Best Paella Valenciana in New York City

3 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Sevilla Restaurant & Bar
Sevilla Restaurant & Bar
82/100 (2243 ratings)
Restaurants
Mediterranean
Spanish
Mediterranean
Spanish
Vegetarian Friendly
Seafood
Seafood
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Scallops
Clams
Calamari
Mussels
Calamares
Cheesecake
Tapas
Gazpacho
Shrimp
Octopus
Chicken Wings
Paella
Lobster
Seafood Paella
Salad
Paella Valenciana
Fish
Crab
Sit down
Spanish
Seafood
Mediterranean
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Takeout
Dinner
Late Night
Lunch
Mid-range
"It was my first time here, but it won't be my last. This was a delight to come to this restaurant. The food was so good that those flavors were like..."
Jose R Lopez
"I visit this place as often as I can when I visit New York City. The food is consistently delicious. The Lobster Special - scrumptious. And their..."
Sheryl Carter
"2nd time of go to the amazing restaurant. Staff extremely attentive , friendly and professional. Best food ever . Rib with fruit sauce are out of..."
Neyla Estrada
"This place is "ESPECTACULAR"!!! Once a friend and I stopped by for dinner but it was closed, and today at work, in an informal conversation with a..."
Aida Gomez
"First and foremost this is a walk-in place so no OpenTable or Resy reservations. Came here with my wife and kid for a Spanish food night and the..."
Neftali S (NS)
"I had been meaning to visit Sevilla for years, and finally made it. In the middle of the sweltering NYC heat, entering the restaurant was a welcome..."
Heather Dolland Tamam
"Love love love the food. I had some tasty ham croquets , a seafood Paella, a house sald and a Birthhday Flan as wepl as a cafe con..."
Janet Caraballo
"The owner of the restaurant wholeheartedly made sure to pay each table a visit to confirm everything was ok. We enjoyed our table specific musical..."
Patrick Davidson
"This place is the definition of old school restaurant. The food was amazing, lots of apps and sangria and you have to get the paella! No reservations..."
Mike Ortiz
"Great vibes & always delicious food @Servilla! Had seafood 🦞paella, Filet of Sole w/green sauce, rice +..."
Catherine Maggio
"This restaurant was outstanding. Perfect service. Nice warm atmosphere. Pork chops weekend mouthwatering. Salad fresh & delicious. Chicken w almond..."
Colleen Dooley
"I have been coming here with my parents since I was very young maybe around 10? Now as an adult I had a wonderful date night with my husband. I find..."
Amanda Blackman
"Best paella and sangria ever , but you can't go wrong with anything on the menu. The veggie paella is really vey good , way better than I expected...."
Paul Leonard
"Always enjoy the time at Sevilla. Never let me down. They have the best (and inexpensive) sangria and paella! Definitely order them for your first..."
Justin Carpenter
"Authentic Spanish food and vibe from everyone who works there. The chorizo is really good and paella is very well served (they say for 2 people, I..."
Regulo Salinas
"This place first opened in 1941 and that experience, class and tradition continues to this day! The atmosphere, the interior are exquisite. There's a..."
Juan Gutierrez
Meson Sevilla
Meson Sevilla
87/100 (2686 ratings)
Restaurants
Mediterranean
Spanish
Mediterranean
Spanish
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Lamb
Scallops
Pesto
Clams
Fish
Calamari
Pork
Mussels
Calamares
Salmon
Tapas
Tortillas
Shrimp
Octopus
Paella
Seafood Paella
Lobster
Patatas Bravas
Pasta
Paella Valenciana
Salad
Rice pudding
Crab
Sit down
Mediterranean
Spanish
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
Cafe Espanol
Cafe Espanol
78/100 (522 ratings)
Restaurants
Mediterranean
Spanish
Vegetarian Friendly
Latin
Seafood
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Clams
Calamari
Mussels
Calamares
Salmon
Tapas
Gazpacho
Tortillas
Shrimp
Octopus
Chicken Wings
Lobster
Paella
Salad
Seafood Paella
Paella Valenciana
Scallops
"Lobster Night on Monday, great deal! I had a twin lobsters with a nice sangria. People are friendly..."
Atsuko Takahashi
"Great for a romantic dinner for small groups! Traditional spanish plates and excellent pitchers of margaritas and mojitos- all at a great..."
Colleen Brooks
"Love this place. Great food, fun bar and friendly people. The menu offers delicious tapas as well as many traditional Spanish entrees. The flexible..."
Christine Williams
"used to come here often during my time at NYU. Most recently was here a couple of months ago for dinner with my family. the place is very intimate..."
Steven Lam
"Food is absolutely tasty. Service is fast and waiters/waitresses are very friendly and PROFESSIONAL. I love the scenery and even though it is a tight..."
adonia johnson
"I visited Cafe Espanol with a group of 6. We all had the most amazing meals and I love this place! I had the seafood Paella and it was off the hook..."
Jim Brickett
"The owner, Irene, made a point to walk around and chat with patrons. Loved her energy & passion. The staff showed a lot of teamwork and seemed..."
M Riley
"Great authentic Spanish food. Great Sangria. Great service and great prices. We were so full when we left that the four of us fell asleep in the cab..."
Don Stugots
"Been going to Cafe Espanol for years. Food is tasty, drinks are abundant, prices are realistic, (and for their lunch menu, outstanding!) staff is..."
Carlos Ortiz
"The atmosphere and decor is awesome. The service was good even though I had to wait longer than usual.(Saturday crowd). The food was a bit expensive..."
Derek Penn