Went In for the first time ever this week! The couple who owns the store do it all and the are the kindest, genuine people. Cookies were yummy. Comparable prices to a Crumble cookie but so much better. We got a dozen for about $26. We were not huge fans of OCNJ but the cookies were a favorite!
Every year we go to the Ocean City NJ shore we spend time feasting on the various culinary delights. Crazy Susan’s cookies are one of our favorites. They have a large variety of cookies and it’s hard for me to identify a bad one. My personal favorite is likely the Turtle Caramel cookies. But you really cannot go wrong with any. And Susan is a wonderful person and does everything she can do to support her customers.
Crazy Susan makes some amazing cookie varieties! You don't want to leave the beach without paying her shop a visit. 😋
Crazy Susan's cookies are crazy delicious! I love all of them. The butterfinger one, the sugar one, the Reese's one, but my favorite is the Mayor. The Mayor is a fudge cookie mixed with Snicker Bar and Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup and topped with a Rolo candy. It's delicious. I went to OC for vacation. Can't wait to come next year and get more! :)
Honestly the best cookies I’ve ever had!
I ordered a cookie cake for my granddaughter‘s 15th birthday. The whole family absolutely loved it! Susan was wonderful. We also tried a couple more of her specialty cookies and they were amazing! Thank you so much Susan for the excellent service and delicious cookie cake!
Try the “hot chocolate” chocolate chip cookie. So soft and moist and melts in your mouth. Tastes just like hot chocolate. Chocolate chip cookie lovers will not be disappointed. It’s out of this world!
Just had THE best cookies in my entire life. So good I had to post about it. 💖 Crazy Susan's is adorable. The inside smelled out-of-this-world delicious as soon as I walked in. Crazy Susan was there taking orders and giving helpful info to her customers. The most friendly woman ever. I immediately loved her. My personal favorite was the lemon sandwich cookie 😍🤤😍🤤 I can't wait to make more trips there whenever I get in town!
![5]( "Recensione")
Susan Holender: customer, Ocean City, NJ
Eleven years ago, my husband and I discovered Crazy Susan Cookies in Ocean City, New Jersey. Once you walk into her store, you never want to leave. It is our favorite place to visit at the shore over and over again.
Before that time, we tried cookies from all over the country. They were just OK. After tasting Crazy Susan Cookies, we realized that nothing could compare! Her cookies are the best we have ever tasted because she only uses the finest ingredients. With her secret recipe, Crazy Susan makes every cookie by hand. She also has an incredible assortment and variety of cookies, which makes it difficult to pick a favorite.
We buy them by the dozens; we ship them to others and ourselves as special gifts. When cookie gifts arrive, the gift box is individually wrapped with gorgeous tissue paper and ribbons. They are perfection. All our friends and family agree!
Crazy Susan is sweet, kind and has a great sense of humor. We fell in love with her and her entire staff and family.
We cannot get enough of her cookies,
We want to thank Crazy Susan for making us so very happy all year long.
Please support this business! With all the ice cream and pastry stores around, we were excited to find this place and give something different a try. The aroma of the store was heavenly. Although we took far too long trying to decide which cookies to buy, the staff could not have been friendlier. The turtle cookie was our favorite; very decadent. But don't underestimate the oatmeal raisin cookie. I know, right? I don't know what kind of magic is in that recipe, but it was so flavorful and almost cake-like. Will definitely be back soon!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes