My first reaction was that it was expensive but after trying it, totally worth it! Won't hesitate to pay for the delicious margherita because it didn't only look and smell great but it was possibly the best pizza I've had in NYC. I've been thinking about it since and am looking forward to trying the other pizzas on the menu ππ
Best pizza in New York! This place uses the highest quality ingredients. This is the kind of place where you come back again and again to try the whole menu, but not only their pizzas are excellent the salads are to die for. And what can I say about the Roasted Apple Crisp and The homemade tiramisu? EXCELENT uhmmm
Its about time Harlem caught up with quality wood burning oven pizza culture. As far as top notch pizza pie experience, #HarlemPizzaCo is on par with the best of them. Yet another valuable addition to Harlem's ever growing culinary experience.
Amazing food, great service! I had the Baby Arugula Salad and the Lexington Pizza. The salad is insanely good! The pizza was lovely and tasted even better when I had leftovers later in the day. I will definitely be back!
Had the marguerite & the spicy salami. Both were delicious. For dessert, the Nutella calzone-served warm with fresh whipped cream. It was sooo good. Service was excellent, nice wine & beer selection. I will go again next time I'm in Harlem.
This place is a must if you are in the city! The pizza here is incredible and better than every other pizza place you'll find around here.
Great pizza! Crust is thin and crispy all the way through. I ate a whole pizza and didn't feel disgustingly full as the ingredients are all natural and the pizza is not greasy!! This place is for the nyc pizza snob.....you won't be disappointed!
How can you not love a pizza place that serves coke-a-cola in glass bottles! Not to mention the pizza is made fresh while you're there with some of the best toppings I've had on any pizzas.
Cannot say enough good things about their pizza. The best advice I can give you? Step out of your cheese pizza ordering box and get one of the specials. These guys know what they're doing!
This is truly a neighborhood gem. The best pizza and calzones I've had in the city!
Brick oven pizza at it's best! And service is absolutely great
Love the pizza at Harlem Pizza Co! A hidden gem in New York!
Soooo good. I'm so glad these guys are right downstairs, they're my favorite!
Amazing pizza! I love this place! And my kids are crazy for the Nutella pie.
Jacqueline Stone Hetherington
+5
Best in the neighborhood! Love the pizza, the menu and service!
Great pizza, great prices, great service. Recommended!
We had our first delivery last night. Two pizzas and a salad. Everything was really delicious and made with a lot of CARE. It will be our first of many, I am sure. Thanks and welcome to the neighborhood!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes