My girlfriend and I stumbled upon this place today. We went to Kitchenette to buy a scone, but they didn't have any. A man at the counter told us that if we wanted really delicious pastries to go "literally around the corner" and that we would find a bakery there. We've been in Morningside Heights since 2006 and never once had either of us seen Susan Sez. We popped in, asked what they had, and were delighted with free samples (chocolate biscotti and sugar cookies), followed by two muffins - peach and pear - straight out of the oven. The muffins were light, sweet little clouds, peppered with deliciously caramelized fresh fruit. One of the best muffins I've ever had. We will definitely be coming back here for more.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes