Super cozy
Italian restaurant.
It was good food, many kinds of pizzas. The pizzas were baked in a real pizza oven. The pizza crust was on the thin side.
Definitely recommended.
What a taste of Italy. The pizza is athletic and the Italian Beer selection is amazing. They serve it correctly. I will definitely be back. Give it a try. They have inside and outside seating.
This is literally the best pizza place ever. Everything is amazing. Would recommend going here 100%. The pizza is a must-try.
Best pizza in NY! The marguerita is very tasty and the pizza alla Nutella is the perfect dessert. Besides that the place is cozy and as informal as it should be.
Was great was here with a reunion of my old friends and the pizza and wine were outstanding. One of the best pizzas in New York and that says something.
Has a variety of delicious and interesting pizza… Especially the white cream pumpkin and also has excellent basics like margaritas. Loved the Italian desserts. Wine selection was superb.
Excellent food, very diligent and friendly staff.
The wood oven baked pizzas are fantastic.
The place is cozy,
Very reasonable prices too
We went there for our son birthday. He is the one who picks this place. He loves all the pizzas, tiramisu, chocolate tratufo. Desserts itself are great. Don't forget their cappucino is excellent.
Sottocasa is one of the best pizza places in all of NY. If you’re worried that a trip to Harlem is “too far” you should reconsider. It doesn’t matter what pizza you order, you will enjoy it. Everything is delicious! The staff are friendly, the vibe is lovely, and the food is delicious! They have an extensive craft beer list and the beer bottle come out in a bucket of ice. Overall it’s an incredible place and needs to be highlighted because it’s too good not to share with others! Will be back 100%
This is the best TRULY ITALIAN pizza in NYC. It is no different than if you ate it in Napoli. I have had it in Napoli and had it here & it is the exact same.
It’s also undeniably the best gluten free pizza in NYC. What a gem!
The staff are warm, welcoming & attentive. The vibe of the restaurant is perfect. The wine is great. We are so lucky this is in our neighborhood!
And a great back room for small private parties.
I am dairy free too & waiting for the day they offer a dairy free mozzarella! ;)
A hidden gem you can easily kiss walking by. A great traditional brick oven pizza place with a cozy welcoming atmosphere and great pizza.
Great authentic, brick oven, Italian pizza. The pizza is delicious, they use natural ingredients. The restaurant is comfortable, not too loud and very clean. The pizza was ready in no time. Best pizza place in Harlem
Loved this place! Came on a Saturday night and shared the romana pizza. Please do drizzle the olive oil! Staff was kind and friendly! Even remembered my partner and I the next day when we came in to get a margarita pie to go! Would definitely recommend eating here.
Amazing pizza location in harlem that serves a variety of very well done pizzas. Great portion sizes, perfectly baked crust, and fresh toppings. Another surprise were the great selection if desserts. Service was very friendly and professional. Would highly recommend
Pro: Authentic Italian pizza (a little soggy in the center) but i love it, crust filled with airpockets and thin. They use reL mozzarella and fresh products
Con: They only sell by pie no slices.
They serve wine, cocktails and sangria but no open bar
I recommend others to try you might fail in love
I mean. FINALLY. A real pizza. Feels like a good pizza home in Italy!
Well done guys, keep the quality and the smiles please!!
I both dined in and did take away.
Take away was super quick!
I’ll keep coming to Harlem for a good pizza then 😊
Really good pizza here. We ate it so fast we didnt take any pictures. Impressive tiramisu! Courteous service. We will definitely come back again!
![5]( "Recensione")
I rarely review restaurants, as I’m rarely impressed by the food I eat in restaurants. Sottocasa deserves to be known by all foodies out there, so I really hope after reading this you settle on Sottocasa.
All my friends (even the difficult ones) and I were all pleasantly impressed by the wood fired pizza. I personally had the Reginella pizza with a Rughetta salad, and I melted down after every single bite. From the dough to the mozzarella, every single ingredient exploded with flavor. There is no doubt the chefs uses the best ingredients they can find in New York! My feelings while eating are just indescribable! The last time I felt this while eating a pizza, I was visiting my family in Napoli.
This is a must-try little gem! The atmosphere feels warm and cozy from the moment you walk down the stairs. The staff is welcoming and very friendly. They also have an impressive selection of imported Italian beers. The Nazionale was delicious!
Please go; you won’t regret the trip to South Harlem!
Best Naples style pizza you can have in the city! Reminds me of the award-winning pizza I had in Italy. The dough is perfectly fluffy and crispy at the same time. But when the pizza comes out of the oven, have it immediately, every second it cools down, the tip of each slice gets a bit more soggy from the delicious sauce of the toppings. The Laura is our new favorite! But everything we have tried is divine.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes