"I usually don't write reviews, but my experience at the Island Mermaid was outstanding. Between the food, the service, and the view it was..."
Travis D'Arienzo
"The only thing that surpasses the quality of the food is the quality of the service. The staff operates with a level of professionalism not usually..."
Peggy Murphy
"I thought the food was delicious and the service was great. We did have to wait a little but it is a summer Sunday on Fire Island! The steamers and..."
Robin Katz Rabinowitz
"This place was fantastic. Food, service, great. Hostess Victoria Wisdom is a goddess. Entertainment by Miss Caitlin Bell, accompanied by Andy was..."
Douglas Marange
"My favorate on Fire Island. Outstanding view. Always a terrific meal. Broad menu. Excellent crew. Checks all the boxes. You're cheating yourself if..."
John McLoughlin
"Best burger I've ever had. The pomegranate martini was..."
Lorraine LiVigni Kennedy
"Came here for my friends’ birthday and had the most incredible meal. Everything was perfect from the vibes to the service to the tasty food. I..."
abby gardner
"They’ve continued to make improvements to the Mermaid and it shows. Now they have a permanent outdoor tent that would be great for inclement..."
Windows on the Sea
"Had (still having as I’m sitting dockside) an amazing meal. Wonderful food and service. Very kid friendly. Attentive and caring staff. Mussels and..."
Dr. Eric Turk
"We sat on right by the water, which was beautiful. The service was on point, you always felt you were taken care of. We ordered the tuna stack..."
ashley popek
"Food was good. Went on a Monday, Our first two appetizers of choice were not available. Good atmosphere, The salmon and Brussel sprouts were..."
joe balestra
"The service was incredible, unmatched vibes we came here for my birthday dinner and did not regret it. Staff treated us so right, definitely get the..."
Mia Deutsch
"Scott, the owner, took such care of us and all the food was lovely. The bus boy was conversant and conscientious. We loved our server Victoria! She..."
Lynne Sadusky
"Island Mermaid is our Fire Island Favorite, always consistently good. Definitely make a reservation, especially on weekends, they get busy. Great..."
Travis Nicholson
"A group of us came this weekend to celebrate my cousins bachelorette. Everything from the service to the food was perfect. Compliments to the chef..."
Brianna
"Such a great experience! The food was delicious especially their chicken wings. If you’re in fire island you must stop..."
Glenda Cordero
"I have been here a few times now and me and my family have loved it here every time. The service was great and amazing food to match. I will..."
Mark Davis
"The restaurant is amazing!!! Best service and atmosphere if you want an amazing dinner and vibes this is the spot. Good for friends family and just..."
Eliana Mischel
"Had a great time food was good Jesus was very attentive drinks were fun Scott suggested good one bailey's and club soda my fave and Ava and Finn kept..."
mari almond
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes