This was our 2nd pizza place in NYC, and it was good! Tomato mozzarella was great, very thin crispy, crunch, well-toasted crust, fresh tomato, and great texture of strings of mozzarella cheese. However, the one with pepperoni was a bit soggy and less crispy. Nice place to grab a quick meal.
We stopped in on a wet cold night and the pizza turned everything around - great selection and even better taste - nice option to try a few. We had the cheese and BBQ chicken - both were amazing. The only issue is the cleanliness of the washroom, but the pizza itself was outstanding!
I would highly recommend the grandma pizza! The crust was delicious, crunchy crust while still being soft. The flavor of the sauce is awesome! The place is small, busy and a little chaotic. Prices are very good $3-5/slice and 2 slices is more than enough.
Place was packed and run like a well oiled machine. They took orders and got everyone in and out.
Got the grandma style square and regular spinach and mushroom. Both were cooked perfectly and had great taste. Definitely stop by.
We recently went to Bleeker Street on our trip to NYC, our favourite was Nonna Maria - amazing flavour , cheesy and the best marinara sauce ! Loved the crust of the pizza and I asked one of the guys making the pizzas that what do they put at the bottom- he mentioned it’s some of breadcrumb- which makes it super crunchy! Had heard a lot about this place and it lived upto our expectations! We are glad we went! The pepperoni slice was really good too! On our second visit we tried the BBQ one as well but we preferred the nonna Maria (that was more like the traditional one with amazing sauce on top) , also their garlic knots/dough ball was heavenly! They are constantly baking fresh batches of pizzas and we’d seen a lot of deliveries going out as well! We didn’t get any queues ! Must try when in NYC..this was our favourite spot out of all pizza places we tried !
Bleecker street pizza is a great stop for slices. They have really good thin pizza. It's cheesier than in some other places I've tried, and the flavor itself is really good. The crust was crispy in the right places, and we really enjoyed it. I've also had their white slice before, and it was really good as well. I recommend coming here to try out the regular cheese.
I have never in my whole life had a better pizza than this one. We ordered the Nona whole pie pizza. Even the border was crunchy. I have no words that can describe how good this was. Simply delicious.
Hugely disappointed that the crust was so burnt on the just cheese and didn't bother to eat. But the second slice was extremely good. Loved the pizza, thought it was great, but the second slice made me question consistency.
As an outsider, would recommend trying, and worth a few blocks of walking to get.
Best slice pizza in town!
No wait, quick, and delicious!
Want a quick bite in the village? This is the place and would be one of the best slices you ever had!
We went for late night pizza here on a weekend, and the atmosphere is lit. Loud music. The servers have a lot of fun dancing and singing with the guests. The serve your slice hot with a big display glass of all the pies. Decent pizza if you’re tipsy. I got a meat lovers with pepperoni and sausage.
After being told that we had to have pizza when we visited New York, we asked around. Bleeker Street seemed to have a couple of top rated establishments. We picked Bleecker Street Pizza. I ordered a slice of Hawaiian, and my wife ordered a Veggie slice. They dropped them into the pizza oven and handed them out to us a few minutes later. Delicious! I would highly recommend this location.
Loved it… cheesy, not too sauce, very flavorful. Also right amount of crispiness. I thought it was a lot better than Joes Pizza.
I bought the cheese pizza and their chicken, bacon ranch pizza…
This place will definitely be my after dancing go to spot.
Their nonna Maria is such a unique tasting pizza with lots of herbs and fresh mozzarella cheese. Definitely one of the best pizzas I've gotten to try in NYC. 100% would recommend getting a slice here and will be back someday to try some of their other slices.
I LOVE THIS PLACE!!
Not a big fan of pizza but Bleecker Street Pizza makes some gooooooood pizza.
Also, dont forget to take home some garlic knots. If they get cold, pop em in the oven and itll taste even better.
The founder and previous owner, Greg, comes in on Fridays. He’ll surely make your Bleecker st pizza experience worth while.
Really good pizza! Absolutely recommend the Nonna Maria. The service was a bit questionable and seemed grumpy despite it not being too busy the time we went. Cashier got impatient with the second it took for Face ID to work on my phone to pay and heard him get grumpy at others taking longer than mere seconds to order with no queue. Despite this I do recommend visiting as the pizza is really good.
Ordered 2 slices of nonna maria which were quite good! Our slices weren’t the freshest as they were reheated but we still quite enjoyed them. We regret not trying a classic cheese slice as that would’ve really shown the quality of the Bleecker Street Pizza. This place was absolutely packed on this Saturday night, as it seems like a go-to place for locals. The dining area felt more like a college cafeteria but that’s the experience of a classic new york pizza shop on a bustling night during the weekend. All in all very grateful for the convenience of this delicious slice.
![4]( "Recensione")
If you're craving for a slice of delicious pizza, Bleecker Street should be on the top of your list. This pizza joint has created quite a buzz among pizza enthusiasts, so when I went there, I was curious to see if it lived up to the hype. I can happily say that Bleecker Street's pizza exceeds expectations.
The crust was perfectly cooked, crispy on the outside, and soft on the inside, with just the right amount of doughiness. The sauce was well-balanced with the toppings and the cheese, which were generously spread on top. The thinly sliced pepperoni added a flavorful kick without overpowering other ingredients that can sometimes be the case. The best part was the overall texture of the pizza
Furthermore, I appreciate the excellent customer service level provided by Bleecker Street pizza-makers. They were friendly, welcoming, and took the time to explain the menu in detail. The ambiance of the place was great, and I felt relaxed from the moment I stepped in.
In conclusion, Bleecker Street pizza is an authentic New York-style pizza that will satisfy your cravings for a perfect pizza experience. With high-quality ingredients, exceptional customer service, and flavorful toppings, it's hard to resist the temptation of a slice of Bleecker Street pizza. I highly recommend it and will undoubtedly visit again.
Hands down the best slice I’ve had in NYC. Their Nonna Maria slice was perfect, the sweet tomato chunks in the sauce, the ratio of cheese to sauce and the crust were spot on. The comfort when you take that first bite is out of this world, it’s the whole package. I tried their veggie slice as well which was the best I’ve had, the veggies were cooked to perfection and had a lovely smoky flavor. The cheese slice was good but wasn’t my favorite of the lot. The service was fast and the staff were friendly - even threw in an extra slice when I went in for the second time in the same day!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes