Reviews Gallaghers Steakhouse

We ordered special lunch courses - upgraded to fillet mignon and lamb chop. The lamb chop was tender, and the mint sauce was great. Fillet Mignon was great as well. Their signature sauce was a bit weird to me the first time (tasted like tomato soup), but it was somewhat addictive! Oh, their appetizers were great as well. The Caesar salad was seasoned perfectly, and the soup was delicious. The key lime pie was also refreshing (liked it better than the NY cheesecake). Considering the price, portion, and taste, I recommend this place! I would visit again if I com back to Manhattan.

My wife and I ate there today to celebrate her birthday. It was just brilliant. The welcome, the atmosphere, the food were so good. Attentive staff made sure we were looked after but without being too in your face or rushed. The beef was cooked to perfection.

Our visit to Gallagher's Steak House yesterday during the Christmas season was nothing short of extraordinary. My wife and I were treated to an amazing culinary experience that exceeded our expectations. The festive ambiance added a special touch to the evening, creating a warm and celebratory atmosphere. The true star of the night was undoubtedly the steak – a culinary masterpiece that showcased the restaurant's commitment to quality. Cooked to perfection and bursting with flavor, it was a delight for the taste buds. The attentive and friendly staff contributed to the overall positive impression, ensuring our dining experience was memorable. Gallagher's Steak House has proven itself as a top-notch establishment, delivering not only exceptional food but also a welcoming environment perfect for festive occasions. We left with satisfied palates and hearts full of holiday cheer, making it a dining experience we won't soon forget. Highly recommended for those seeking a memorable steakhouse experience, especially during the festive season.

Our dining experience here was absolutely wonderful!!! We were in town to see the Eagles concert at MSG and decided to try a different steakhouse instead of our usual. We weren’t disappointed trying somewhere new. HIGHLY recommend making reservations or you’ll be out of luck trying to get in. The Host was professional and courteous. Seated us accordingly to our reservation. Walking through was an experience of all the wonderful memories this restaurant had. Beautifully decorated with pictures of the past and richly colored with old world charm. The bar room was centered well to accommodate more guests. Our dining table was towards the back where we had a nice view of the open concept kitchen. The booth was very comfortable. Seating seemed to be a bit crowded during peak dinner hours. We had a lot of room at 4:30pm when we arrived. At 5pm is when more guests started arriving and we had guests fill up all along the wrapped booth. It was enough to eat comfortably but to close to get out from the booth comfortably with disturbing the table. Staff was also absolutely wonderful and knowledgeable of their menu. Menu had quite a bit of deliciousness to chose from. Prices were very reasonable for this upscale steakhouse. Drink menu had a great selection of wine, champagne, cocktails and beers. Also reasonable prices. Service was on par for timing of drinks, appetizers to entrees. Did not order dessert since we’re not dessert people. Since the restaurant became busier, our waiter was a bit slower to getting our check. We were on a tight schedule to get to the concert so we had to flag our waiter to move things along. It’s understandable not a big deal. Ambiance was so relaxing and quiet soothing despite the hustle of a busy kitchen. Overall, we had such an exquisite meal and wonderful conversations about this place. Love it!!! Thank you Gallaghers.

This is probably the best steak I have ever eaten, it was a beautiful piece of steak and cooked perfectly. The lunch special was extremely good value. Carmine was an excellent server, so friendly, polite and helpful. If I am ever back in Manhattan, this will be top of my list.

The best steakhouse I've ever been! Top quality of food, great selection of cocktail and spirits. We have been served at the bar by the barman, very kind and careful to every single detail, excellent service!

I went for the lunch special+ $18 upgrade for the filet mignon. Asked for a medium tree but they gave me rare. But the steak was delicious. The crust was wonderfully seasoned and was super tender. The tomato steak sauce was a great compliment to the steak with a bit of acidity that helped make the steak go down easier. The bread was probably the worst part of the meal. Soup and dessert was good but nothing spectacular. I would say for $50 that I spend. It was the best filet mignon meal I had.

Absolutely loved every single thing about this place and the meal. Hands down the best french onion soup and french fries and the steak (filet mignon) was incredible. They had a 4 cheese mac and cheese on as a special which was perfection. Excellent service with an old school charm that you can't find anywhere else. They make the meanest Manhattan ever. I wouldn't change a thing and can't wait to come back!

This restaurant was recommended to me as a must visit when in New York. Followed the advice and was not disappointed. The whole vibe of the place is what a good eatery should be like. It has that decent old school feeling about it. Waiters are professionals and know how to offer impeccable service to the customer. Steaks were phenomenal and so well prepared. You cannot say its an expensive restaurant because what you receive reflects what you pay.

Absolutely incredible experience at Gallaghers! We had the Porterhouse for 2 which was 100% the best steak I've ever eaten. The crust and flavor are impeccable and I've never had anything even close. Paired with the delicious Caesar salad & beef tartare. Truly a wonderful meal and excellent service all around!