Reviews La Pizza

As a tourist who has been to both the Flatiron and Downtown locations, this Flatiron location falls a bit short compared to Downtown, but on its own is a great place for a pasta and pizza lunch, well with a trip. This location is at street level, and a bit more casual (in comparison to downtown) though the decor was very clean and elegant. Our service was good, if a bit blunt, and our server checked on us several times. My lasagna was very rich with many sheets of fresh lasagna. I liked it, and my daughter loved it. My kids were not presented with a kids menu, but there was a kids cheese pizza available upon request, which was enjoyed. My eldest daughter loved her four cheese pizza (and ordered it at the other location this same trip). I appreciated there being a few craft beers on tap. I didn't love the fresh bread we ordered. It was only $3, and served with olive oil - it was soft with 4 big pieces, but a nibble of my daughters' pizza crust was more appealing, so I'll skip it next time. We closed out our lunch sharing an amazing tiramisu - so creamy and delicious!

I brought a friend here from out of town, and we visited on a Sunday at about 230 pm. There were no lines to get a table, and we were seated right next to a window overlooking the Memorial Pools. Absolutely breathtaking views! A great first impression. Right after we sat at the table, we were greeted by a gentleman offering us water. (Love that!) After reviewing the menu for a few minutes, Jordan came over to take our order. He was dressed in a suit, which we found interesting. (There's a definite pecking order within the staff.) He was very outgoing and friendly and answered my friend's menu questions with ease. I ordered the spaghetti cacio e pepi with a truffle addition and my friend ordered the tagliatelle alla bolognese. I asked if I could change my pasta to angel hair, but that was not allowed. We didn't order appetizers. Several minutes later, Jordan informed me that the kitchen had run out of truffles, which was a bummer. The entrees came pretty quickly, but not too quickly, and were served by Diego another person who is great at his job. Both were very generous portions, and neither of us was able to finish, though we really tried! We were offered freshly grated cheese shortly after we began eating. We shared our pasta, and both were cooked to perfection (al dente) and tasted fantastic. The staff was very attentive, but not annoyingly so. We didn't feel rushed, which is a treat in NYC. We didn't order dessert, though the gelato looked amazing. Here's why I gave 4 instead of 5 stars. After we paid, we both went to the restroom. It was so shabbily done, almost as an afterthought. There was a line, and we waited in a very narrow but heavily trafficked hallway that had mops and a locker jammed into it. When we got to the bathrooms, we found a very poorly designed space with angles that made it almost impossible to avoid coming into contact with other patrons. There were social distancing signs which were pretty comical, considering the lack of space. They also only offer hand dryers, so I can only imagine how warm the bathrooms get in the summer. Upon leaving the restrooms, we meandered through the market, which was well-stocked and beautifully arranged. We made a few purchases and headed to the exit. At least we thought we did. It took us 10 minutes of walking around in a complete circle as we followed the exit signs. We finally asked someone to show us the actual exit, an escalator down that proved very elusive. It was an unfortunate end to an otherwise wonderful experience. I hope they redesign those restrooms and provide better exit signage in the future. The photos are of the dining space, our view, and the hallway to the restroom.

Pretty good Italian food for reasonable price, especially with the Eataly restaurant feast that ended yesterday - but I believe it will be back soon. The service is a little slow. Highly recommend you book a reservation since the line can get pretty long. It is located in the Eataly market so great place to browse for Italian produce after your meal.

My favorite spot in NYC for pasta! Service is great, food is amazing!! The wine is very pricey, but delicious. Both the Flatiron location and the 9/11 location are excellent. I've been to both several times, highly recommend!

We walked in for a quick lunch while out shopping. Pretty solid overall. I had the lasagna and my partner had the squid ink gnocchi. The lasagna was moist and flavorful and I enjoyed it paired with my foccia bread. I'd ask for extra sauce next time if I had to make it perfect. My partners gnocchi was good, but a tad basic and bland. Could of used a bit more pizazz... Maybe some chili or red pepper? Maybe more citrus to brighten it. Overall not bad though. One complaint is that a fly flew into my wine. Food service was exceptionally fast. Would come again for a quick pasta fix.

We came here for pasta and had a great experience. Our server Caroline was absolutely amazing. We loved her! I got their $28 deal which came with Bruschetta (AMAZING!) and pasta. The overall experience was just so good. I’d come back here in a heartbeat when I come back to NYC. Thanks Caroline!

Got the lasagna and Aperol spritz - they were both pretty decent. A bit overpriced, but that’s to be expected in Eataly.