For pre -Wicked or theatre bites, McHale’s service and quality is always top notch. The caesar salad is amazing and service is always with a smile. Fresh beers on tap and great selection.
Great for a young family
Casual pub atmosphere that was perfect for our family with young kids. We went at 7 on a Wednesday night and it was pretty empty so there was no wait. I highly recommend the Shepard’s Pie
We stopped in for a drink and appetizer. Great place to watch a sporting event. The bartender had all the baseball games going. Nice beer selection. We had the deep fried chicken dumplings. Very good. The bartender was very attentive. We really enjoyed ourselves.
Just popped in for a beer and ended up staying hours (because of s great bartender 😉) and getting some bar food. Great wings and slab bacon - sinfully good.
This is my favourite Irish bar in NYC.. from the location to the interior - everything is perfect. The service is flawless and the management team should be very proud. The prices are very reasonable and one of my favourites on the menu are the chicken fingers! McHales' staff are very welcoming and attentive. It's ideally located near Broadway and it's definitely worth a visit!
Great Irish pub/bar. Has an upstairs where we sat. Had windows overlooking the street below. A little warm up there but great seats otherwise. I had the French onion soup to start and wow! Look at picture and you will know. I had the Shepards pie which had great flavor and .meat was so tender. I could have ate 2 dishes of it. My friend had the reuben and shared with me. Was best i have had. Illinois has nothing like the quality of this. Great place!
Came after a show at Westside theater. Apparently the Irish curry was their best seller. A little spicy, loads of chicken. I went to school in Ireland and I didn’t remember this in pubs… 😂 loved the environment. Served by Rachel. Come and enjoy a late evening out. Like the fact that most indoor pubs are not smoky like Irish pubs 2 years ago. 😝 had a Bud light. I like my wimpy beer. God bless the USA.
Great location for a pre-theatre bite and for sports fans. TVs well placed throughout the restaurant to watch all your favorite games. Love the wood paneling and Christmas decorations during the holiday season, which adds to the cozy feel.
My fish and chips were just average: batter on the fish was very thick and the whole dish came out cold (I suspect it was waiting on the pass while the other dishes for my party were still cooking). However, the friendly service more than made up for the food.
Beautiful place with very kind staffs, especially Mary, she managed all the tables with a full restaurant all by herself and maintained patience and kindness. Would definitely return because Mahale so accommodating and the food was good.
Came in to watch a UFC PPV fight on Saturday night. The food was pretty good, with lots of big screens for the fights with no cover charge. Good mix of tourists and locals, and they’ll have a cute decorations during the holidays. Great place to watch sports while having good food and drinks!
We had beers with our nachos and appetizer sampler. Other than the chicken tenders (not too tender, sadly), the food was good. The beers had a great pour, which is saying a lot because one of them was Guinness. From the moment we entered to the time we left, the customer service was fantastic. They were very busy, as it was cutting close to showtime at the theaters, and everything went smoothly. It’s a great spot if you’re in the area.
I highly recommend this restaurant. The staff was friendly, the atmosphere was good, and the food was great. Whenever I get the opportunity to eat at an Irish pub I take it. McHale's is one of the best I've experienced. I had the shepherd's pie and it was delicious.
Host was awesome, had a bigger group and we got accommodated on our requests. Ordered a Coney Island IPA. Shared nachos and chicken wings, nachos don’t look that appealing but it was pretty good.
Gorgeous place with AMAZING food! Service was slightly slow, but it was understandable since they had just opened. The spicy crispy sandwich was decent, wouldn't recommend it unless you add a sauce to the side or just want something crispy and tender since it barely has spice to it. Fries were generously given, let me tell you they're DELISH!!! Everyone was so sweet, music is very fun to jam to, several TVs as well so we can view a game if we're bored. Had a brownie for dessert, so great on a rainy day like this because it was warm and gooey and adorable how they presented it on the plate. WILL DEFINITELY RETURN!
McHale's was great this evening! We stopped by with a family of 8 after watching Phantom of the Opera. Killer fish and chips, fries and currie, and the Buffalo Chicken Mac, it all hit the spot. Had some beers and drinks while we were there.
Go check them out, tell them Eric Berry your Georgia Realtor sent you.
Nice little bar conveniently located across the street from the Gershwin theater. My daughter and I were seated quickly. A good blend of music playing as well as the Yankee game and the Master's tournament. The server was an absolute gem. He was attentive, knowledgeable and friendly. The drinks were refreshing and the food was okay. The mozzarella were fine but the sauce was a bit off. We discovered a small piece of chicken in the sauce. We weren't sure if that was part of the sauce or an oversight by the kitchen. Anyway, I'd recommend this place if you're in the area waiting for a show.
Great pub to watch soccer and have a pint or two with food. Reasonably priced given it's prime location. We went there several times during our visit to NYC. I like the friendliness of the staff.
This place is absolutely AMAZING! We visited this place for the first time last week while visiting NYC. We ended up going there 3 nights in a row because of how great the atmosphere and service was. Neal and Chris- The bartenders were OUTSTANDING! Super personable, funny, and nice. We tried their Nachos and fish and chips both really good. However, the fish and chips were AMAZING! Can’t say enough good things about this place, will definitely be back when we go to NYC again. Check it out, you won’t regret it!!!!
Only had a perfect Guinness, but Bethany and her team were so very inviting and whole bar is over-the-top beautiful (especially with Christmas decorations everywhere)!
Friendly local customers and staff. Great stew. Great atmosphere.
From the two Canadian girls.
Irish pub in close proximity to Broadway district/Times Square. Wide variety of food including standards like salads, burgers and sandwiches but also occasional specials such as pork dumplings with sweet chili sauce. Very clean establishment. Well decorated for the Holiday season. TVs all over for sports fans to enjoy. Friendly, hardworking staff. Huge selection of Irish Whiskey and they keep the stiff drinks flowing. Slainte!
Great wings. Great staff. The bartender upstairs will make ya laugh. Definitely a good spot to watch sports. 10/10
Great little Irish pub. With extremely cold beer. The coconut Majito was definitely delicious. The second floor dining has a nice view of the street .
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes