Best Ice Cream in Newburyport

6 restaurant menus in Newburyport, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Harbor Creamery
Harbor Creamery
90/100 (338 ratings)
Restaurants
American
American
Dinner
Lunch
Lemon Ginger Ice Cream with Whipped Topping
Sea Salt at Harbor Creamery
Candy
Pistachio Ice Cream
Sprinkles
Peanut Butter
Caramel Crunch
Chocolate Sorbet
Mocha Chip
Regular Sundae
Ice Cream
Minty Chip
Chocolate Milk Cookies
Mocha Dairy-Free Icecream
Ice Cream Cup with Whipped Topping
American
Takeout
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"I'm picky about ice cream, and was prepared for the typical overly sweet, airy, cheap tasting ice cream found at most ice cream shops, but this is..."
Alexis Katkevich
"Beautiful shop! Amazing flavors, my favorite was the coffee crunch! This is now our go to shop for..."
Nom Baccam Darling
"Loved the ice cream at Harbor Creamery. I am an Oreo fan and the chocolate milk and cookies is amazing!! So good I bought a quart to take home. Their..."
Christina Lynn
"Sugar free mocha espresso with REAL chocolate jimmies = ��� Amazing home-made ice cream in the heart of downtown Newburyport! They even put..."
Ashley Matthews
"Awesome ice cream and an always helpful staff! The inventive flavors are always really good and something you can't find anywhere..."
Lauren Sager
"Best mint choc chip I've ever had! Amazingly gorgeous shop and fantastic staff ......"
Sharon Honey
"So happy there is finally a local shop that makes the perfect vanilla!..."
Caitlin Blais
"Love having a new, homemade ice cream place in town! Shop is so cute and the ice cream was..."
Deanna Moreau
"Absolutely phenomenal homemade ice cream! The spaghetti � sundae makes any Sunday a sundae funday! Great staff!..."
George Bixby
"Delicious homemade Ice cream, friendly staff and beautiful nautical decor. Attention to detail all around! Loved..."
Brittany Bowie
"Our second visit! Kids LOVE the spaghetti sundae!! I had the key lime. So, so good!! Creamy, fresh, and delightful!!! It will definitely be my go-to..."
Lori McIntosh
"The ice cream is delicious and they make it right there, service is excellent and the prices are reasonable. Really nice new business in Newburyport,..."
Matt Connorton
"The best! So delish and not too sweet. Could tell you use high quality..."
Shireen Rich Scott
"Delicious homemade ice cream! Our favorite flavors include Riptide, Caramel Crunch, and Cookie Dough! We'll be back..."
Lisa Johnson Sundstrom
"Dangit. Its close, its employed by super friendly folks, its going to be open in the winter AND it's awesome. Stoked to have you in..."
Kristi Ferguson
"Incredible ice cream and offerings. Amazing home made..."
Ryan Kelley
"Best ice cream in a very long time! Mint chocolate chip...... Yummmmmmm!!! Can't wait to go back for..."
Annelies Joss
"I'm a barber at Inn Street Barbershop and my last cut came in today eating a bowl of coffee ice cream. Which prompted me to stop in on my way home...."
Lowell H. Oliver
"Exceptional tasting ice cream served with a smile! The Harbor Creamery is perfect for any sweet..."
Mandy Linehan
"Best dairy-free ice cream I’ve had. Ever. So rich and creamy and full of flavor. Also they not only packed the cone with ice cream but put..."
sian quinn
"Best ice cream along the east coast! We had a sundae with the Cookie Dough, Chocolate Milk & Cookies, and Campfire flavors. It was delicious! 😋..."
Brooke Huntsman
"The donini is amazing. Perfect amount of soft crunch on the outside and cold ice cream on the..."
Toni Mac
"Wow! Freshly-made ice cream, family -owned, and AMAZING dessert options. Friendly folks, too! We brought some West Coast visitors, some locals (..."
Tim Marusich
"This was a pleasant surprise after lunch. The ice cream was super creamy and really fresh. The brownie sundae was..."
dennis kolecki
"I love ice cream. Really and truly. My favorite part of the northeast is how readily available it is. Harbor Creamery is far from the best. But..."
Shawn Ward
"Awesome place with options for everyone. They have a great selection of regular flavors and toppings and also offer some non-dairy sorbets. It's in a..."
Stephanie Wallenstein
"Excellent ice cream! Lots of flavors to choose..."
Bob
Mission Oak Grill
Mission Oak Grill
89/100 (1949 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
American
Bar
American
Vegan Options
Bar
Steakhouse
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Dinner
Late Night
Beef
Calamares
Salmon
Lobster
Crab Cake
Pasta
Chowder
Salad
Tapas
Clam Chowder
Fish Taco
Chili
Tacos
Mac and cheese
Haddock
Crab
Saltimbocca
Filet Mignon
Scallops
Cheeseburger
Ice Cream
Churrasco
Swordfish
Oyster
Burger
French onion soup
Ribs
Calamari
Cakes
Risotto
Lamb
Mussels
Shrimp
Fish
Tuna
Sit down
Bar
American
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Reservations
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Seating
Private Dining
Table Service
Accepts American Express
Wheelchair Accessible
Street Parking
Accepts Discover
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Dinner
Late Night
Mid-range
"We tried to book a reservation but they were all full! When got there the place was packed and it was a bit stuffy so we asked to eat on the patio..."
Renee Parent Vass
"Absolutely amazing from start to finish. I took my boyfriend here for his birthday dinner. The experience was top notch from the beginning. The..."
Beth Crowley
"Perfection from start to finish. Cocktails, soups, entrees & dessert were top-notch, and Nick our server was a pure..."
Kristine Garrity O'Brien
"First time, nice and clean great atmosphere food was delicious, I got the chicken saltimbocca to die for my husband got The Oscar and oh my, dessert..."
Dawn Silva Coco
"Well let's see.... The food is excellent and the atmosphere is spectacular. Try the Poutine, Short Rib Empanadas, Mussells, Thai Ribs, Cheeseburger..."
Carl Matthew
"Nice place with great food choices. The building used to be a church. Interesting conversion of space, windows, and walls. Cool vibe; check it..."
Michael Costa
"Such a fun place with a wonderful bar, fabulous cocktails, and food is so delicious!! One of my favorite..."
Linda Taylor Knight
"Awesome food and dessert the atmosphere was great the people around me were friendly highly recommend the..."
Mel Drew
"Great Old fashions...Brazilian dish with skirt steak and yuca fries was outstanding...server was attentive and very pleasant...highly recommend...."
Christo Lyons
"Great atmosphere, friendly attentive waitress and food was cooked perfectly and so tasty. Definately worth going..."
Catherine Charron Pearson
"We just hosted a cocktail party upstairs at Steeple Hall this weekend and it couldn't have been more perfect! The venue was just what we were looking..."
Heather Grzybinski
"Really tasty food. Ordered mac and cheese with grilled shrimp, shrimp was a little to charred for my liking and a bit salty, but the mac and cheese..."
Im Russia
"The staff was super friendly. The atmosphere is very nice. It’s upscale feeling but not too upscale. Keeping it casual too! The food was all fresh,..."
John P
"Great dinner at Mission Oak Grill in Newburyport. Easy parking. Fast service. Excellent selection of food. Beautiful bar too! Loved the..."
Mark Zajac
"Thank you to Nikolas and the staff at Mission Oak Grill! We had a wonderful rehearsal dinner. The food was delicious and the staff was fantastic!..."
Karen Noggle
"Great spot! We had a rehearsal dinner upstairs and everything was perfect. The food and service was amazing all around! Definitely recommend if you..."
Patrick McNamara
Simply Sweet
Simply Sweet
89/100 (110 ratings)
Dessert
Ice Cream
Takeout
Cheap Eats
"My friend and I only visited the 🍨 ice-cream part. Very small inside. Facemasks are not required to enter. Service was good! I had the German..."
Stephen Priest
"Great selections of homemade chocolates,fudge and novelty items as well as old time sweets. The staff is friendly and Wendy does a great job of..."
Tony Koumantzelis
"First time visiting the area, but came for the ice cream. The flavors were abundant! Ordered pistachio while granddaughters ordered 2 others flavors..."
Kathryn McCormick
"One of my favorite places to go when I'm in Newburyport. Many flavors of ice cream and even ice cream for..."
frog frog
"We actually went ti the ice.cream store to the left this time, but we have visited Simply Sweet before! Who doesn't like good confectionery!? How..."
Eric Gregg
"The Best Chocolate and Best Costumer Service!!! I was in Newburyport yesterday and this small and cute Candy Store made my day. The store is..."
Jousy Lins
"Stopped in with my wife on a day trip for my 50th and purchased a 1 lb box. They have a great selection for everyone to choose from. Lots of..."
Steve B
Dolce Freddo Gelator
Dolce Freddo Gelator
86/100 (341 ratings)
Dessert
Ice Cream
Gelato
Sit down
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Cheap Eats
"Great location and fantastic flavors! My favorite is pistachio. If you don’t see it outside ask for it. They might have in the back. A huge variety..."
Andrea Li
"Sea Salt Caramel Gelato is MOUTHWATERING deliciousness! My favorite treat in New England by..."
J
"We love this place! We come here from very far because of their amazing gelato. The staff is very accommodating, very friendly and never lets us..."
diana denisyuk
"Downtown location, great ice-cream, wide selection what else you need? Get a scoop and..."
Tom J
"Simply THE creamiest, most delicious gelato in the Boston area, punto, Basta! Puts gelato sold in the North End to shame. Not even close. Owned and..."
David Gray
"Ive never had gelato but this was so good! Highly recommend the caramel brownie..."
Natalia Pena
"Excellent Gelato and sorbeto. Good selection of flavors from the typical chocolate, to some good creative flavors like "Almond Joy". The prices are..."
Jeff Laurenza
"HUGE scoops for gelato and delicious! Mango sorbet was fantastic. Benches out front and in the plaza next..."
Greta Lofgren
Hodgies Too Of Newburyport
Hodgies Too Of Newburyport
83/100 (505 ratings)
Dessert
Cafe
Cafe
Mint Chip Ice-Cream
Kitty Size Cone Chocolate Chip
Almond Joy and Sugar Cone
Ice Cream
Moosetracks
Chocolate Ice-Cream with Sugar Cone
Rum Raisin Ice-Cream with Sugar Cone
Café
"Good 🍨 ice-cream, service was friendly but a bit slow. They are 🧤 handling online orders as well as people who arrive, and there were a..."
Stephen Priest
"The no sugar added ice cream is quite good and creamy. It's worth the ride just for the NSA ice cream. The staff is exceptional and Worthy of..."
Anthony C. Adamopoulos
"Always great ice cream 😻 young people with manners are hired and this is a wonderful thing! They are required to have customer service skills!!!..."
Elizabeth Arthurs
"We stopped in for a post-covid vaccine treat. There were many flavors ... so hard to choose. Beware, the portion size is enormous. We got the..."
Wayne Geiser
"If you like Hodgies you will like Hodgies Too ;) If your in either area of one, stop on bye and get your ice cream buzz on..."
John Petralia
"There ice cream is always great with many flavors to pick..."
Peter Young
"Friendly, rather fast, and great ice cream. Keep in mind that their large is 5 huge scoops, with their smalls having 3 scoops. Definitely getting a..."
Abigail
Tuscan Sea Grill & Bar
Tuscan Sea Grill & Bar
76/100 (1243 ratings)
Restaurants
Seafood
Italian
Bar
Bar
Pub
Pub
Seafood
Italian
Tuscan
Central-Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Crab
Clams
Mussels
Tuna
Salmon
Crab Cake
Lobster Roll
Swordfish
Octopus
Ice Cream
Gelato
Shrimp
Lobster
Pesto
Pasta
Fish
Salad
Pub
Italian
Tuscan
Seafood
Central-Italian
Bar
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range