Best Blackened Mahi Mahi Sandwich in New York City

There is only one restaurant
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Croton Reservoir Tavern
Croton Reservoir Tavern
71/100 (2133 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Gluten Free Options
Bar
Pub
Grill
Bar
Grill
Pub
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Brunch
Drinks
Salad
Shrimp Avocado Salad
Crab
Sopa de Langosta
Tuna
Margherita Flatbread
Salmon
Tavern Burger
Blackened Mahi Mahi Sandwich
The Cobb Salad
Crab Cake
Burger
Crispy Gochujang Brussels
Cheesecake
Crt Standard Burger
Omelette
Three Bean Veggie Burger
Cast Iron Shrimp
Pork
Summer Squash & Prosciutto Flatbread
Burrata
Hayden Old Fashioned & Mexican Martini
Arroz Con Salmón Y Zanahorias
Ribeye
Lobster
Braised Short Rib Rigatoni
IPA
Rosé
Manhattan
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Sit down
Grill
American
Bar
Pub
Reservations
Full Bar
Seating
Free Wifi
Table Service
Television
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Mid-range
"Looks like a typical cross town bar but has a great atmosphere and exceptionally well prepared food. Not a big menu but the selections provide for a..."
Bill Dittrich
"My daughter and I were having a pre birthday dinner. The place is lovely. We particularly recommend the Brussels sprouts!!!..."
Maria Munoz
"The food is delicious so are the drinks. The waitress was super nice to make sure the soup was vegan. We will be back for..."
Diana Salmazo
"Early dinner after an enjoyable matinee. Never been to Croton but a place we wanted to try! Host/waiter greeted us upon entering and seated us..."
R A
"We came in a Saturday around 7 and the restaurant was just about empty, which made me nervous. However, we were seated at the bar and was met by the..."
Joe M
"Spirited atmosphere and an energetic vibe. Food was nice with fresh vibrant vegetables. Bartenders were polite, attentive and..."
Kassim Chaudry
"I've been here a couple of times, and it's hit or miss food wise. Service is usually good, but they are out of things a lot. For example, I went..."
Katie S
"Nice place in the craziness of Bryant park! Service here was good. Beer line can use some checking as we had a couple flat lagers in our..."
Executive Thrillseeker
"Awesome restaurant. Great service, amazing food and the prices are great compared to other upper scale..."
Joe Lee
"I really enjoyed having lunch here. The burger was excellent it came with a very small salad but the quality of the meat was good and the flavor was..."
Robin
"Fantastic classic New York bar, with very friendly and helpful staff. Very welcoming, wheelchair friendly, accommodating to allergies. Delicious..."
Blaire Hannan
"It was pleasant, We sat outside although it lightly rained. The staff took about 6 umbrellas and pushed them together to give us shelter for our CLUB..."
Leilan Robinson
"Good bar for after work drinks. Bartender Adam was great, very friendly. Would definitely come back. Bells Two Hearted IPA..."
Paul Basantes
"Good place for a drink in the evening. Prices are ok. Had good talks with the bartender. Havent checked their food, but looks good from what Ive..."
Rob Th
"Host greeted us immediately upon arrival and sat us at our reserved table promptly. Our waiter was engaging, efficient and our drinks and salads..."
Theresa
"Always a great time at Croton. Jason, Kaberle, Daryl and the rest of the staff are always accommodating. Best place to unwind after a crazy work..."
Dez I