"Went to buy some brownies as a gift - and gifted myself a congo bar. Wow - this was fabulous. It was kind of a take on a magic cookie bar. Coconut..."
Meenakshi
"These witches are totally bewitching! The brownies are moist and dense, but not doughy. So many different variants to choose from. I had the original..."
Manz
"Who doesn’t love a good Brownie?In New York City’s Chelsea market, the Fat Witch Bakery has built an entire business on selling just..."
The Restaurant Fairy
"We stopped in while walking around Chelsea Markets (store is close to the 9th Ave entrance), lured by the interesting name and creative decor...."
Anatoli
"Everyone's fave brownie in more than a few..."
Tastymontreal
"Hardly Could Contain Her Joy. Purchased an original Fat Witch Brownie for my dining partner and let me just say she could hardly contain herself with..."
Lepricano
"THE BEST BROWNIES EVER. These are the best brownies I've had in my entire life. They are AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! `Nuff..."
Maddie
"Brownie-licious!. Best little brownies I've ever tasted. Great gift for the chocoholic or brownie addict in your life. I got my dad a box for his..."
Lola
"Starting with the blondie brownie-I really liked this one the best of the two. It had a strong vanilla taste that I liked, was chewy and it had large..."
Bella Vivere
"However I was swept away by the Fat Witch Bakery the first time I tried their sample. It is perfectly fudgey without being..."
Andrea
"Fat Witch bakes all of its goodies on the premises, so you can rest assured that they're fresh. None of that Entenmann's stuff that could be a week..."
EateryROW
"One Fat Witch scratches the itch Two Fat Witches are bad for the britches... Chelsea Market was one of the very first places* I decided had to be..."
Penguins And Parentheses
"Who doesn't love a good Brownie? In New York City's Chelsea market, the Fat Witch Bakery has built an entire business on selling just brownies. Their..."
The Restaurant Fairy
"We got three small brownies: citrus had a great flavour, and Macha one had a full matcha flavour which I loved (considering some bakeries have just a..."
S LEE
"I ordered a tin of assorted brownies from Fat Witch Bakery for my sister’s birthday, who is a self-proclaimed brownie connoisseur, and it was..."
Elizabeth
"Not super welcoming or friendly. The caramel witch brownie was pretty good,..."
Carrie Desler
"Simple and to the point, they even had samples. They are smooth but with a nice thickness in the bite and the edges have crunch, perfect texture...."
leshem c
"I come here all the time! Amazing brownies with a wide selection of flavors.(matcha, vanilla, white chocolate, caramel, etc) I recommend getting the..."
Sofia Liu
"Being from out of state, it was tricky to find. But boy the brownies were worth it! I tried the Raspberry and Turtle brownies and they we’re both..."
Lisa Alvarado
"Great brownie. Lots of great looking baked goodies. Simple and attractive decor. Visited there recently and was surprised to see just how empty the..."
Jason Persaud
"A great snack-ish dessert as you’re exiting the Chelsea Market.
When we planned to visit the Chelsea Market, my girlfriend was recommended to..."
Anderson Z
"They truly melt in your mouth!!
Super fresh, amazing rich taste, and such a lovely little place. They have a ton of selections to chose from, and..."
Jenna Bishop
"This place is located inside the chelsea market on 8th st. They havw a tons of variety and brownie flavors. Even found a matcha..."
Martiña González
"I have know this place since 2007 till now the best brownie i have ever had, i think they have 10 flavors, i only wish if they would deliver out of..."
Mohammed Maghrabi
"My favorite brownie in New York.
Their brownies are freshly made and delicious.
Friendly and helpful staff! Love this..."
Light Foot By Coni
"Great brownies in town. I only come here after five so that I can get 50% off brownies for..."
Lisa Kim
"Great brownies - the Fat Witch Babies are just the right size to get your brownie fix with minimal guilt. Cute packaging. Take a dozen to the next..."
KGQ NYC
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes