Best Reuben sandwich in New York City

4 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Katz's Deli
Katz's Deli
90/100 (74929 ratings)
Restaurants
Deli
Deli
American
Israeli
Kosher
Kosher
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Brunch
Hot Dog
Cheesecake
French Fries
Roast Beef
Omelette
Corned Beef
Cheesecakes
Bagels
Sandwiches
Reuben sandwich
Burger
Matzo Ball Soup
Pastrami Sandwich
Beef
Salad
Cakes
Sit down
Israelí
Deli
Delivery
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Highchairs Available
Accepts Credit Cards
Non-smoking restaurants
Brunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Katz’s is an institution for a reason. Absolutely the best pastrami sandwich that has ever existed. You can’t go wrong with a place like this...."
Aylon Pesso
"We were there while in NYC because everyone was talking about the famous sandwich. I can tell you that we expect really something else from..."
Jurj Alexandru
"There is a reason this place has stood the test of time in NYC, an absolute staple and must do if visiting here. Both the pastrami and brisket are..."
Bec M
"This was one of the best meals we had in NYC. The lines were long but it didn’t matter, it was a great experience. Hold on to the ticket they..."
Hector Pina
"An important place on the NYC map for fans of meat sandwiches. The delicatessen is always crowded with customers, which means that the waiting time..."
Irek Fojcik
"Several people had recommended it to us... 'the best pastrami in the world' they said. Once we got close to the place we could see that something was..."
sergi sm
"I initially thought Katz's was overrated, but it truly deserves all its praise. The service was impressively quick, the meat was unlike anything I've..."
Ethem Can
"This place is a MUST visit if you’re in the area. While the line outside may seem long and daunting, it honestly moves pretty quickly. We ordered a..."
Jessica Ali
"This is an institution for deli meats in NYC. They give you a sample of the meats you like before you order. Wow, you can try and then buy. What a..."
C Neon
"The pastrami, though very pricey, was delicious! Even better than it looks. I got the reuben (add pastrami $1) which came with house pickles and we..."
Kel
Stage Door Deli
Stage Door Deli
88/100 (2684 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Pizza
Vegan Options
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Brunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Salad
Cheesecake
French Toast
Toasts
Cheeseburger
Corned Beef
Burger
Bagels
Reuben sandwich
Beef
Pastrami Sandwich
New York Style Pizza
Cakes
Pancakes
Paninis
Sit down
Pizza
American
Seating
Serves Alcohol
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Brunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop
Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop
83/100 (3440 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Deli
Diner
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Brunch
Dinner
Breakfast
Lunch
Late Night
Carrot Cake
Bagels
Pancakes
Reuben sandwich
Matzo Ball Soup
Meatloaf
Pastrami Sandwich
Salad
Tuna Melt
Tuna
French Fries
Toasts
Sandwiches
Burger
Roast Beef
Grilled cheese
Omelette
Beef
Corned Beef
BLT
"Cannot say enough good things about this place. One of our very favorite spots, which we visited three times on our trip. They serve the BEST hot..."
Amy Obreiter
"Really good sandwiches, service and it had a lively and energetic vibe to the place. I had a turkey club sandwich while my wife had an egg salad..."
Rajashekar Subramany
"An amazing dining experience! Friendly and courteous atmosphere. Our server, Bella, was so knowledgeable and recommended great sandwiches. The..."
Tony Perez
"Classic diner with sandwiches and Jewish classics like matzo ball soup. Bar seats are a tough fight but get much easier to land if you come alone...."
Rovik Robert
"Amazing pastrami Sandwich! It was delicious. I ordered the Ruben pastrami Sandwich and my husband ordered the cheese burger which was delicious as..."
Gabriela Gonzalez
"Came here for lunch and was met with a crowd. The food tasted wonderful (I recommend the Reuben), but the service is done in super cheap plates and..."
Ross Wilson
"There was quite a line on weekend but the wait was not so long. Food was good with good oldie..."
Mild
"If a restaurant has been serving food for over 90 years, you can be sure it will be on my Try List. Eisenberg’s was on that list for my NYC trip..."
Eboni M
"We got in line when it was out the door but we’re seated in a little less than 30 minutes. We got the Matzah ball soup, and Reuben Sandwiches...."
Micah “East” Lewis
"Eisenberg's, now known as S&P, is a NYC tradition since 1928. Here's the drill: you sit at the counter amid total chaos and the "counterman" takes..."
Hilary Ring
Majestic Delicatessen
Majestic Delicatessen
73/100 (974 ratings)
Quick Bites
American
Vegan Options
American
Deli
Cafe
Cafe
Deli
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Breakfast
Lunch
Late Night
Brunch
Salad
Cheesecakes
Cannoli
Tuna
Bagels
Cheesecake
Turkey Sandwich
Reuben sandwich
Pastrami Sandwich
Cakes
Paninis
French Toast
Sandwiches
Toasts
Cheeseburger
Juice & Smoothies
Burger
Beef
Roast Beef
Omelette
Pancakes
Corned Beef
Juice & Smoothies
Fast food
American
Deli
Café
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Brunch
Late Night
Breakfast
Mid-range
"Fantastic food!! A little pricey but everything else is too and this place is definitely worth the extra cost! And the staff is not rude, very nice..."
Stephanie Walters Riser
"We love this place. Great food, friendly and hard working staff. Great place to relax and watch people go..."
Jeff Marken
"Looked for something different while in New York. Came across this Majestic place. Most everything in one stop. Canola, Cheese cake were good...."
Phil Santarelli
"Been in the area for a week and eaten here a few times...it's always busy, but the service is great and the food even better! Will certainly be..."
Bill Jagdev
"Always the best cheesecake around! Friendly..."
Sara White Socks
"Great dining experience, close to our location. Price was in our budget. I had the best French Dip..."
Robin Carson
"Loved the food and the place has this quiet yet happy mood to it. Also, the service is great and the staff is friendly (Abrazo a los mexicanos que..."
Iván Solorio Santos
"Great staff, amazingly clean for Times Square and the food is fresh and..."
Samantha Rivera
"OMG this place was GREAT . The service was out of this world, they take your order and by the time you get to the register to pay for your food it's..."
Darla Darla
"Had nice breakfast here at Majestic Deli. Ordered Italian omelette. Nice fluffy omelette. It was too early to order their their pastrami..."
P D (PDiddy)
"Amazing for breakfast. The bagel with cream cheese and salmon was amazing, maybe just a tad too much filling but tasted amazing. Service is fast,..."
Chris Longmuir
"My wife loved the Ruben! I had the cheeseburger. Stopped in while visiting time square. The only complaints would be the Ruben being $20, and also..."
Thomas Ranaldi
"My meal looked…sad, don’t you think? Like my eggs were dealing with post Christmas depression or something. Having sad that, everything was..."
Henry Voros
"Nice average New York deli located on times Square. Average prices but suggest buying drinks elsewhere due to cost. Good sandwiches and salads. Nice..."
Get Up Radio Media
"Came here twice for coffee and some of the biggest donuts cakes and pastries I've ever seen. Reasonable prices for what you get here. Lots of photos..."
Chris Larkin
"OK first of all I understand this could be considered a tourist place, BUT the food was great and we saw lots of locals eating inside as well! Lots..."
Emily Case