Reviews Carroll Place

We went to this place for a friend's birthday dinner . Upon walking in, the place was really cute! The service started off, shaky. We had a party of 18 and the tables that they gave us was just not picking up to suit our party. We asked to be moved to a different area, but they said they had a bigger party. However, they ended up moving us to that place, which was interesting because I thought they said they had a party. It ended up that they did have a party. We just got there first. I'm glad they moved us because it was definitely more comfortable. The bottom is option was all or nothing but that's pretty typical for a restaurant in the city. We got the some appetizers: - Caesar salad was made out of spinach. Spinach leave the weird taste in my mouth which has nothing to do with the restaurant. The salad was good. -The Meatballs were so good. Not dry and very flavorful. -The Fries were incredible. They had a hint of truffle flavor. They also had a nice bite to them. - The brussels sprouts were cooked well. I wish they were more saucy. - The pizza was floppy but decent. I'm overall not a huge pizza fan but I liked the thinness of the crust. - The penne alla vodka lacked a decent amount of sauce for me. I needed more of that creamy tomato sauce. - The chicken was kind of dry but okay. After like 10pm, the place turned into a club vibe. The music was bumping and it was a nice mix between current and oldies songs. I would recommend!

I must say this place is very beautiful, I bought a groupon for 2 which was a 3 course meal and wow it was amazing the food here is sooooo good and they give you a lot of food omg i really enjoyed the drinks everything i would definitely come again the manager Alex was soo friendly and nice to us live coming to places that make me feel welcomed can’t wait to go back ❣️❣️🥰😁😁😁😁😁

We are are at restaurant right now. The place is beautiful. We are waiting for our meals. Plates look awesome. The lady who welcomes us was awesome. I know we are tourists, but we need a smile from our server, please. Pizzas are just woaw... Fantastic

Amazing! Amazing! Amazing! This was such a charming dinner experience, aside from the Uber soft and warming interior, the staff provided the most unbelievably welcoming service. The entire place was full of smiles and laughter from happy diners. I had an unforgettable dinner with some friends where we opted for Carroll Place's new family style dinner menu which offers an array of appetizers and entrees to choose from, and dessert plus a bottomless beverage add-on. We got to select 4 appetizers and 3 entrees, and all decided to sip on endless rose. Our starter choices were Arancini, Calamari, Rosemary Wings and a Cheese and Meat Charcuterie board served with honey and soft bread. Our shared entrees were Margherita Pizza, Hanger Steak and Penne a la Vodka alongside Truffle Fries and Broccolini as sides! The huge sweeping meal then wrapped up with a Nutella Calzone Pizza, would definitely recommend for an intimate group celebrating something special or just looking to have a great time over a delicious feast. Thank you Carroll Place!

Great place for happy hour apps and drinks for a group. There was also a fun band playing in the back after happy hour. I’ll be back.

I've been to Carroll Place for brunch on the weekends and happy hour during the week and have always had a great experience! This is one of the better brunch deals in Manhattan- $30 for an hour and a half of unlimited brunch drinks and an entrée. They have a great selection of entrées too! They also have some great deals if you decide to stop by for happy hour which is Wednesday - Friday. I'm a huge fan of the rosemary chicken wings and the Arancini (risotto balls). Carroll Place is fairly large with a small upstairs section, but it still gets crowded so I would recommend making a reservation.

Came here for the brunch / happy hour. Was a fantastic price considering the price of the rest of the menu. Mondy our server was top tier, very friendly and helpful! Our drinks were tasty and the food was also good, thoroughly enjoyable

i usually dont say this about any restaurant in a review, but its CRIMINAL that this place doesn't have a unanimous 5 star review. Everything from the minimalist but swanky spreak-easy decor to the most amazing homemade Italian I have ever had in NYC, this place is just an absolute gem of a find. Will def be back to try their other dishes - and cocktails - which were also ON POINT !! Thank you Carroll Place !!!