Best Classic Burger in New York City

3 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Slowly Shirley
Slowly Shirley
87/100 (771 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
Bar
Pub
American
Dinner
Late Night
Drinks
sake
Martini
Mai Tai
Classic Burger
Double Cheeseburger
Double Burger
Jalapeno Cocktail
American
Bar
Wine and Beer
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Street Parking
Seating
Serves Alcohol
Late Night
Drinks
Dinner
Mid-range
"Excellent service and cocktails at The Hukilau! These folks know how to get down, and they know their stuff! Great job! Can't wait to make it to..."
Billiam Prestwood
"Very cool place with amazing drinks pre dinner date. Must check it..."
Ricardo Jardim
"What a wonderful place to enjoy great bites, outstanding cocktails and wonderful conversations amongst..."
Duane Fernandez Jr
Whitmans Restaurant
Whitmans Restaurant
83/100 (2678 ratings)
Restaurants
American
American
Dinner
Lunch
Crack Kale
Bluicy Burger
Our Famous ''Juicy Lucy''
Local Beer Sausage
Brooklyn Best Lemonade
Burger
East Villy Cheese Steak
Cheese Stuffing
Sides Blue Cheese Fries Tater Tots Sweet Potato Fries
Brussel Sprout Salad with Grilled Chicken
Classic Burger
Salad
PB & B Burger
Patty Melt
Cheesesteak
blt Sandwich with Chips
Fried pickles
Peanut Butter Burger
Onion rings
Hamburger
Avocado toast
Fried Pickles
Green Chili Burger
Kale Salad with Grilled Chicken
Sit down
American
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Takeout
Reservations
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"Honestly, the best burger joint in New York City. Took my friend from UK to this burger joint while he was in the US and he loved it. The service was..."
Sharun Kumar
"Just as amazing as I had expected since we have been copying their recipe for like four years now. They know how to make you a good..."
Tom Plomin
"This place is awesome! We walked in with a party of 10. They accommodated us immediately.. quickly moving tables together. The burgers are amazing!..."
Cindy Lee Sabaski
"The PB&J Burger was incredible; cooked perfectly! The service was generous, kind and sincere! I enjoyed the menu selection and beverage options! ..."
Nicole E. Day Gray
"whitmans is the only place in the world i would choose for the best grilled..."
Harrison Sears
"Food. Service...."
Bryson Edwards
"The meat is something special. They make an incredible hamburger, and it's all about the meat. Single Outdoor seating is the expert..."
Justin Linn
"Loved their burgers filled with cheese....."
Marcy Bonilla
"It has a very 2010s hipster vibe and I'm into it. Probably one of the few places I've seen with a peanut butter burger on the menu (it's very good)..."
Steve Bronder
"First I will say I love the staff, ther are always super friendly and extremely accommodating. The food is first class. I've had just about..."
Robert Field
"the side of pickles is what gets me to keep coming back!!! its AMAZING, you get about 4 full sized local pickles. the vegetarian philly cheese steak..."
Erika B
"This place is tucked into a quiet corner of St Marks Street. The burgers were on point with juicy meats, hot fries and optional unique toppings. In..."
Kumaar U.
"A bit expensive and some think the portions are small but I think it's the perfect size with relation to the bun and lettuce and other toppings. The..."
Bob Barzyk
"***** 5 STARS I want to know who is responsible for this incredible food experience. Thanks you! Consider opening a Whitman’s on long island. I’d..."
Ross B
Room4996
70/100 ( ratings)
Restaurants
Classic Burger
Strawberry Margarita
Sweet Chili Wings
Salmon
Lobster Mac & Cheese
Chicken &Woffles