14 on short notice with a smile. Great pizza. Go with the thin pizza. Great pina..."
Eric Larkin
"Amazing pizza! Delivered quickly and crunchy crust..."
Mary Rivera
"Excellent food... everything was good except the spaghetti sauce.... way to watery... Pizza is always on point. Drinks are plentiful and the staff is..."
Ryan
"Food was excellent, had the chicken parmesan dinner with spaghetti. The chicken was delivered and perfectly cooked. The spaghetti was a little over..."
Jon Milochik
"Very nice people good service and I got the Square pizza with pepperoni and man is it good. Thanks again for the good..."
Chad Shade
"Overnight on way home ar New Milford Holiday Inn and found this gem, I've eaten a lot food over the years and the Spinach Calzone and garlic knots..."
"Best pizza around.. bacon ranch tomato and bbq Roman slices rock.. regular slices amazing.. and the wings......"
Aimee Schnuerle
"Love this place! Been coming here for years, food and service are..."
Aileen Mary
"One of my favorite Pizzeria's hands..."
Lisa Walsh
"We stopped by towards the end of the night (8ish) and had a few slices. The chicken bacon ranch and meatlovers were both good. The slices were huge...."
Ingrid Badilla
"Hands down the best customer service ever. Ordered catering and not only was it on time, but the owner actually came to set up himself and ensure..."
Rani Rani
"I like the fact they made everything at the premises. All the dishes were fresh. French fries was large, they really mean it it's a lot! I'm sure it..."
Rorpin Dong
"To quote my niece: "This pizza has changed my life."
Just moved to the area and Sopranos is our new go to pizza spot. Whole family agrees it is..."
Howard H
"Love the pizzas here . The square flat breads were so awesome too. Had the veggie one and it was so goooooooddddd ... quick service and a very good..."
Raj S
"Have been coming to this pizzeria for over 10+ years. They have good food and the pizza is pretty good I enjoy it. Is it the best pizza around..."
Cactus Jack
"They got the best Margherita Pizza, no joke. The pizza is fresh and the crust is amazing. They also have great mozzarella sticks and fried..."
"Upper Crust Cucina is one of our favorite Italian restaurants in the Litchfield Hills! All of their pasta and desserts (Tuscan Tiramisu!) are..."
Michelle Chaberek
"Always so welcoming and treated like family. The food is delish! And the weekly specials that change weekly are awesome. I love seeing the new ideas..."
mercedes reckless
"Great little spot. Food was delicious. Highly recommended. Great pizza and wonderful clean ingredients...."
Amanda Lein
"I love their food. I’ve eaten here probably about an average of once per every 1.5 weeks for the past four years or so. The service quality is..."
Christopher Ivey
"Very friendly people and the pizza is great! Definately try their flatbread as..."
Ankur Patel
"The food was creative and unique and pretty good. Can't..."
Tim
"Excellent food & service. Vegetable lasagna & goat cheese ravioli were delicious, side of roasted cauliflower equally..."
"Ate wings n pizza in many places for many years n this place is one of my favorites when I’m up in that area I make it a point to order out from..."
michael musso
"Great pizza! Reminds me of New Jersey pizza Ny style! Everything on the menu is very tasty! But their pizza is..."
emilia birtch
"Awesome pizza!! Taste like I'm out in NYC but without all the..."
Randy
"Best quality and taste compared to any other pizza restaurants in the entire area! And believe me, I have tried all of the other pizzas and subs from..."
Bear Guy
"We had the Chicken/Bacon/Ranch pizza and it was excellent! Also, the Chicken Parm Sandwich was solid. We’ll call them..."
Jeffrey Geiser
"Love their pizza! It's hard to find decent pizza in..."
Court Hummel
"This is one of the best places in town to grab a delicious anything. Pizza, cheese steaks, burgers. Everyone is so friendly and happy. The prices..."
Brian Mirra
"We went here to eat during a road trip. Didnt know exactly what we wanted, and this place seemed convenient. From the outside it looks like a boring..."
"Best pizza in New Milford. � We had the Sophia Loren pizza...the fresh mozzarella made it so delicious. I highly recommend..."
Kay Mac
"Best pizza around.. I'm from Brooklyn and I'm very picky about my..."
Thomas Dorr
"We loved the New York Pizza! Amazing! Reminded us of home....staff was very friendly and accommodating...the pulled pork pizza was..."
Ria Orofino-Militana
"Food is delicious and everyone was extremely friendly! Great service and staff! My 8 year old son even said "those guys are really nice Mom!" Thank..."
Tanya Ciatto
"So happy to see you guys open again!! Love the pizza! So delicious, and amazing..."
Kristina Freundt
"Awesome pizza for our area!!! Definitely on our return..."
Anthony Sartori
"Amazing food and friendly service. New York style..."
Rick Cas
"Great pizza! My favorite in the New Milford..."
Danielle Casagrande
"Great service, yummy food, reasonably priced. Win, win, win!!! We will be..."
Pamela Blaine
"I ordered delivery through Google and it was a fantastic experience. The delivery driver was very friendly and on time. The order was easy to do all..."
Sean Reilly
"Love the chicken Alfredo pasta and pizza. Really good, hot and customer service is great. Highly..."
Paola Gonzalez
"I have ordered delivery from here several times, it was always great. Unfortunately they told me on the phone twice so far that they couldn't..."
Cheyenne
"So Good!!!! Hands down the best sicilian pie with pepperoni we ever had! Chicken wings were amazing too; cooked exactly as we requested. The kid..."
Trish Formisano
"They made a mistake and dropped my order off at the wrong house, but the staff totally made it right. Not only did they fully refund me but they..."
Lydia
"We ordered here for the first time tonight and we are very pleased! The sauce on the pizza is excellent, the crispy chicken on my wrap was so good,..."
Steph
"Every time I order there, they have been amazing. They always get my orders correct, and their food tastes great. I love this place! Additionally, i..."
"Love the food from Roman's, never had a bad meal there, and we're there at least 3-4 times a month, either eating in the restaurant or take out! ..."
Jackie McMahon
"Romans has been a part of my life forever. The best Italian food in this general area. It is not worth spending ridiculous prices at find Italian..."
Linda Strozza Ganguzza
"Our family has been coming to Roman Pizza for 16 years. Every dish we have tried is delicious and we always experience great service as..."
Alfredo E. Granados
"The best food and most amazing childhood..."
Jimalee Patterson Lovely
"simply the best...................... the mussel sauce is the very best I have ever had in my..."
Jimmy Drake
"I love this place. I come here all the time for penne with broccoli, garlic and oil. Great atmosphere. Great staff. All around great Italian..."
Alex Teunisen
"Best value in NJ. This place has the best food and service. I've traveled the world and this is my favorite place since..."
Nick De Mauro
"I was visiting from Montreal, stopped in with my family. Absolutely the best pizza I have ever tasted..."
Mike Del Vecchio
"Great atmosphere friendly staff and some of the best Italian food out there. They make you feel more like family than a..."
Chris Doc Denton
"Great food and friendly service. The best..."
Rick Kramer
"Great food and service. Friendly staff and clean restaurant. I'm never..."
Annette Perez
"It's a nice Italian restaurant with good service.
If you come here go for the pizza which it extremely good! The pasta dishes were mediocre at best,..."
Coby Sternlicht
"03-19-2022 Today, on VERY short notice, I needed 15 plain pizza pies delivered to the New Milford high school for students that were practicing for..."
Diane L.
"My all time favorite getaway for good Italian food or catch up with a friend over a cup of hot cappuccino..."
Anwesha Dutta
"Great restaurant in a strip mall. Great food, reasonable prices. Help is friendly and courteous. Have never had a bad..."
Rus Rossini
"Been going for years.
Always our go to place when we dont feel like cooking.
Never been..."
Edward Greenwald
"Cozy family restaurant. Comfort Italian food. Really good. Big portions to share! Great..."
"Italia Mia is by far our favorite Italian restaurant! They're open until at least ten, for New Milford, that's a real plus! The Chicken Marsala and..."
Cheryl Showah
"I was at my sons Basketball game Masuk vs New Milford High School looking for a place to eat after the game and found this place on Google, just..."
Steven F. Torok
"My husband and I love Italia Mia! The best family atmosphere! Christina, Rolando and Lauren are the best bartender's around! Everyone is so friendly..."
Terry Jamie Carroll
"Italia Mia is the best! The food is always incredible and the staff is TOP notch!..."
Lauren Sciacca
"Food is always amazing and the portions are large. I’ve never had a bad meal and you can’t beat the 9.99 pasta..."
Sara Lucsky Gutierrez
"Since we moved to New Milford in 1969, Italia Mia has been our go-to restaurant especially for special family occasions. The food is consistently..."
Virginia Ballard Driscoll
"Great food, Big Bar and excellent staff, very nice place for..."
Christine Yacko
"Food is always so great. We get take out at least once a month and the service is so wonderful. They are so..."
Denise Reiss
"The cuisine was excellent, and so was the..."
Liam J. Enea
"Love this place. Been in New Milford forever. Real Italian food and..."
Marie McCarthy
"We love Italia Mia. Other Italian restaurants have come and gone, but it remains the best around. Wonderful pizza, great dinners and grinders, nice..."
Maria Economou
"Best restaurant in New Milford. Waitstaff excellent and friendly! Great happy..."
Sue Sciacca
"My favorite restaurant in town Have been coming here since they opened.my children, grand children, and great grandchildren have enjoyed many meals..."
"Frequent often, pizza � is superb, their menu is selective and everything I’ve had has been wonderful. Great ambience and service is spectacular..."
Maureen Covello
"Awesome place to go for excellent food, Very friendly staff, unlike some other places i have visited while in CT. 2 thumbs up..."
Duane Stearns
"Food was great!! Nice atmosphere. Waiter was rushed - always running and loud. Disappeared twice - we had to look for him twice. He needs to slow..."
Philip Carrone
"Had an awesome meal and was a great atmosphere. Our waiter was fantastic! And, he's a military Veteran! We will definitely..."
Mark Spencer
"The meal was absolutely delicious.... from the Sailor's mussels, to the Chicken Caprese..... Portions and price were fantastic. Thanks for a great..."
Laraine Lukacs Selivonchik
"Our dinner was very good and our waiter is always the best. Dennis is very..."
Jean McGuire Ferrara
"The menu is a bit limited if you are more inclined toward chicken or vegetarian meals, but everything I’ve had here has been good. The antipasto is..."
amanda
"We had dinner in the "sunroom" which is a small atrached greenhouse that overlooks a small pond. It was a little chilly but it was beautiful and the..."
Jessie Barr
"Did a take out for pizza. Ordered a small cheese and a small figgy figgy.. the cheese pizza was incredible. Had such great flavor!
The figgy fig,..."
Monica Cusano
"We always enjoy the pizza. Martini is good and strong. Prices aren't..."
"Having dinner at Tivoli Restaurant was a fantastic experience. The food was delicious and the service was really excellent. The waitress was always..."
Isabella Salazar
"The Romano Pizza we had was awesome, the pasta super delicious. Most of all I loved the service and I had such a great evening with friends in a very..."
Shere Nagarwalla
"I had the chicken bruschetta and my friend had the shrimp francaise. The service was excellent and the waitstaff was very attentive to our table. The..."
Sean Reilly
"Even though it was short staff the service was excellent and the food was delicious as well. My whole family enjoyed it and the vibes in the location..."
William Aquino
"Terrific restaurant in downtown New Milford with outdoor seating, Italian-American menu, great appetizers, Pizza, entrees, salads and, of course, ..."
Joe Sylvester
"Very nice atmosphere, Staff was very polite And quick, Salad had a nice balance and was so enjoyable that I almost had a second one,A1 on The..."
Joseph Caporale
"Cozy restaurant with delicious Italian food. Not terribly expensive. Only complaint is that even though the restaurant was completely empty, service..."
Zach Baecher
"The food is fantastic. I had a salad which was perfect with house dressing, Shrimp were so fresh over linguine that was out of this world. My husband..."
"Hands down the best pizza I have ever had. I am not a huge pizza person and my husband and I just cleared a large and small pizza just the two of us!..."
Candace Thompson
"Great food!!! Enjoyed the food great staff!! Delicious!! 5 star restaurant!! Enjoy come down to Colosseo!! Enjoy great Italian..."
Mayla Mansanet-Rivera
"went there today for a birthday lunch. great food and great service, my only disappointment was that the online menu and the inhouse menu were..."
Diane Hunihan Hulswit
"the food is fantastic!!!!!! Service was exceptional too...best italian food in..."
Pamela Way
"We have eaten here many times and order pizza from them often. The food is always fresh and delicious. We held a party at the restaurant this past..."
Audrey Palinkas Garrison
"It's a much better place now, it has ambiance and the food and service was excellent. definitely going back. Good wine..."
Karen Gellella
"I've always ordered take out from here but finally had dinner here in the dining room. Casino Pizza was awesome and service was..."
Robert James Braathe
"Stopped in tonight for dinner. Very nice dinner, food was very good along with great..."
Jay Swan
"Went for dinner last night. Food was outstanding from soup to dessert! Waitress was fabulous! Will definitely be going back! Great..."
Lynn Thompson White
"Great place for a nice dinner out or to just meet friends for for drinks! Prices are very reasonable especially for the quality of the..."
Rebecca Rebillard
"Enjoy! I know you will love the experience!!! Great food, attention to detail and a wonderful staff! TVB Roberto &..."
Patrizia Massaro
"Fantastic food and service!! Always like going "home" to..."
Janie Larson
"New menu/pizza is great!! Roberto went out of his way to make sure our order was taken care of!! Will definitely be visiting more..."
Kristen Bradle
"Great dinner! New look, great food and excellent..."
"I went there today with 3 friends. Everything we ordered was delicious. The grinders are huge and they have a lunch menu with reasonable prices. Also..."
Marie Douglas
"Very Best Pizza anywhere around New Milford or any towns near!!! Go there every..."
Diana Bates
"We did dinner for two. Food was good and the price was great. Can't ask for..."
Alan Lounsbury
"Menu is full. Much more than pizza. Good experience inside during covid times. Clean dining and good service. I'm rating it 4 stars due to what I..."
"We've been "regulars" ever since we moved to the area 10 years ago and love the place! Whether it's a signature pasta or meat dish, or a hamburger,..."
Alicia Sakal
"I miss a good Pizza Miss the owners too great place to have good..."
Gigi Vlamis
"I love the Holiday Restaurant........Have enjoyed many times going there.....Hope for many..."
Judy Swanberg
"Always been, always will be my #1 choice. Best calzones I've ever..."
Chantel Nicole
"Best food ever and speedy delivery thank you for delivering every friday night. Never had an issue with..."
Kyle Sheaffer
"Love the Chicken Danielle. Lots of cheese on the Baked Ravioli..."
Loriann Ickrath Chiarito
"It's great have been going there over 15..."
Joann Holbrook
"We have been eating at holiday restaurant for a few months now and every time it is a perfect experience. Their supreme pizza is amazing. Seriously,..."
TG SS
"We were vacationing on Candlewood Lake and were looking to go out for Italian food. There were 9 of us so we were worried about having to wait to be..."
Jennifer Welles
"Solid thick crust pizza. Just the right amount of topping unlike some other pizza places in the area. Ingredients taste good. They deliver. ..."
Colby Turner
"This is a nice little restaurant, I haven't had the pizza but the seated dining is great. The food comes quickly and they use lots of fresh..."
Ashley Van Tassel
"Had a lasagna from there. It was delicious. 1 meal serves 2 for sure!
The place isn't the clean kind. We never know what's going behind walls in..."
Marianna Camisão de Oliveira
"We had a Christmas geocaching event here in mid-December, which is how I know about the restaurant. I thought the food and service were good. We went..."
Morton Fox
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes