Celebration candle, will stay lit anywhere from 10-40 seconds (depending on your karmic connection) These candles don't smoke during lighting, they are considered LOW smoke upon diffusing of flame. Suitable for indoor use ONLY.
3.99 $
Number glitter candles (0 - 9)
Choose your COLOR and NUMBER
1.99 $
H-A-P-P-Y B-I-R-T-H-D-A-Y Candles
13 individual letter candles (INCLUDES the insert/pick)
2.99 $
Congratulations Candle
Spells out congratulations.
3.25 $
Beer Candle
Beer shaped candle
3.25 $
Champagne Candles
Champagne shaped candles
3.25 $
Pack of 24 candles traditional
Traditional pack of yellow, pink, white, blue spiral
2.99 $
TALL Rainbow Wavy Candle
Tall candles rainbow color
3.25 $
Gold Metallic Celebration
Metallic gold shiny 10 pack
3.25 $
Princess Castle, Unicorn, Heart Candles
3.25 $
Trick candles (re-lights)
2.99 $
Gluten Free (Friendly) Cupcakes and Bars
Gluten free Carrot Cupcakes
Our famous carrot cupcake iced with a spiced cream cheese frosting. (Includes walnuts)
4.25 $
Gluten Free Red Velvet cupcakes
Our traditional authentic cream cheese red velvet cupcake!
4.25 $
Gluten Free Vanilla and Vanilla
Our buttercup golden vanilla cake with a vanilla buttercream.
4.11 $
Gluten Free Vanilla / Chocolate
Traditional golden vanilla cake with a Chocolate buttercream
4.11 $
Gluten Free Chocolate / Vanilla
Chocolate moist cake with a rich vanilla buttercream
4.11 $
Gluten Free Chocolate / Chocolate
Our moist chocolate cake with our Chocolate buttercream
4.11 $
Gluten Free Gooey Chocolate chip blondie bar
4.12 $
Gluten Free chocolate fudge brownie bar
4.11 $
Cupcakes
1 Dozen Premium Cupcakes Full size
A dozen of our top flavor cupcakes of the day.
62.74 $
1 Dozen Traditional Assortment NUTFREE full size
A dozen traditional cupcakes, free of nut.
60.74 $
1 Dozen Mini Cupcakes NUTFREE MINIS
A nut free assortment of mini cupcakes.
35.74 $
1 Dozen Premium Mini Cupcakes MINIS
A dozen of our top flavors in mini.
39.74 $
Chocolate Lover's Mix Cupcakes
A dozen of our top chocolate cupcake flavors. Contains nuts.
57.74 $
Apple Pie a La Mode ***
Caramelized apple cinnamon struessel cake topped with a ice-cream scoop style vanilla buttercream.
19.99 $
FUNFETTI Birthday Cupcakes
Our Vanilla Cake with Funfetti Rainbow Sprinkles throught. Choice of Buttercream.
19.99 $
Buttercup Golden Cupcake
Fluffy vanilla cake with choice of buttercream.
19.73 $
Classic Chocolate Cupcake
Rich chocolate cake with choice of buttercream.
19.73 $
Red Velvet Cupcake
Buttery cake with a hint of cocoa topped with cream cheese frosting.
19.73 $
Lemony Lemon Cupcake
Light and lemony cake with zesty lemon buttercream.
19.73 $
Chunky Monkey Cupcake
Banana cake filled with chocolate chips and chocolate buttercream.
19.99 $
Hummingbird Cupcake
Banana pineapple cake with cream cheese frosting and chopped pecans.
19.99 $
Devil Dog Cupcake
Rich chocolate cake with a whipped meringue frosting and chocolate drizzle.
19.73 $
Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter cupcake
Dark choc cake with Reese's PB cups inside and PB icing. For all you peanut butter freaks out there
19.99 $
Espresso Shot cupcake
Dark choc cake with a nescafe espresso coffee buttercream. Just don't try to eat one and fall asleep. Not happening.
19.99 $
Lemon Raspberry Torched Meringue
A light lemony cupcake with fresh raspberry jam filling and a whipped torched meringue frosting.
19.99 $
Oreo Cookies 'n Cream cupcakes
Vanilla cake stuffed with a whole Oreo (yes a whole one) topped with an Oreo crumb buttercream.
19.99 $
S'mores cupcake
Dark choc cake torched meringue, topped with toasted marshmallow, and don’t forget the graham cracker crust. Definitely addicting
19.99 $
Salted Caramel Dulce de Leche cupcake
Dulce de Leche cake with Swirls of salted caramel buttercream (sea salt). Sweet and salty, like a typical NY'ker.
19.99 $
Spiced Carrot cupcake
Carrot cake with apples & walnuts topped with a spiced cream cheese. Definitely a top favorite.
19.99 $
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Cupcake
Vanilla cake with a chocolate chip cookie inside topped with cookie dough buttercream + cookie dough topping.
4.25 $
Twinkie
Vanilla cake with light whipped meringue interior and topping. Like a classic Twinky (minus the 37 ingredients)
3.99 $
UBE cupcake
Filipino purple yam cake topped with Ube cream cheese icing.
4.25 $
Strawberry Cupcake
Light strawberry cake baked with fresh pieces of strawberry
4.25 $
The Thaly *Raspberry Choc*
Soft decadent chocolate cake with a rich raspberry filling, topped with a raspberry buttercream, ganache drizzle.
4.44 $
Brownies, Bars, and Squares
1dz Bar and Cookie Platter **
A platter of 6 of our favorite bars and 6 of our favorite cookies. All in one platter.
54.74 $
Lemon Tart Squares**
Our tart lemon squares topped with fine powdered sugar on a soft flaky crust. A topseller.
20.49 $
S'mores Campfire Bar***
Our top selling bar: Graham cracker crust, marshmallows, rich ganache, topped with torched meringue and chocolate fudge drizzle. Messy, but yummy.
21.24 $
Gooey Choc Chip Bar
A lovely chewy bar mixed with brown sugar and packed with chocolate chips.
19.74 $
Magic Coconut Bar
Shredded coconut, walnuts and chocolate chips caramelized in layers in a graham cracker crust.
19.99 $
Fudge Brownie
Rich and moist fudge brownies each infused with a hint of creamy dark chocolate.
19.73 $
Oatmeal Fudge
Housemade fudge layered between a chewy oatmeal crust.
19.99 $
Walnut Brownie
Our traditional brownie mixed and topped with walnuts
4 $
Peanut Butter Buckeye bar
Chocolate ganache, smooth peanut butter, and a oreo chocoolate crust on the bottom. Just like a classic buckeye reeses bar.
4.25 $
Oatmeal Fudge Bar
Oatmeal crust with rich chocolate fudge and extra oatmeal pieces of oatmeal on top.
4.25 $
Pecan Pie Bars
A rich square slice of Pecan pie in a bar!
5.5 $
Butter Cake Bar * New bar alert! *
Golden butter cake crust topped with gooey butter cake filling.
4 $
Cookies
Cookie Lovers Platter
An assortment of a dozen cookies
47.24 $
Triple Chocolate Fudge Pudding Cookie
Chocolate pudding cookie made with Valrhona cocoa powder and chocolate chunks, because chocolate chips aren't as fun.
18.24 $
Bestest Oatmeal Cinnamon Chocolate Cookie
Oatmeal cinnamon cookie loaded with chocolate chips.
18.44 $
Chocolate Chip Cookie
A traditional style chocolate chip cookie.
18.44 $
Salted Caramel Chunk Cookie
Soft and chewy cookie with gooey caramel bits and chocolate chunks topped with sea salt.
18.24 $
Snikerdoodle Cookie
Cinnamon snickerdoodle cookie. No worries, it's soft.
18.24 $
Famous Puddings
Famous Banana Pudding
Layers of luscious vanilla pudding with vanilla wafers and bananas.
94.74 $
Oreo Cookies and Cream Pudding
94.74 $
Chocolate Trifle Pudding
100.74 $
Caramel Brownie Cookie Dough Pudding
Chunks and bits of Chocolate chip bars, fudge brownies, and caramel drizzle goodness layered in our specialty pudding.
51.24 $
Tiramisu Pudding
The Buttercup twist on an Italian classic. Espresso flavored pudding layered with dark-roast coffee dipped lady fingers, dusted with a layer of Valhrona Cocoa Powder.
51.24 $
Mini Cheesecakes
Oreo crumb Mini Cheesecake
Oreo cookies and cream interior, oreo crumb topping. Chocolate based crust.
7 $
Marble Swirled Cheesecake
A swirl of Chocolate Marble Ganache
7 $
Strawberry Swirl
Strawberry cheesecake swirled with our homemade strawberry jam.
7 $
Red Velvet Cheesecake
Chocolate crumb crust / Red velvet cheesecake with cream cheese frosting and red velvet cupcake crumbs on top.
7 $
Quadruple Chocolate Cheesecake
A chocolate crumb base, chocolate cheesecake, topped with a ganache fudge and chocolate shavings on top.
7 $
Vanilla Bean Cheesecake
Vanilla Bean Cheesecake topped with our Vanilla Buttercream
7 $
Raspberry Marzipan Cheesecake
Raspberry swirled Cheesecake made with Marzipan (almond paste)
7 $
Cakes by the Slice
Buttercup Golden (Vanilla) with Chocolate Buttercream SLICE
22.74 $
Classic Chocolate Cake with Chocolate Buttercream SLICE
22.4 $
Lemon/Lemon Slice
22.99 $
Red Velvet Slice
22.99 $
Vanilla Cake Vanilla buttercream Slice
Vanilla Cake with Rich Vanilla Buttercream.
22.74 $
Chocolate Cake with Vanilla Buttercream Slice
22.74 $
Ube Cake with Rich Ube Frosting Slice
22.99 $
Strawberry Slice (staff fav)
Strawberry cake with bits of diced strawberries topped with a white chocolate infused vanilla buttercream
7.25 $
Salted Caramel Dulce-de-leche SLICE
7.25 $
Whole Cakes
Buttercup Golden Layer Cake Chocolate Icing
Buttercup Golden vanilla cake with rich chocolate buttercream
122.74 $
Classic Chocolate Layer Cake
Classic chocolate cake with rich chocolate buttercream
122.74 $
Bundt cake slices
Chocolate Sour Cream Cake
10" Cake.
32 $
Cinnamon Maple Bundt Cake Slice
A moist, rich cinnamon maple bundt cake with cinnamon glaze on top!