Best Nutella Pizza in New York City

3 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
San Matteo Pizza Espresso Bar
San Matteo Pizza Espresso Bar
91/100 (1827 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Espresso
Calzone
Pizza special
Nutella Pizza
Burrata pizza
Tomato Sauce
caprichosa
Fresh Burrata
Vino Bianco
Peperoncino
Eggplant Parmigiana
Tiramisú
Pasta
Cheese Balls
Margherita Pizza
Salad
Pizza Napoletana
Burrata Pizza Bianche
Al Crudo
Prosciutto E Burrata Antipasti
Prosciutto E Bufala Pizza
Prosciutto
Insalata Di Arugula
Pesto
Antipasti
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Quality ingredients makes for a damn good pizza. The dough and crust was just the right amount of crispiness. Fresh cheese was delicious! Small..."
Raul Quintana
"Great pizza place with lots of authentic Italian touches and dishes. The panuozzi has a great crunchy crust, and you can choose from a wide range of..."
Vladimir Dragoev
"Wow!! Very Italian place. Waiter suggested items and we bit. Very Italian dishes. All great tasting, great presentation, great portions! Was..."
James Gottshall
"Absolutely delicious! Came here for lunch and loved everything we got. For a group of 4, we got burrata, a salad, two pizzas (the crust was perfect),..."
Melissa O'Connor
"Authentic restaurant with a real Italian touch. Food was amazing, worm and welcome service, ask for the special plate, wowww it was..."
ManyTime Keren
"Pizza Is very good here! The place is nice but not amazing inside nor outside. That is why I gave 4 stars to the atmosphere. I would not bring my..."
Sara
"Very authentic Italian pizza. So crispy! Maybe the best one on..."
Emily Wang
"True Italian Naples style pizza. Great ingredients, good flavor, and a crunchy crust. Would..."
Austin
"Amazing calzone (ricotta salami) and informal Italian outdoor dining, very cozy the owner and service are very attentive and friendly, end with their..."
Frank Fayer
"This is my go to place for pizza in nyc. Pizza is amazing, staff is friendly and cozy atmosphere. Be aware that this is not NYC style pizza, but..."
Felipe Tinoco
"UPDATE: It's a sad day when I have to update this review but it's here. The owner has retired to a Cafe he runs elsewhere and new management has..."
Tarek El-Ghazaly
"I got the Capricciosa pizza and it was amazing! I’m not Italian but I’ve been to Italy and this definitely felt..."
Mckenzie Michael
"Great pizza, quality ingredients, nice service, outside seating - all at a decent price...."
Carlos
"The server and pizza maker were both friendly. Generous outdoor seating, Well made and tasty pizza, but a little over-priced. Got one Vestuti pie,..."
DBorreliWHAT
"A hidden gem of Neapolitan taste. San Matteo has a great family atmosphere and the fantastic taste of authentic Neapolitan pizza and Italian food...."
Adriano Carelli
"The most wonderful food and wine. Might be the best pizza outside italy. long-time..."
Evan Seide
Keste
Keste
85/100 (3543 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Tiramisú
Fried Dough
Classic Margherita Pizza
Angioletti with Nutella
Night & Day Calzone
Arancino with Truffles
Real Italian Salad
Salad
Vegetariana Sin Gluten
Prosciutto & Mushroom Pizza
Lasagna
Panna Cotta
Espresso Doppio
Nutella Pizza
Fresh Mozzarella
"How could I have ever gone to any other pizza place ever? This place is perfection. I am an avid gluten eater but my husband has a severe gluten..."
Heaz Kissinger
"Welcoming, attentive service. Outside seating good. 11 inch pizzas from $19 to $24 for the quality ingredients are good. Generous amounts of..."
M O
"Best gluten free pizza I’ve ever had!! While visiting New York, I had to go twice as it was that amazing. I had to ask if it was gluten free pizza..."
Celia Lane
"Why take 1 pizza when you can have 2? Delicious neapolitan pizza! Simple and tasty, not much more to ask or say. Those pizza are so good that after..."
Benoît
"Had a gluten free pizza and calzone. Both were good though Calzones are rather heavy (never had one before). But pizza was amazing. We picked this..."
Badrul
"Stopped in for a late lunch with a table of 6. We split a salad and three awesome pizzas on the patio. Also ordered a few of the spritz cocktails..."
Scott Griest
"Great pizza and service Their fried pizzas are different from the regular personal pies, great flavors and the crust is quite flaky on the outside..."
Victor C
"Good taste, portions, price, especially if coming for lunch Came here for the lunch specials. Tried one of the 8 inch pizzas with prosciutto. Crust..."
Leon Lin
Keste Pizza & Vino
Keste Pizza & Vino
85/100 (3936 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Neapolitan
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Lasagna
Panna Cotta
Focaccia Di Recco
Burrata Fritta
Fresh Mozzarella
Tiramisú
Salad
提拉米蘇
Espresso Doppio
Fried Dough
Nutella Pizza
Classic Margherita Pizza
Angioletti with Nutella
Night & Day Calzone
Tiramisu
Prosciutto
Arancino with Truffles
Real Italian Salad
Italian Beef
Vegetariana Sin Gluten
Neapolitan pizza
Montanara Truffle
Buffalo mozzarella
Truffle Burrata Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Pizza
Neapolitan
Italian
Non-smoking restaurants
Delivery
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Highchairs Available
Accepts Credit Cards
Family style
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range