The best Restaurants in Newark Valley ranking of February 2025
5 restaurant menus in Newark Valley, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
"Lived here for years. First time ordering a full Stromboli (no peppers, add bacon)
HIGHLY Recommend!! It’s big and full of meat, it’s great. New..."
Ant Mert (Mert)
"We drive about a 20 minute drive to get the pizza here. This really is one of the best pizza places in..."
Shannon B
"A local business loved by her community. They've cranked out pizza pie after pie for the needs of the community for YEARS! If you are in the area..."
Jesse Barrett
"Staff is always polite and any request I have they honor. We buy pizza and wings all the time but the ravioli and chicken spiedies are..."
kathy vanvorce
"For the little town of Newark Valley, this place is good. They have a charming, homey atmosphere with good service and a friendly waitstaff. The..."
Evan Arnold
"We got a sheet pizza here for 13.99, was the best tasting pizza I've had in a while. Sauce and cheese remind me of Anielios in Corning. We were more..."
Michael Slaughter
"Great atmosphere and service!! You get more than you can eat and it's old school Italian!! Absolutely delicious!! We are up from Florida and my..."
Faye Gillow
"Never been. Taking son to mx track down road figured we could try it. One of the best steak subs I ever had. If we come down here again (2 hours from..."
Bethany Herkimer
"Surprising restaurant find in Newark Valley, NY. We've drive by Fortunato many times, and finally decided to stop in. The outside looks decent much..."
Tim Sweeney
"Chicken in our salads was bone..."
Lex Snyder
"Fortunato's is what my mother calls and "Old World Restaurant". That is a big compliment. I agree that the food is substantial and packed with..."
Anne Calloway
"Pizza is super good. That being said, sometimes I'll call three times over the course of 15 minutes and no one answers the phone.
I wish there was..."
Christopher Cena
"Out on a drive and stopped here for lunch. Very clean and updated. Good menu choices from appetizers to dinners. Fairly priced and lunch was..."
"For the price you get quite a bit of food. I ordered the 2 pieces of French toast and ham on the side. I got two Huge pieces of French toast and 3..."
Dawn Westbrook
"Small town winner !! Best breakfast for 30 miles consistent dishes not good one day bad the next. always GOOD! What a jem thanks for feeding..."
steve junior
"I got breakfast and it was pretty good! Potatoes were a little overcooked but that's probably just personal preference. French toast is really good...."
Ash Willows
"Excellent place for a cheap and hearty breakfast. Basically, this is what a small Town diner should be at breakfast time..."
james marsh
"Attentive staff, (more like friends)were quick to fill my cup of Joe and the food was very..."
Louise Marie
"Stopped here after the one up the road was to busy. Well worth it. French toast was good, eggs where good, everyone I went with enjoyed their food...."
Tayler Robins
"My son and I had some time to kill before an appointment so we popped into the Creekside, which is a rather unassuming, hidden little gem. I've been..."
4theloveofsaints
"The people are friendly and real. They treat you like they have always known you. The food is excellent and the atmosphere is homey! Like going to..."
Esther Snavely
"First time here and but not our last! The food was great! Friendly hometown diner. It was clear to us that this iwas the go to place for the..."
Char France
"We love going here it's a great place to eat and sit down with the family the people there are kind and make you feel at home the food is always..."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes