Best Key Lime Pie in New Shoreham

There is only one restaurant
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Winfield's Restaurant
Winfield's Restaurant
90/100 (841 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Seafood
Vegan Options
American
Seafood
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Scallops
Duck Confit
Catfish
Duck
Filet Mignon
Cakes
Mussels
Bread Pudding
Lamb
Tuna
Lamb
Fish
Salmon
Key Lime Pie
Pork
Lobster Mac & Cheese
caesar salad
Pan-Seared Salmon
Beer
Shrimp
Crispy Skin Salmon with Risotto Nero Creme Fraiche and Black Tobiko
Filet Mignon
Beef
Grilled Atlantic Swordfish
Cod
Chatham MA Mussels
Swordfish
Tuna Entree
Lamb chops
Lobster
Tuna Tartare Appetizer
Pasta
Swordfish Entree
Salad
Catfish Etouffee
cod fish
Polenta
Mac and cheese
Crispy Skin Salmon Entree
Blondie
Duck Confit
Crab
Seared Scallops
Crawfish
Sit down
American
Seafood
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Reservations
Seating
Dinner
Fine Dining
"Significantly better food than most other restaurants in the area. It’s nice, but not “fancy” or pretentious. Worth a visit if you’re tired..."
Colin Valentini
"Excellent dinner that featured some of the best fish we have ever had. The flavor was incredible with a fine balance of complementing the fish but..."
Bryan Everitt
"Great service and food was delicious. Loved the steak and..."
Matthew LeBlanc
"Listen I’m honest.... I’ve never thought twice about lobster Mac and cheese.... always overrated until tonight. It turns out every place else..."
Jonathan Klomp
"Review 2022: see review below - this place is certainly a must while you visit BI and in the top 3 restaurants on the island as of 2022. From what I..."
Brian F
"Came into Winfield’s on 7/31 for dinner at the bar. Martinis were on point and service was prompt and professional. But oh my goodness the food!..."
G Rendek
"Out of staters from the New York Metro area visiting the Island for 3 days and Winfields was hands down the best. We had 4 meals between the 2 of us..."
Doug Padla
"A solid experience on an island full of over priced restaurants. Delicious drinks & food and the outside patio is great to start off the evening with..."
C Lee
"The roasted garlic cloves with the bread were the best thing I've had in a long time. The food was also amazing. 5 stars is simply not enough for..."
Jack B
"Excellent food. Professional but homey service. Spaces that allow either a quiet intimate night out and a highly social experience of the Island..."
Robert Benjamin
"It has been almost 4 years, but we cannot stop thinking about the Winfield salad. It was so good that we ordered a second one. So good that we talk..."
A W
"Nice, cozy atmosphere. Wait staff professional, pleasant, accommodating and customer focused. Very helpful with suggestions and recommendations. Food..."
Channon C
"The service was great and the food was delicious. I started with the ceviche, which was top notch and very fresh. Then I tried some of the gazpacho..."
Jyl Warn
"Amazing dishes so flavorful and..."
Elisabeth Buchwald
"More like 4 1/2, but still excellent. Interesting menu, descent wine list, nice atmosphere. Superior wait staff. Wonderfully prepared food, quality..."
Wayne Morra
"This place is one of the best restaurants on Block Island! It is pricey but it's worth every penny. Mouth watering filet and the potatoes are amazing..."
mm k
"Great food, favorite place I went to on the island. The waiter was amazingly nice, she accidentally put in swordfish instead of the pork chop, and..."
Marc