Ms. Lili is an absolute delight. The Kreatopita was beyond amazing! Every pastry we sampled was fabulous. This place is a must! It's location in Hell's Kitchen is perfect, just a few steps from Time Square!
Amazing Greek Bakery in NY! Traditional sweets that taste home made. Love the galatobouriko and your tsourekia were to die for. Thank you for providing a taste of home over Easter for us. Helen and Stephanie from Melbourne Australia.
Fabulous sweets and family. A must visit in NYC! We will be back again
The flogera has yet to disappoint! Excellent!! When in the city, I do my best to make a stop here. I remember a flight from EWR to LAX many, many years ago and the woman next to me was raving about Poseidon. I did not have to take her word, however, as I had already visited several times as a post meal stop from Cara Mia nearby.
Yesterday (3/31/18) was my first time at Poseidon and I thought it was a really great bakery!! I had the Kreatopita and the Trigona. I look forward to coming back next time I am in New York City.
Why is there not an option for 6x stars!? The people who run this place a lovely, it may say 'Greek' on the sign, but they also have Austrian heritage and it makes for a fantastic blend of deliciousness! So homey and yummy, plus freshly baked items sold still warm! Can't wait to visit again. :)
Christina DeFrancesco Haber
+5
So glad we found this bakery. We were looking for an Italian bakery and more than happy to find Poseidon. Such a great selection and nice family. We got 4 different desserts because we couldn't get just one.
We visit Every time we're in the city! You can't go wrong, no matter what you choose!
I've been coming here for over 20 years. Everything is always wonderful.
The absolute best Greek bakery in New York City.
The spanakopita and finikia are must-haves!
Unparalleled in quality and service. Food made with love!
Love love love in a little blue and white box xxxduane
Lina Fappiano Avila DiMora
+5
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes