Reviews Buzzy's New York Style Pizza

Zomato
Veronica Saha
+3.5
I just had the jalapeños poppers and the mozzarella sticks as I was in a hurry so I just took them with me,it was deep golden fried with nice amount of crunch and melted cheese inside which I love always!!!
May 18, 2016
Zomato
Anthony Nalli
+3.5
This is absolutely our favorite pizza and wings place anywhere. The pizza is thin crust, with a delicious tomato sauce. The wings are typical Buffalo wings and are meaty and cooked to perfection. Buttery garlic is her favorite, mine is a combination of buttery garlic and medium which adds a very slight kick of (probably something like) Frank's Red Hot. Our pizza of choice is simple pepperoni.


UPDATE (May 2017): We haven't been in the area in a while and decided on a return to Buzzy's. The pizza was good (though sadly not as great as we had gotten used to) and the wings had barely any sauce on them. Service was good but we left somewhat disappointed.
Mar 06, 2016
Zomato
Bearandbu
+4.5
Great service, good food.... Buzzy's was recommended by a co-worker. There are quite a few reviews on Urbanspoon complaining about service, so here's a log of my first visit (I live in Buffalo). I'm writing this in real time and will edit later:
6:37 I walk in restaurant, only 1 empty table in dining room.
6:40 seated by hostess.
6:44 waitress named Mallory takes my order of diet coke, small salad, 10 wings extra crispy, medium sauce.
6:46 drink arrives.
6:48 salad arrives - no surprises - typical large side salad with fresh, crisp iceberg lettuce and bland hothouse tomatoes, decent blue cheese dressing, crunchy croutons, a few black olives.
7:06 wings arrive. They are crispy, as ordered. Celery and carrots cost extra at 75 cents (boooooo!) but I get 8 large pieces of each veggie. Wings are medium sized, mild-to-medium in heat, and taste fresh. Wings have a thin sauce with a moderate butter flavor (akin to Anchor Bar).
7:25 waitress returns. She asks how things are. She is quite pleasant. Takes empty plates away.
7:27 check arrives, waitress takes money.
7:31 change arrives.
On a scale of 0 to 10, service is a 9; maybe I lucked-out with Mallory, but all I see when I look around the dining room are smiling faces. This place, due to its location, is the UN of restaurants. Lot's of shoppers from the north, out-of-towners staying in nearby hotels, foreign tourists, etc.
On a scale of 0 to 10 (a 2 being the current crap that Anchor Bar serves, a 9 being Elmo's or Buffalo Tap Room) wings were a solid 7 (despite not being a fan of thin, buttery sauce).
This is a pleasant experience; I over-tip Mallory ($4.50 on a $17.50 check)...she is a pro and worth every penny. I will definitely visit Buzzy's again if I am out this way, but I'm not likely to make a special trip..
Jul 01, 2014
Zomato
Mal
+4.5
Great pizza and wings!. My family loves to stop at Buzzy's for dinner after crossing the border to do some shopping. We get a tray of pizza and wings every time, and haven't been disappointed! We have yet to find a local place that compares.
May 28, 2013
Zomato
Canadian Foodie
+4.5
Great pizza and wings!. Our go-to restaurant in Niagara Falls, NY. Pizza is delicious, the wings are tasty and the prices are reasonable. Service is good. Yes, they can get busy but it is worth the wait. We have never been disappointed.
Oct 01, 2012
Zomato
CW
+4.5
Delicious "NY-style" pizza, but don't be in a hurry. After taking our order at 2PM on a Monday afternoon with only two other tables, it took over 1/2 an hour to receive our pizza. Skip the garlic bread with mozzarella, and save it for a bigger pizza. Chewy crust, not too thin and held the toppings well. A two-topping large pizza was around $15. Wish I could return for more but was only passing through town.
Sep 28, 2012
Zomato
Casimone
+4.5
Mmmmm. If you like greasy pizza then you would love this. I'm from Toronto. Every time we cross the border we go to this place to pick up wings and pizza. I haven't had the wings but I hear that they are great.
Aug 13, 2012
Zomato
NotAdelard
+4.5
Anytime I'm going through the falls and am gonna eat, I stop. Pizza's , Calzone and wings are as good as it gets.
Aug 10, 2012
Zomato
Alia
+4.5
Every time, I go there, always like my first time! The dough is phenomenally prepared, topping are good, always feel full afterwards, good service, good atmosphere. The only think I do not like...is that I live in Amherst and I know they won't deliver it there! Otherwise great pizza! Recommend it to anyone who likes good quality food!
Aug 09, 2012
Zomato
Sharon Marie
+4.5
Served a very very soupy pizza
We had to wait a good 15 minutes till it set up enough to serve.
The wings were very good.
Aug 06, 2012
Zomato
Randy Williams
+4.5
Real Pizza- Real Service. The best place to get a pizza in Niagara Falls
Jul 22, 2011
Zomato
Tammy Tipton
+4.5
We got the Bravo pizza and wings. The pizza was tremendous! All the toppings were awesome, and the dough was one of the best we ever had!
Jun 07, 2011
Zomato
Alan Bedenko
+4.5
Very good NY style thin crust pies. Among the best in WNY.
Nov 14, 2010
Zomato
Bart
+4.5
GREAT PIZZA/WINGS. We travel from outside Toronto to go to Buzzy,s. On a whim Sat. afternoon we will dive to Buzzy,s for pizza & wings. They are the best from Toronto to Buffalo
Feb 12, 2010
Zomato
Jennifer
+4.5
Love the food here, especially their pizza. It's usually the first restaurant we go to when we come to town.
Jul 14, 2009
Zomato
Alan Stockings
+4.5
One of the best pizza places in the area! Great food, and delivery too!
Jun 30, 2009
Zomato
Matthew Lockhart
+4.5
Best ever. I come all the way from haimtin ontario for the pizza and wings best food ever.
Apr 01, 2009
Zomato
Ian Walpole
+4.5
Best Thin Crust Pizza!. What more can I say, go there, order a large pizza, take home and enjoy. Each bite is bursting with flavor, could eat a large myself!!
Dec 29, 2008
Zomato
Buffalo Eats
+4.5
Thanks to the ranking system on Urbanspoon I found out about Buzzy's a few months ago. I noticed it had a large amount of votes and some people were commenting about how it's the best pizza in Western New York. I don't make my way out to Niagara Falls very often, in fact aside from occasional trips to Clifton Hill when I was younger and shopping at the Outlet Mall, I don't think I've ever really hung out in the area. Recently, I was re-reminded of Buzzy's existence when I read Buffalo Spree's Pizza Showdown and was convinced by Alan Bedenko that I needed to try it out. Alli and I found ourselves doing some last minute bridal party shopping last week and since it's a rare occurrence for me to be in that area, I decided it was either now or never (or at least not for another 6 months). Here's how the meal went… It seems like asking people on twitter for re
Jun 08, 2011
Clicca per espandere